Talk > Anime/Sci Fi > [Sci-Fi] ST vs BSG

[Sci-Fi] ST vs BSG

Nice animation. They got the viper weapon sound wrong, and a little too much rotation going on, but well done.

However this is not really Star Trek versus BSG, more like ST vs the Cylons.

reply to Nightwing
OMFGZ that was "fun" if even a little overdone, but yeah I clapped towards the end Nifty! Watched it twice, Fullscreen.

reply to Nightwing
That was great! Loved it!

reply to Nightwing
Interesting. The Starfleet ship models were pretty nice, but there were so many other problems overall that it was tough to enjoy.
--
When you are leaving.. heaven is a distance not a place. --Carissas Weird

reply to Nightwing
That was great.
Kind of odd to see the Galactica get it's ass kicked like that, but I guess shields do trump armor.
The mass jump to warp speed by the fleet was a cool bit.

Thanks, Nightwing.
--
"Every normal man must be tempted, at times, to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats." - H. L. Mencken

Ain't no way a Federation ship could hang in a fight like that.

Still, decent job. Only thing missing was seeing the Yamato warp in and wipe everyone out with the Wave Motion Gun. Tho I may be biased.........

reply to Nightwing
I'll have to check this out when I get home.

reply to Nightwing
The defiant could take on a fleet of Base Stars... Of course the Defiant has Ablative Plot Armor and Plot Shields.
--
[65 Arcanist]Filan(High Elf) Zone: Broadband Reports

reply to Alpha Phoenix

reply to Nightwing
Wow, what a rush. That was great!! Did anybody catch the ending after the credits?

Apparently, after that last ship got away, the Cylons are rebuilding their fleet.
--
Illegal aliens have always been a problem in the United States. Ask any Indian. Robert Orben

reply to Nightwing
Pretty good for a fan made mini-movie but I thought the enterprise alone could take out the entire Cylon force.
--
Add a signature here

reply to Nightwing
I enjoyed it. Like Rook008, it was hard to see the Galactica get its ass kicked like that. But it was outnumbered 3-1. Then the cylons were out numbered. But if it was just one federation ship I am not sure it could do a lot better. Sure the shields help but even they can get worn down. Made me want to see a shadow ship from B5 come in just to see it slice apart ships.

Anyway it was pretty cool to watch. Thx Nightwing
--
Cry "Havoc!" and let slip the dogs of war

reply to PhoenixDown

Re: [Sci-Fi] ST vs BSG

reply to PhoenixDown

reply to Nightwing
I find the lack of story disturbing.
It should be mentioned that this is Lorene Greene's BSG, Not Edward James Olmos'. I was hopping to see some raiders.
There was no thought of tactics either. Even the ancient tin cans would have done a better job of defending themselves.
Camera work needed more thought. Looks like they were trying to use the camera type work from the new BSG but forgot there had to be someone there to take the film(as did the new BSG from time to time, I believe).
And where were the raiders when the Starfleet ships arrived?

And there was one Starfleet ship I did not recognize.

I can only give 2.5 Cylons
--
"We are the only intelligent people in the universe." Arrogance 3:10

reply to Nightwing
I saw what to me was ST TNG Enterprise from the series and the newer one from TNG movies. The Defiant and the U.S.S. Nautilus NCC-90101 is the almond shaped one that took a hit. Am I right?

I liked it but it was a bit long and drawn out. They seemed to put more detail into the Star Trek ships as well.
--
"When the power of love overcomes the love of power, the world will know peace."
-Jimi Hendrix

reply to captokita

said by captokita:

Ain't no way a Federation ship could hang in a fight like that.

Still, decent job. Only thing missing was seeing the Yamato warp in and wipe everyone out with the Wave Motion Gun. Tho I may be biased.........

said by Rook008:

Kind of odd to see the Galactica get it's ass kicked like that, but I guess shields do trump armor.

That or phasers and photon torpedoes don't pack the punch you would think....

reply to Fir_Na_Tine