dslreports logo
site
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc

spacer




how-to block ads


Search Topic:
uniqs
2970
share rss forum feed view:
normal


cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

[Masonry] Pouring concrete steps

Click for full size
I'm hoping to get the steps up to my front porch poured this weekend, if it doesn't rain. This is my design. I have most of the form done already. But I had a question about the work. I know after I pour and float the concrete, I let it sit for a bit (an hour or so?). Then I can take off the forms from the front of the risers and touch those up with a trowel.

My question is: can I do that with the side? Is there any point, while the concrete hasn't completely set, that I can take the form off the side to touch it up and make sure it's all smooth, without the whole thing collapsing?

Most of what I read says to wait a day before taking the form off the side. But I'm guessing that's too long to be able to do touch ups. By that point you'd need to parge the side if it's not perfect, no?

If I can't, I was thinking of putting a thin veneer on the inside of the form, over all the screw holes, so that the finish on the concrete comes out smoother.

Thoughts?

PrntRhd
Premium
join:2004-11-03
Fairfield, CA
Reviews:
·Comcast

[Masonry] Re: Pouring concrete steps

How much concrete work have you done before?
You want to use an edging tool on the steps to round the steps front edge, and you should use a broom or similar tool to make the steps no slip on the upper surface.
You can apply a sand/cement mix to make the sides more attractive after the forms are removed.



Ken
Premium,MVM
join:2003-06-16
Markle, IN
reply to cybersaga

If you take the form on the side off after 1 hour the bottom is likely to slump out. I'm not going to tell you how long you need to wait to take the side off, mainly because there isn't one correct answer. It depends on how wet the concrete is, air temp, humidity, etc...

One thing you can do that will help the finish look is run a palm sander all over the outside of the forms as soon as the concrete is all in. It's a poor man version of a concrete vibrator. Don't overdo it though, you should do the entire outside of the forms in 60-90 seconds max.



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..
reply to PrntRhd

said by PrntRhd:

How much concrete work have you done before?

Not much, but I've done a ton of reading, YouTube watching, and consulting with people who do know what they're talking about. This last question is my only unknown left.

said by PrntRhd:

You want to use an edging tool on the steps to round the steps front edge, and you should use a broom or similar tool to make the steps no slip on the upper surface.

Yes, that's all on my to-do list.


cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..
reply to Ken

said by Ken:

If you take the form on the side off after 1 hour the bottom is likely to slump out. I'm not going to tell you how long you need to wait to take the side off, mainly because there isn't one correct answer. It depends on how wet the concrete is, air temp, humidity, etc...

Yeah, I figured one hour wouldn't be nearly enough. I am planning to use the least amount of water possible to make sure I have the lowest slump possible.

Is there any way to check when is the right time, without actually taking it off?

Also, should I be waiting longer to take the form off the bottom step too? Or would a couple hours do for that one?

The temperature took a dive here as soon as September came. It'll probably be around 60-65 degrees when I do this.

said by Ken:

One thing you can do that will help the finish look is run a palm sander all over the outside of the forms as soon as the concrete is all in. It's a poor man version of a concrete vibrator. Don't overdo it though, you should do the entire outside of the forms in 60-90 seconds max.

Yes, that's a trick I picked up on YouTube that even my neighbour, who works with concrete, didn't know. He suggested the hammer. But thanks for the warning on overdoing it.


cowboyro
Premium
join:2000-10-11
Shelton, CT
reply to cybersaga

Different formulations of concrete will have different setting times. The correct answer is check for hardness in an inconspicuous place.



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

said by cowboyro:

The correct answer is check for hardness

How? Just push on it and see if it gives? Whack it with a hammer?


John Galt
Forward, March
Premium
join:2004-09-30
Happy Camp
kudos:5
reply to cybersaga

You're overestimating the rapidity with which concrete sets. It's not like one second it is fluid and the next second hardened. It's also dependent on the temperature, so cooler days give you more time to finish. When you're pouring, fill a small container like a cardboard box so you can press on the concrete to check on how it is setting without disturbing the main pour.

Concrete curing is a chemical process, not one where the concrete 'dries out". The entire mass will cure at the same rate. The exception is the immediate surface, which can lose water to evaporation on hot, sunny days.

Are you getting ready-mix or mixing on-site? The amount of water is critical and should be measured carefully, especially if you are on-site mixing.

said by PrntRhd:

You can apply a sand/cement mix to make the sides more attractive after the forms are removed.

This process is called "dry-sacking" and can provide a nice finished surface. It is easy to do and only requires a foam float and the drysack material.

If you want really smooth surfaces, you should have used MDO to build the forms. Since you have already built the forms, you should consider using a form release agent to facilitate the form removal without damaging the surface.
--
Many believe, but few will question...I decline to be blind.



cowboyro
Premium
join:2000-10-11
Shelton, CT
reply to cybersaga

Use a nail. Don't remove the forms if the nail goes in by hand.
Having done a similar project myself, the time needed was about 8-10hrs.
»Pouring concrete steps - DIY



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

1 recommendation

reply to John Galt

said by John Galt:

Are you getting ready-mix or mixing on-site? The amount of water is critical and should be measured carefully, especially if you are on-site mixing.

I'm mixing on site with a portable, electric mixer. I was planning on mixing two bags at a time, and measuring out the water for each mix to make sure the whole pour is consistent.

said by John Galt:

This process is called "dry-sacking" and can provide a nice finished surface.

Would that look ok if I did it the next day? What I'm trying to avoid is having it look like I patched it.

said by John Galt:

If you want really smooth surfaces, you should have used MDO to build the forms. Since you have already built the forms, you should consider using a form release agent to facilitate the form removal without damaging the surface.

Form release agent is already on my list. I'm using 2x10s for the risers (trimmed to size) and 1/4" MDF that I bent to shape for the bottom step. I have the supports for the MDF in place, but I haven't put the MDF in yet (I don't want to leave it out in the rain). I'm going to try to avoid putting screws in the inside of the MDF.

The side is plywood and has lots of screws going from the inside into the posts I drove into the ground. That's why it's the part I'm most worried about the finish.

said by cowboyro:

Use a nail. Don't remove the forms if the nail goes in by hand.

That's a great trick! Thank you!


StillLearn
Premium
join:2002-03-21
Streamwood, IL
reply to cybersaga

Are you planning to do a single pour for porch and steps?

If yes, will your form have horizontal boards above the step surfaces to contain the concrete?

You should video the pour, and we hope it does not become a Youtube hit.



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

said by StillLearn:

Are you planning to do a single pour for porch and steps?

No, the porch is already there. It has a cold cellar underneath. We had to break up the old steps that were there when we waterproofed the basement.

said by StillLearn:

You should video the pour, and we hope it does not become a Youtube hit.

Ha! Maybe I'll take pictures along the way.


John Galt
Forward, March
Premium
join:2004-09-30
Happy Camp
kudos:5

Post a photo now.



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON

1 recommendation

Sure I'll take a picture when I get home tonight.


Trimox

join:2012-09-24
Anywhere

If you do have the palm sander for vibrating you can always just get some discs to smooth out any imperfections after you take the side form off

Like these or what ever size you need:
»www.toolocity.com/4-sase-vacuum-···rit.aspx



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON

Interesting. Thanks for that.



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

Click for full size
So here's what where I am so far. I know I need more support, for the side and for the front. That's coming. You can also see in the front where I'll be slipping in my curved MDF.

I'm also going to be putting rebar into the foundation to make sure it stays put relative to the porch (making sure I don't hit the hollow parts of the block). I know that's a little controversial, and some will probably think that's a bad idea. But when the whole was back-filled after the foundation repair, we put all gravel in right from the footing (on that side anyway). So it has good support underneath. I don't see it yanking the blocks out. I just want to avoid the slight shifts that'll make things look uneven.

I'm also going to be throwing fibers into the concrete mix, as well as air-entrainment admixture (since I'm in Canada). I want to make sure this is as strong as possible.

Trimox

join:2012-09-24
Anywhere

Are you using a gas powered mixer or electric?



Cho Baka
Premium,MVM
join:2000-11-23
there
kudos:2

He indicated electric.
»[Masonry] Re: Pouring concrete steps
--


Trimox

join:2012-09-24
Anywhere

said by Cho Baka:

He indicated electric.

Sorry had forgotten that. Just thinking about end of the world cold joint moment.

(Nightmares from the days when the concrete truck was late for a pour)

Unxchay

join:2003-10-14
Milwaukee, WI

1 recommendation

reply to cybersaga

I don't do concrete work myself but I do reside in Wisconsin and design landscapes & hardscapes for a living. A few thoughts to consider (using imperial units, sorry I don't have good metric conversions at hand):

A) This is a lot of stair mass to support without a footing. Typically we show a footing down to frost, either CMU or cast-in-place. On top of the footing we then cast the stairs. Here you'll have a monolithic stair pour that's going to be subject to whatever shifting may occur in the sub-base. You're clearly past that point now but it would be fair to assume some future movement of the stairs.

B) Are you going to pour the entire void space beneath the stairs as well? I ask because that's a lot of cubic area to fill with concrete. You could consider building some sacrificial formwork inside of the stairs and then filling the rest of the void space with some kind of angular stone. As long as you maintain min. 6-8" concrete thickness in the narrowest points, you'll have all the strength without the unnecessary volume.

C) Rebar is a good idea. Tying into the house foundation will help prevent long-term leaning or slumping, especially with no foundation. Then we typically call for small #3 (3/8" dia.) bars in at the noses of the steps, set at least 2" from the exposes surfaces. We also show #4 bars (1/2" inch dia.) @ 12" o.c., running diagonal (parallel to the riser-tread intersections), again at least 2" from the exposed surface.

Good luck, hope all goes well!
TOM

/edited for clarity



AbruptMayhem

join:2013-07-08
MA

1 edit
reply to cybersaga

I'm surprised there is no steel bar ties into the existing foundation. I'd want to do them on both sides (back and side) of the stairs in your situation. That would help keep it from moving from frost.

Good site on how to do concrete stairs.
»www.icreatables.com/exterior-hom···eps.html


cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

said by AbruptMayhem:

I'm surprised there is no steel bar ties into the existing foundation. I'd want to do them on both sides (back and side) of the stairs in your situation. That would help keep it from moving from frost.

Good site on how to do concrete stairs.
»www.icreatables.com/exterior-hom···eps.html

I've actually read that page several times over I have it bookmarked. And yes, I'm going to put rebar into the back and sides to keep it in place.

said by Unxchay:

A) This is a lot of stair mass to support without a footing. Typically we show a footing down to frost, either CMU or cast-in-place. On top of the footing we then cast the stairs. Here you'll have a monolithic stair pour that's going to be subject to whatever shifting may occur in the sub-base. You're clearly past that point now but it would be fair to assume some future movement of the stairs.

Yeah. Hindsight is 20/20. If I had thought of this back when it was all dug up for the foundation repair, I would have thrown in a sonotube before backfilling. But removing the stairs was a surprise. We thought the steps went right down to the footing, until they started digging up and we found it only went a couple feet into the ground, which meant we had to remove them to be able to waterproof the foundation beneath it. That or leave that corner not waterproofed and hope no water gets in, which may have been ok, but I really didn't want to revisit this.
said by Unxchay:

B) Are you going to pour the entire void space beneath the stairs as well? I ask because that's a lot of cubic area to fill with concrete.

No, I'll just be filling a few inches below ground level. When that area was backfilled, it was filled with only gravel. So I shouldn't see as much movement as you would expect with dirt.


StillLearn
Premium
join:2002-03-21
Streamwood, IL
Reviews:
·AT&T Midwest

said by cybersaga:

Yeah. Hindsight is 20/20. If I had thought of this back when it was all dug up for the foundation repair, I would have thrown in a sonotube before backfilling. But removing the stairs was a surprise. We thought the steps went right down to the footing, until they started digging up and we found it only went a couple feet into the ground, which meant we had to remove them to be able to waterproof the foundation beneath it.

Not at all expert on this, but suppose you drilled 1 or 2 holes 4-ft down with a post hole digger before pouring? Clean up the dirt with a shop vac before pouring.

Just an idea, which may have no merit.


AbruptMayhem

join:2013-07-08
MA

said by StillLearn:

suppose you drilled 1 or 2 holes 4-ft down with a post hole digger before pouring? Clean up the dirt with a shop vac before pouring.

Just an idea, which may have no merit.

He said it was backfilled with stone/gravel so digging would be brutal and the hole would just collapse.


Jim
Premium
join:2003-02-10
underabridge
reply to cybersaga

I realize it's kind of late but did you consider precast steps? May not be available in your area and/or cost prohibitive but a hell of lot easier.
I hated steps. I would have rather hand troweled an entire two car garage by myself rather than form pour and finish steps (I did concrete work for a living 30+ years ago).
But I was lazy.
--



cybersaga

join:2011-12-19
Welland, ON
Reviews:
·Start Communicat..

I thought about it, though I wouldn't say I "considered" it

I know this is much more work. I just wanted something that looked good. I'd hate to finish a project and go "ugh" every time I pull into my driveway.



AbruptMayhem

join:2013-07-08
MA

1 edit
reply to cybersaga

The good news is once it's done if the finish isn't as good as you want you can skim coat it with more concrete or paint it.

If I needed to do that type of project I might consider adding some copper tubing or a heating cable close to the top of each step for heating (snow removal). Next time we redo our driveway I'm having that put into the driveway so all I do is turn it on and I don't have to shovel anything.


kherr
Premium
join:2000-09-04
Collinsville, IL

I'd hate to see your power bill $$$ after that!!



AbruptMayhem

join:2013-07-08
MA

4 edits

said by kherr:

I'd hate to see your power bill $$$ after that!!

Pretty minimal actually. Cheaper then paying someone to plow. The driveway ones typically use hot water on a recirculator. It's radiant heat. A buddy has one that would be similar to what I want. It runs him about $15-25 per 4-6 hour snow storm for about 1,000 sq. ft of driveway. It costs me $35 to get mine plowed. That doesn't including waiting for the plow to get there or the time it takes them to clear it. Typically that makes me 1-2 hours late to work.

These people are saying they used it to get rid of 20+ inches of snow for a cost of $10-12.
»www.angieslist.com/articles/are-···ense.htm

Worth looking into since it's not that expensive to add when you pour the concrete. Even if you don't hook it up at least the option is there. It might cost like $100 for the OP's stairs to add a heating option. For stairs it might cost $2 per storm to clear the stairs but you won't have to worry about slipping from ice/snow.