dslreports logo
site
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc

spacer




how-to block ads


Search Topic:
uniqs
29
share rss forum feed


Blackbird
Built for Speed
Premium
join:2005-01-14
Fort Wayne, IN
kudos:3
Reviews:
·Frontier Communi..

3 recommendations

reply to norwegian

Re: Interesting Article About Kaspersky

said by norwegian:

One has to ask the question, what of people in the US that worked for 3 letter agencies and post regularly here, do they get excluded from this filter of IT people who worked closely with governments? ... We all have views of our own.

If Kaspersky was only "posting regularly" here, I'd not be in the least concerned about his 3-letter agency associations, nor would I be about anyone else having 3-letter associations with whatever country... because whatever is dispensed in this forum is only opinion, like yours or mine. But that's neither the issue nor the risk about which I'm concerned. 3-letter-agency posters here (whomever they might be, if any) don't, to my knowledge, head up and guide the efforts of antivirus firms whose presences are widespread on large numbers of Western computers. Antivirus software enjoys a special place on systems, is granted special privileges by users, and works largely out of sight... it necessarily must retain a higher level of trust, both the software and those writing/updating it. The article raises some potentially very serious issues, IMO, involving possible FSB influence or association with Kaspersky and potentially his company's products; his denials referenced in redwolf_98's post are now on record as well. Unfortunately, the question remains for those of us "outside" as to who/what to believe. From my perspective, there's just not enough material evidence (yet) in play to draw a clear conclusion or risk assessment. As to what best one should or should not do, given the issues raised and the denial on record, it's indeed one's own decision to make.

As for me, I will continue listening attentatively to what Kaspersky says about many things related to malware and AVs (he is, after all, an recognized and very knowledgeable expert), but I will not put his company's software on my systems.
--
“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money.” A. de Tocqueville


Rebrider
Been There Done That
Premium
join:2000-11-23
++ 1


norwegian
Premium
join:2005-02-15
Outback
reply to Blackbird
What I'm trying to say:

EG:
You have an opinion on this because he was employed as a cryptographer by the government, and has ties, this you are concerned over.
I won't debate that.

Microsoft has big ties with the government of it's home too.
ahulett See Profile here has ties with Microsoft and is employed by them and tends to err to the side of his employer - he would be mad not to.

-------

Where can you pick the line between facts and hearsay for any software?
Do you pick open source software only due to it being open to the public, or closed code because you think your data is safer?

We are allowed opinions, and at least half of the posts here are opinions not facts in these types of forums.
I'm just surprised when such an obviously educated person gains a tunnel vision type opinion.
Where do you draw the line.

--
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing - Edmund Burke



Blackbird
Built for Speed
Premium
join:2005-01-14
Fort Wayne, IN
kudos:3
Reviews:
·Frontier Communi..

3 recommendations

said by norwegian:

... I'm just surprised when such an obviously educated person gains a tunnel vision type opinion.
Where do you draw the line.

My "tunnel vision," as you call it, has been shaped by having been a "Cold Warrior" for a fair number of years. I know what 3-letter agencies on both sides of that divide were (and are) capable of. I strongly believe that I'd much rather be on this side than on that side, for what I believe are still very good reasons - even though this side does some things I'm very opposed to. I also believe that 3-letter people rarely, if ever, change their connections, loyalties, practices, or ways of thinking even after "leaving" the profession. Hence I am under no illusions about Mr. Putin, a long-time KGB staffer himself, particularly as I watch what is evolving in the former Soviet Union under his leadership.

I am likewise under no illusions about the FSB and SVR, both split from the KGB and inheriting its staffers, nor about their continuing objectives. The FSB is not the FBI, nor does it operate under anything approaching the same kind of restrictions or constraints. Any organization that has close links or ties to the FSB or Putin did not forge them by the usual kind of bid/contractural arrangements generally followed in the West... that's simply not how State Security in Russia operates. If I'm made aware that an organization or its leadership has signficant links to FSB or SVR, then the potential (and hostile) security risks are simply higher than I choose to run, either now or in some future scenario. My concern lies not just with trusting current software and its "cleanliness", but with the integrity of future automatic signature and program updates that I must allow an AV to obtain and activate on my systems, largely unsupervised.
--
“The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money.” A. de Tocqueville


Tom_Tome

@rr.com
Interesting, I was a "Cold War Warrior" for a number of years as well yet trust Russia over China a country that no doubt has Mfg. a large portion of the parts in your computer. If not Mfg. in China in countries with close ties to China.

It does not matter what 3 letter agencies you throw out there they are all out to get away with whatever they can and generally do especially in the US and Russia.


norwegian
Premium
join:2005-02-15
Outback
reply to Blackbird
said by Blackbird:

My "tunnel vision," as you call it, has been shaped by having been a "Cold Warrior" for a fair number of years.

Fair enough, then your opinion is a legitimate one, and to be honest, I've enjoyed your comments extensively here, so will say no more.

However, while it might sound like I was having a dig, it was an attempt to highlight programming etc of all nations and work ethics and the software of any company in any country. You could also say the same about tradesmen too, they are good or bad, or somewhere in between, how do you know without experience or knowledge on these.

Still it was quite a good write up all the same, and I enjoyed it, and will have a more in-depth read later.

Cheers for the post John.

--
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing - Edmund Burke