 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 Reviews:
·Callcentric
·Anveo
·Shaw
·AcroVoice
·callwithus
·voip.ms
·FreePhoneLine
1 edit | [Electrical] Overloaded neutral / building wiring fault I have a UPS in my wife's home office with an illuminated building wiring fault light. This can apparently happen because of reversed polarity (it's not - at least not at this plug), missing ground, (it's there), and overloaded neutral. I used a multimeter to measure some of my outlets:
The following is edited because I bought a new meter and retested:
#1 Home office outlet: Hot to Neutral 120V Hot to Ground 120V Neutral to Ground 57V
#2 Outlet on same circuit Hot to Neutral 120V Hot to Ground 120V Neutral to Ground 0
#3 Outlet on different circuit Hot to Neutral 120V Hot to Ground 177V Neutral to Ground 57V
I'm guessing I have some issues. What is the best way to troubleshoot this further and what problems could this cause if left unchecked? Is this a DIY fix or should I ignore it or should I call a pro?
Thanks, Mango |
|
 garys_2kPremium join:2004-05-07 Farmington, MI
1 recommendation | You have a partly open neutral to your house, an extremely dangerous situation. Call the power company as an emergency and they'll find out if the problem is on the pole/underground feeder, at the meter or if it's your problem. Call them tonight! |
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 Reviews:
·Callcentric
·Anveo
·Shaw
·AcroVoice
·callwithus
·voip.ms
·FreePhoneLine
| I forgot to mention it has been like this for the two years I've lived here. I (incorrectly) thought the light on the UPS was due to missing ground but today I noticed a ground wire was there and so I looked further. But I will call them on Monday.
Given that some of the outlets do not have the problem, does that suggest an inside wiring issue rather than a problem on the pole/meter? |
|
 shdesignsPowered By Infinite Improbabilty DrivePremium join:2000-12-01 Stone Mountain, GA
2 recommendations | reply to Mango
Sounds like an open ground, not a neutral as you always have the same voltage from line to neutral. |
|
 TexPremium join:2012-10-20 kudos:1
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
What kind/brand of meter are you using to test voltages? Get yourself a circuit tester. |
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 | This meter: »obrazki.elektroda.net/0_1212514700.jpg
The UPS is an APC Back-UPS ES 350. |
|
 garys_2kPremium join:2004-05-07 Farmington, MI
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
Yeah, there should never be 150 volts on a 120 volt socket. A bad neutral will easily do that, but so could a bad meter. |
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 | I just tested with a Kill-A-Watt which shows 122 volts at all outlets. The 150V is probably due to a cheap meter. Though I'm still somewhat concerned that Neutral to Ground is showing any voltage at all. |
|
 tschmidtPremium,MVM join:2000-11-12 Milford, NH kudos:8 Reviews:
·G4 Communications
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Hollis Hosting
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
Normal branch circuit voltage is 120 volts so either your meter is badly out of calibration or your line voltage is incredibly high. Over voltage is not likely because of it was stuff would be burning out, incandescent lights and motors.
I agree with the other posts you most likely have an open equipment grounding conductor. The lack of ground is a safety hazard.
/tom
|
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 Reviews:
·Callcentric
·Anveo
·Shaw
·AcroVoice
·callwithus
·voip.ms
·FreePhoneLine
| said by tschmidt:open equipment grounding conductor Could you please explain this using shorter words?  |
|
 tschmidtPremium,MVM join:2000-11-12 Milford, NH kudos:8 Reviews:
·G4 Communications
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Hollis Hosting
1 recommendation |  Grounding |
The ground wire is open between the outlets you are checking and the circuit breaker panel. Neutral and Ground (EGC) are connected together at the neutral bus bar in the breaker panel.
/tom |
|
 lutful... of ideasPremium join:2005-06-16 Ottawa, ON Reviews:
·TekSavvy DSL
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
said by Mango:I just tested with a Kill-A-Watt which shows 122 volts at all outlets. The 150V is probably due to a cheap meter. That meter is OK, it is showing the peak voltage. There was a thread some time ago where it was explained in depth after someone measured 154V.
Kill-A-Watt is multiplying the measured peak voltage by 0.7 which you can do using a calculator.
said by Mango: Though I'm still somewhat concerned that Neutral to Ground is showing any voltage at all. voltage = current * resistance
You probably have very low current flowing through a high resistance path to ground. |
|
 SparkChaserPremium join:2000-06-06 Downingtown, PA kudos:3 Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
1 edit
4 recommendations | said by lutful:That meter is OK, it is showing the peak voltage. There was a thread some time ago where it was explained in depth after someone measured 154V.
Kill-A-Watt is multiplying the measured peak voltage by 0.7 which you can do using a calculator.
would you link to that thread?
Of the 5 meters I have not one measures peak. All are RMS.
BTW 150V * 0.7 =105 and line voltage peak is ~169
-- "Facts do not cease to exist because they are ignored." - Aldous Huxley
"The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it." - Neil deGrasse Tyson |
|
|
|
 tschmidtPremium,MVM join:2000-11-12 Milford, NH kudos:8 Reviews:
·G4 Communications
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Hollis Hosting
1 recommendation | reply to lutful
When OP posted such a high reading I thought it might be Peak to Peak rather then RMS but as SparkChaser posted the readings do not match.
/tom |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T Midwest
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
Here are a couple drawings showing shared neutrals. The first one shows the normal concept:

The top part of this one is one shows how you can get the unexpected voltages when the neutral path gets broken:

Your differential voltage between the neutral and ground is going to be the simplest way to track where the neutral is open.
Shared neutrals make it harder to use GFCI breakers, since those depend on having equal currents in the hot and the associated neutral. There are special breakers that look at two hots along with the shared neutral. |
|
 leiboldPremium,MVM join:2002-07-09 Sunnyvale, CA kudos:8 Reviews:
·SONIC.NET
1 recommendation | All that information about shared and broken neutrals is correct, but doesn't seem to apply to his situation.
He gets 122V at all outlets measured with a kill-a-watt and 150V at all outlets with a very inexpensive analog multimeter.
To me this indicates that the neutral is good and the ground is missing (either never installed to begin with or subsequently broken).
Voltages can be measured on a broken ground either through a high resistance path (as mentioned earlier) or through induction. -- Got some spare cpu cycles ? Join Team Helix or Team Starfire! |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T Midwest
| said by leibold:He gets 122V at all outlets measured with a kill-a-watt and 150V at all outlets with a very inexpensive analog multimeter. I had missed that.
Some analog meters have a different scale for AC. |
|
 Reviews:
·TekSavvy DSL
1 recommendation | reply to Mango
If it was me I would get a proper meter and make some real measurements. Borrow one if you have to. The kill-a-watt is not a great meter (reads hot to neutral only) and that analog meter is dangerous if it is giving false readings.
If you are on the 250VAC scale and you are reading 50v neutral to ground on that scale, I would want to figure out what is going on. I wouldn't write the whole situation off based on the readings you are seeing on the kill-a-watt. Some cheap digital meters from china will show odd readings on a open circuit but an analog meter will generally not show those spurious readings.
The analogue meter is not reading peak voltage. Like sparkchaser said peak is 169v
Honestly if it was me I would get to the bottom of this. Get a good meter and start in the panel and work out. Make sure the ground and neutral and bonded in the panel (brass screw) and that the voltage is the same to from both hots to ground and neutral. There should be no difference between the two. |
|
 | reply to StillLearn
said by StillLearn:Shared neutrals make it harder to use GFCI breakers, since those depend on having equal currents in the hot and the associated neutral. Shared neutrals cannot be used with GFCI breakers as there is no proper way wire a single neutral to two of them.
With a GFCI breaker the load hot and neutral connect to the breaker, therefore each hot must have it's own neutral. |
|

1 recommendation | reply to Mango
said by Mango:Neutral to Ground - needle moves slightly when I tested just now, was 45V a couple of hours ago. That sounds like an open neutral. |
|
 | reply to Mango

|
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T Midwest
1 edit
1 recommendation | reply to MatrixHDV
said by MatrixHDV:said by StillLearn:Shared neutrals make it harder to use GFCI breakers, since those depend on having equal currents in the hot and the associated neutral. Shared neutrals cannot be used with GFCI breakers as there is no proper way wire a single neutral to two of them. With a GFCI breaker the load hot and neutral connect to the breaker, therefore each hot must have it's own neutral. A 2-pole GFCI breaker, such as the Siemens QF220P, can be used for a shared neutral circuit.
Regarding the grounds, I think liebold makes a good case. His theory suggests capacitive coupling to the bad ground connection to account for the voltage reading measured from neutral to ground.
On the other hand, a bad neutral may be the deal. I don't know what all of the voltages are. I think that Mango should measure each outlet including those with something plugged in.
Also, checking the meter by probing in a different house might be useful. |
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 Reviews:
·Callcentric
·Anveo
·Shaw
·AcroVoice
·callwithus
·voip.ms
·FreePhoneLine
| So far I have found and fixed:
- Switched neutral on circuit #1 (home office) light. - Wires stripped too far on circuit #2 light & plug. - Grounds at multiple outlets not wired to code, but possibly working properly. - Too many wires in multiple outlet boxes for no reason.
None of this actually solved the problem.
I did notice something helpful. When I shut off circuit #2, circuit #1 tests normal. So I suspect the problem is on #2 but I am going to inspect everything as a matter of course.
Thanks to everyone who has responded so far. |
|
 SparkChaserPremium join:2000-06-06 Downingtown, PA kudos:3 | Just to clarify, Circuit 1 is one side of the 220 and Circuit 2 is the other side ? |
|
 | reply to StillLearn
said by StillLearn:A 2-pole GFCI breaker, such as the Siemens QF220P, can be used for a shared neutral circuit. It is not listed for that purpose. |
|
 Mangowww.toao.net join:2008-12-25 Alberta kudos:11 | reply to SparkChaser
I'm sorry I don't know. How do I tell? |
|
 Reviews:
·AT&T Midwest
1 edit | reply to MatrixHDV
said by MatrixHDV:said by StillLearn:A 2-pole GFCI breaker, such as the Siemens QF220P, can be used for a shared neutral circuit. It is not listed for that purpose. You might want to look at »Most "acceptable" way to go from MBCW recetacle to GFC for discussions.
Note title should have read MWBC (multi-wire branch circuit) and is being used to describe a common neutral shared with two hots.
Also see »w3.usa.siemens.com/powerdistribu···fci.aspx which says The 2-pole device can reduce wiring costs and installation time by enabling contractors to use multi-wire branch circuits, commonly known as "shared neutrals". When using single pole CAFCIs, a dedicated neutral is required for each circuit. The new 2-pole CAFCI allows electricians to share neutrals between the two circuits fed by the breaker. While that is an AFCI, I think the same principles apply. You can search for "2 pole gfci" "shared neutral" to find discussions. |
|
 lutful... of ideasPremium join:2005-06-16 Ottawa, ON Reviews:
·TekSavvy DSL
| reply to spock
said by spock:The analogue meter is not reading peak voltage. Like sparkchaser said peak is 169v How do you know that all outlets are actually getting a perfect sine wave with exactly 169V peak? Even if it is a perfect sine wave, the utility transformer could be overloaded and provide 159V. Anyway, I was guessing [peak - 0.5*ripple] for a crooked waveform.
Can someone explain this set of measurements, specially the 225V?
#3 Outlet on different circuit Hot to Neutral 150V Hot to Ground 225V Neutral to Ground 50V |
|
 shdesignsPowered By Infinite Improbabilty DrivePremium join:2000-12-01 Stone Mountain, GA Reviews:
·Atlantic Nexus
2 recommendations | said by lutful:Can someone explain this set of measurements, specially the 225V?
#3 Outlet on different circuit Hot to Neutral 150V Hot to Ground 225V Neutral to Ground 50V Ground is floating and gets crosstalk from a circuit on the opposite hot line. So, Hot to Ground is more than the Hot to Neutral. -- Scott Henion
Embedded Systems Consultant, SHDesigns home - DIY Welder |
|
 | reply to Mango
said by Mango:I did notice something helpful. When I shut off circuit #2, circuit #1 tests normal. So I suspect the problem is on #2 but I am going to inspect everything as a matter of course.
Look at breakers for circuit #1 and #2. Is one a red wire and one a black wire? Both coming from the same cable? If so then looks like it is a multi wire branch circuit, which share a neutral. If it is, then go back to the breakers. Are they on top of one another or next to one another? If they are next to one another this is wrong. It means they are on the same supply leg, which overloads the neutral. They need to be on separate legs (on top of each other). I had this situation in my home. Kevin |
|