 me1212 join:2008-11-20 Pleasant Hill, MO | reply to Krisnatharok
Re: New benchmarks for th 8350 and 3570k/3770k. Weird results. The 7078 puzzled me too, I know he has a 680 in his office he could have used, but he did give away the 7970. Still even a mid range cpu shouldn't make a difference like that. Not that I'm an intel fanboy, heck I use amd's more core cpus on my code compiling box.
I'm guessing he did black mesa source because its free. |
|
|
|
 KrisnatharokCaveat EmptorPremium join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit kudos:7 | It's still at odds with what everyone else has gotten in their tests. There are three possibilities:
1) His testing is "better" in terms of consistency and methodology than all the other review sites out there. 2) There is a conspiracy by everyone else to push Intel CPUs even though they are subpar. 3) His testing results are flawed.
I am going with #3 if they can't be verified by anyone else out there. -- Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety. |
|
 me1212 join:2008-11-20 Pleasant Hill, MO | I think it may be 3 aswell, based on what I've read on his site he didn't do a reinstall when he switched cpu+mobo and he did the amd first. Just switched the hardware and installed the drivers. |
|
 KrisnatharokCaveat EmptorPremium join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit kudos:7 | lolwut? He just stuck the SSD into a completely new system? |
|
 me1212 join:2008-11-20 Pleasant Hill, MO | Ether that or swapped out the cpu and mobo, possibly ram too. Ether way, just why would one do that? |
|
 KrisnatharokCaveat EmptorPremium join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit kudos:7 | He's cutting corners, I guess.
I could see pulling out the GPU, as that would make no difference, but he shouldn't be moving the SSD between systems--I'm surprised the OS install even worked and didn't detect new hardware and shut down and ask for a new license key.
If he is going to cut corners, he has no business making claims or publishing benchmarks. The goal is in testing is to remove as many variables as possible. That usually means a fully-functioning, fully-patched system running the latest stable version of drivers.
Shifting hardware around like that only increases the entropy he's introducing into his systems. -- Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety. |
|
 me1212 join:2008-11-20 Pleasant Hill, MO | If he wasn't using a legit copy of windows 7 it may not have asked him for new key. |
|
 KrisnatharokCaveat EmptorPremium join:2009-02-11 Earth Orbit kudos:7 | That's speculation at this point. I'll just mark these results as "suspect" and move along. |
|
 me1212 join:2008-11-20 Pleasant Hill, MO | I'm not trying to say he was, I'm just saying that some cracked copies don't ask. |
|