 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | [Connectivity] Connection turns on and off for a few second -- b I'm not sure this is the right forum for this question; if not, please let me know and I'll post elsewhere.
I have Comcast HSI. I have a Motorola Surfboard SB5120 modem which I own. I have a business-related Juniper box that plugs into the modem. My Linksys E4200 plugs into the Juniper and then the computers on the network plug into the Linksys.
For the past few days, I've found that my internet connectivity has been turning off for a few seconds and then reconnecting. In normal usage, I probably wouldn't even notice it, but I use a business program that runs from the cloud and it stops and notifies me each time it disconnects and reconnects.
I am trying to isolate the problem. I've called Comcast and they say there's no problem with my service. I've power cycled all above mentioned devices. I have now bypassed both the Juniper and the Linksys router and have my system connected directly to the modem and the problem continues. I have also noticed that the modem's status lights do not change when connectivity goes out.
Does this mean the modem is likely bad (it is by far the oldest component involved)? If so, what should I buy to replace it?
Thanks. |
|
 pflogBueller? Bueller?Premium,MVM join:2001-09-01 El Dorado Hills, CA kudos:3 | Re: [Connectivity] Connection turns on and off for a few second Please start here: »Comcast High Speed Internet FAQ »How To Get Help!
In particular, it would be good to see the modem's signal levels, traceroute/ping/pingplotter results, etc. -- "I drank what?" -Socrates |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL |  Signal levels |  Pingplotter results |
I am in Chicago, IL, problem described above. Issue seems to be constant but only for a few seconds at a time.
Modem is Motorola SB5120: Software Version: SB5120-2.19.0.16-SCM00-NOSH Hardware Version: 4
Other home networking describe above.
Firewall/Anti-virus is Norton Security Suite Version 20.2.0.19 from Comcast.
Signal levels and pingplotter results are above.
Please let me know if any other information is needed.
Thank you. |
|
|
|
 pflogBueller? Bueller?Premium,MVM join:2001-09-01 El Dorado Hills, CA kudos:3 | Your downstream SNR is quite low (32 dB). It is quite likely that it is fluctuating enough that your modem is losing sync.
You should call tech support and have them come out to investigate the signal.
Is the cable modem behind any splitter(s)? -- "I drank what?" -Socrates |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | No splitters behind cable modem. The cable comes through the wall of the house directly into the modem.
So, you think it could be a Comcast problem rather than the modem going? |
|
 pflogBueller? Bueller?Premium,MVM join:2001-09-01 El Dorado Hills, CA kudos:3 | Looks like something you need to have Comcast come out and investigate, yes. -- "I drank what?" -Socrates |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | Thanks, I'll get on it then. |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | Comcast was here today. After checking inside the tech went outside and looked at the connections. He replaced all of them reporting that they looked "nasty". All seems well now.
I am also inclined to replace my modem. I presently have a Motorola SB5120 which I own.
I was looking at the Motorola SB6141 -- I am on Blast -- will I benefit additionally from a DOCSIS 3 modem? |
|
 pflogBueller? Bueller?Premium,MVM join:2001-09-01 El Dorado Hills, CA kudos:3 | Yes, a Docsis 3 modem would be a good idea. Even if you're on a lower plan, it can still benefit you by spreading things across multiple channels (assuming your CMTS is D3). This means you're less likely to experience issues during peak times.
»Re: DOCSIS 3.0 Available in Valparaiso, IN -- "I drank what?" -Socrates |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | I think I spoke too fast that everything was working again -- my service just blinked out again for a few seconds (I can only tell so easily because I'm running a VPN which notifies me as soon as the connection is out).
I am going to order the SB6141 now. We do have D3 here in Chicago as far as I know. |
|
 pflogBueller? Bueller?Premium,MVM join:2001-09-01 El Dorado Hills, CA kudos:3 | Can you post your signal levels now, post-visit from the tech? -- "I drank what?" -Socrates |
|
 DanM64 join:2013-01-10 Mokena, IL 2 edits | reply to Cyndee All of the Chicago area is DOCSIS 3.0. I'm on the Romeoville headend- I have 8 downstream channels and 3 upstream (I'm pretty sure the entire Chicago area has 8/3). You should notice a difference with the 6141 since you're on Blast- you old modem's single channel capability is barely fast enough to keep up with the Blast package's PowerBoost download speed 30Mb/s. With the channel bonding not only should it be much easier to hit your PB top speed, you won't notice as much congestion either. |
|
 andyrossPremium,MVM join:2003-05-04 Schaumburg, IL | reply to Cyndee Can you post the modem logs? If it only goes out for a few seconds, you could be getting DCC's (Dynamic Channel Change). Since you have an older D2 modem with only one channel, Comcast may occasionally tell it to change channels to help balance the load. That can take a few seconds for the modem itself. Some software may take longer to retry. |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | reply to pflog
 New Signal Levels |
The only thing that looks really different from before is Power Levels.
And, other than that one quick outage Friday afternoon, the connection has been solid since.
I think I will still get a new modem though. |
|
 | Ew. Still not liking those signals and SNR. |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | Will a new modem make a difference? |
|
 | Nope. The tech needs to fix them. |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL 1 edit | reply to andyross
 |  Modem Logs |
Here are the logos -- only shows the current day; don't know how helpful that is.
Your explanation about DCC's makes sense. Often I wouldn't even have noticed the connection go out except that I am running a Net Extender for a VPN that exits or I'm running a program in the Cloud that beeps whenever it doesn't have a connection. |
|
 andyrossPremium,MVM join:2003-05-04 Schaumburg, IL | The next time you notice the dead spot, check the log as soon as possible.
Also, if DCC's are the issue, then going to a newer D3 modem will help. Since they bond channels, they typically do not have to worry about DCC's. If you have a D3 modem that only does 4-down, it could get DCC's if it's in an area with more than 4 downstream available, but I don't know if that's ever done, yet. |
|
 Cyndee join:2001-02-03 Chicago, IL | It isn't possible to check to log as soon as the connection goes out. Normally I connect through a router. So to get to the logs I need to bypass the router and connect directly to the computer and reboot the modem to get a connection; I guess that wipes the log. I can't stay connected directly to the modem for any amount of time as my printers are all connected to the network and there are other users that need to be connected. |
|