 darciliciousCyber LibrarianPremium join:2001-01-02 Forest Grove, OR kudos:2 Reviews:
·Frontier FiOS
| reply to BrettZ
Re: Windows 8.1 Ad with Start Button said by BrettZ:said by Alcohol:a small step forward. hopefully windows 8.2 has a way to completely block metro.
Minimize the metro and you've the full fledged windows OS. Why does metro bother you? Yeah, I don't understand this need to "block" metro. I don't use it for days at a time despite the fact that nothing is "blocking" me from it... -- ♬ Dragon of good fortune struggles with the trickster Fox ♬ |
|
 OctaveanPremium,MVM join:2001-03-31 New York, NY kudos:1 | said by darcilicious:said by BrettZ:said by Alcohol:a small step forward. hopefully windows 8.2 has a way to completely block metro.
Minimize the metro and you've the full fledged windows OS. Why does metro bother you? Yeah, I don't understand this need to "block" metro. I don't use it for days at a time despite the fact that nothing is "blocking" me from it... Yeah I don't quite get it either. I can hit the ground running in Windows 7, Windows 8 / 8.1 Windows Server 2012 Essentials (uses the new UI ie Metro) and OS X,....natively,......no hand holding.
When it comes to windows 8, for the naysayers, I always thought it was a simple issue of don't like it, don't want it or don't know how to use it. I don't agree that it isn't functional, isn't serviceable or isn't useable. However, it seems to me like there is something of a distortion field around the subject. |
|
 Mele20Premium join:2001-06-05 Hilo, HI kudos:4
1 recommendation | said by Octavean:Yeah I don't quite get it either. I can hit the ground running in Windows 7, Windows 8 / 8.1 Windows Server 2012 Essentials (uses the new UI ie Metro) and OS X,....natively,......no hand holding.
When it comes to windows 8, for the naysayers, I always thought it was a simple issue of don't like it, don't want it or don't know how to use it. I don't agree that it isn't functional, isn't serviceable or isn't useable. However, it seems to me like there is something of a distortion field around the subject.
The problem for me (and the main reason I finally, after several months of struggling with Windows 8 Pro, installed Start8) was that the Charms bar and that huge black clock were very frequently accidentally activating. That became very irritating. I also had stuff activating from the corners when I did not intend that to happen. Plus, Metro side has no decent way to list and start applications and no way on Metro to use Windows Explorer which is what I do all the time. Metro side was developed solely for the ignorant of computers users whereas it could have had sophistication also aimed at power users if Microsoft had developed Windows 8 properly.
I've had a computer since 1999 and I am used to using a mouse (and keyboard only when I type or need a very few specific keys (like PrintScreen)). Relearning how to use a mouse after all these years of no problems using one seemed ludicrous and too time consuming. If you are on the desktop on Win 8 the corners and Charms bar should be deactivated. Start8 does this so it was a godsend but Microsoft could easily have designed Win 8 better. Gee, Stardock could fix it but Microsoft couldn't? WOULD NOT is the actuality.
I was in Target a few days ago and saw a new, smallish Acer laptop with touchscreen (first I have seen). I played with it and touch on the Metro side was fun but on the desktop side...nah....plus, I still cannot see Touch screens being great for DESKTOP machines or large laptops. The clerk and I were discussing this and he agreed with me that ergonomically touch screen for desktops/large laptops would be bad unless, perhaps, one stands when using their machine. Standing is not recommended for long periods, plus, one has to modify their desk to accommodate standing. Also, we both think if Dell ever makes Ultrasharp touch screen monitors that a 24" would be at least $600 which is a bit too much for me.
Microsoft should have offered more choice with Windows 8 instead of acting as though everyone has a tablet, small laptop, or cell phone for the internet and does not have a desktop or large laptop also or instead of the first three. -- When governments fear people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. Thomas Jefferson |
|
your moderator at work
hidden : hidden : Friendly delete
|
 AlcoholPremium join:2003-05-26 Climax, MI kudos:3 Reviews:
·Comcast
| reply to darcilicious
Re: Windows 8.1 Ad with Start Button said by darcilicious:said by BrettZ:said by Alcohol:a small step forward. hopefully windows 8.2 has a way to completely block metro.
Minimize the metro and you've the full fledged windows OS. Why does metro bother you? Yeah, I don't understand this need to "block" metro. I don't use it for days at a time despite the fact that nothing is "blocking" me from it... yeah and its using resources in the background. although not much. -- I found the key to success but somebody changed the lock. |
|
|
|
 JehuHodorPremium join:2002-09-13 MA kudos:2 | reply to Anon
said by Octavean:m not ready to give up my desk (with 3x 27" monitors) At my work we have full-sized, motorized desks that raise and lower for standing and sitting. there are lots o options out there for a standing-friendly desk that can support a fleet of monitors. |
|
 signmeuptooThank you YankeesPremium join:2001-11-22 NanoParticle kudos:5 Reviews:
·Comcast
·Optimum Online
1 edit | Landing on a window with 50 or 200 non icon icons, trying to search through such a massive alphabet soup mess to find the one icon, the one app I need to use is a royal PITA. Even on my iPhone I can group/nest like apps to make them easier to find. The Start Menu already does that, it's alphabetized, numerized, groupized, and hierchical. It works great and isn't hard on the eyes. A wall of messy icons is just Windows 3.22 all over again but WITHOUT the great grouping scheme. Sorry, but trying to say we are immature because we're angry over it isn't fair. -- Join Teams Helix and Discovery. Rest in Peace, Leonard David Smith, my best friend, you are missed badly! Rest in peace, Pop, glad our last years were good. Please pray for Colin, he has ependymoma, a brain cancer, donate to a children's Hospital. |
|
 OctaveanPremium,MVM join:2001-03-31 New York, NY kudos:1 | said by signmeuptoo:Landing on a window with 50 or 200 non icon icons, trying to search through such a massive alphabet soup mess to find the one icon, the one app I need to use is a royal PITA. Even on my iPhone I can group/nest like apps to make them easier to find. The Start Menu already does that, it's alphabetized, numerized, groupized, and hierchical. It works great and isn't hard on the eyes. A wall of messy icons is just Windows 3.22 all over again but WITHOUT the great grouping scheme. Sorry, but trying to say we are immature because we're angry over it isn't fair.
Who is this post directed too?
said by Jehu:said by Octavean:m not ready to give up my desk (with 3x 27" monitors) At my work we have full-sized, motorized desks that raise and lower for standing and sitting. there are lots o options out there for a standing-friendly desk that can support a fleet of monitors. Indeed,...
I've seen some very nice options when it comes to such desks that can be elevated automatically. The problem is if I want one I have to pay for it myself and these things typically are not cheap. So I'm OK with a laptop on a treadmill for now. |
|
 GlennAllenSunny with highs in the 80sPremium join:2002-11-17 Richmond, VA Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
2 recommendations | reply to Anon
Remaining in any one position for long periods of time without moving is detrimental--and next to impossible unless you're unconscious; you don't even do it when you're asleep. As I understand it though, with a standing desk you're mostly leaning (which can be quite comfortable). Anyway, sometimes we need to sit, sometimes we need to stand, but more than anything else, we always need to move. (And having a Start Menu wouldn't hurt either. ) |
|
 GlennAllenSunny with highs in the 80sPremium join:2002-11-17 Richmond, VA Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
| reply to signmeuptoo
I've recently found that "looking" for something there is less than satisfying; "searching" is somewhat more fruitful. At this point, the Start screen is something of an "Ultimate Launchy" app: just start typing to get a short-list. I think my non-techie sister will love it. |
|
 sivranOpera ex-patPremium join:2003-09-15 Irving, TX kudos:1 | You'd love ClassicShell. You can get an XP/2000-like Start menu with a run/search box at the bottom a la Vista/7. It's perfect. -- Oh, Opera, what have you done? |
|
 GlennAllenSunny with highs in the 80sPremium join:2002-11-17 Richmond, VA Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
| I'm still on Win7 & plan to stay there. My sister is moving from XP to 8 since that's what's on her new el cheapo PC (which is replacing her 10+ year old PC which stopped working); as long as she can get to some browser, I don't think she'll much care about starting other stuff 99.9% of the time. (She likes the "pretty" tiles though. ) |
|
your moderator at work
hidden : Off topic
|
 | reply to sivran
Re: Windows 8.1 Ad with Start Button said by sivran:You'd love ClassicShell. You can get an XP/2000-like Start menu with a run/search box at the bottom a la Vista/7. It's perfect.
Agreed, as soon as I bought my laptop it was the first download. Since then the metro screen has been a nice addition rather than a painful in lieu of. |
|
 plencnerbPremium join:2000-09-25 Elgin, IL kudos:2 | reply to signmeuptoo
 Picture #1 |  Picture #2 |  Picture #3 |  Picture #4 | |  Picture #5 |
said by signmeuptoo:Landing on a window with 50 or 200 non icon icons, trying to search through such a massive alphabet soup mess to find the one icon, the one app I need to use is a royal PITA. Even on my iPhone I can group/nest like apps to make them easier to find. The Start Menu already does that, it's alphabetized, numerized, groupized, and hierchical. It works great and isn't hard on the eyes. A wall of messy icons is just Windows 3.22 all over again but WITHOUT the great grouping scheme. Sorry, but trying to say we are immature because we're angry over it isn't fair.
Are you talking about the "All Apps" part of the new start screen? If you are, mine is above as shown in Picture #1.
What's interesting is that each header (Applications, Games, Microsoft Office, etc) are *gasp* alphabetized from left to right on the screen. Also, as you can see, all of the icons listed under each of the headings is also in that same order.
How did I do this? The same way I did it in Windows 7. I modified the underlying directory structure of the start menu / start screen.
Browsing to C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs yields what I am showing in Picture #2. Notice how (minus the administrative tools folder) each folder is the heading in the All Apps screen. Any folder that you place there (except folders in folders at that point) will become the headings on the All Apps screen.
Also notice, if you go into one of these folders, the icons match what is shown under the column headers. Picture #3 shows the contents of the directory C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs\Applications. Those icons match what is shown on my All Apps screen under the heading Applications.
Since these are all shortcuts and folders in a directory, they are sorted (by default I might add) alphabetically.
With this being a folder that you, as the end user can modify, you can then customize the "All Apps" folder to your hearts content. Rename the icons to whatever you want, place them in groups that meet your needs. The options are endless.
Remember how I said that this feature was there in Windows 7 as well? Also, the Windows 7 start menu has the same features as the Windows 8 Start Screen. Don't believe me? Well, lets look again at the Windows 7 Start Menu. If you look at Picture #4, we see a typical Windows 7 Start Menu. The icons listed are ones that the user can "Pin" to the start menu for ease of access, or ones that went there automatically if you left the default options set. Sounds familiar right? It should, as that is the first screen of the Windows 8 Start Screen. Like the part in the red box in Picture #4, you can "Pin" items to that that you use a lot, without having to click the words "All Programs" at the bottom of the menu.
To further show this, when you click on "All Programs" you get the 2nd part of the Windows 7 Start Menu, as shown in Picture #5. Looks a lot like my version of the "All Apps" screen in Windows 8 doesn't it? Sure, it may not be folders and sub-folders, but the concept is the same. Its a 2nd screen that lists more (or in most cases, all) of your icons that you may not use all the time.
The bottom line is that the underlying directory structure that makes up Picture #1 and Picture #5 is the same in both Windows 7 and Windows 8. Also, the functionally of "Start Menu" and "Start Screen" is really the same. The first view yields a set of frequently used apps (either set by you or the OS), and the 2nd view will show all the icons. While the steps are a bit different to get to the 2nd screen (Win 7 was a single left-click on All Programs, while Windows 8 is a right-click and then a left-click on All Apps), you really have the same functionally when you think about it.
So, if you were able to fully customize the Windows 7 Start Menu to fit your needs without installing any 3rd party application, then you should have no problems doing the same in Windows 8. I did it without any problems, and see it as just a much larger start menu, which is why its called a start screen, as it takes up your full screen.
Finally, I will close this with a word of caution. I know these to be true as I did them myself! If you do go around and want to modify that directory, here are 2 warnings.
1) Do not delete the shortcut called "Desktop". If you do, the desktop tile that is shown on the first screen will be deleted as well. If you want to be able to click on that to get to your desktop, without having to open something up (like Windows Explorer), make sure you keep that shortcut in place. You can place it in any folder, but it does have to exist.
2) Do not delete the "Administrative Tools" folder. Doing so will remove the icons that come up when you go into the Control Panel, then System and Security, and finally Administrative Tools. If you remove that folder, when you do those steps in Control Panel, you come up with a blank list.
--Brian -- ============================ --Brian Plencner
E-Mail: CoasterBrian72Cancer@gmail.com Note: Kill Cancer to Reply via e-mail |
|
 sivranOpera ex-patPremium join:2003-09-15 Irving, TX kudos:1 | The Start Screen however, can't do this:

Neither can the Vista-style Start menu, but that's beside the point. I'd be using Classic Shell there too. -- Oh, Opera, what have you done? |
|
 plencnerbPremium join:2000-09-25 Elgin, IL kudos:2 | That is correct. You don't get the hierarchical directory listing of folders and sub-folders on the Start Screen. It is all one big view.
Personally for me, that was never an issue. When I ran Windows 7, I had nothing on that first part, and everything under "All Programs". My most used items would be out of folders and just listed on the 2nd screen. Everything else was in folders under that. I also did not have sub-folders (never liked them on the start menu, even back with XP).
With XP and Windows 7, I hated to see a big start menu, so I have always tried to limit the number of icons that were put there, the exception being Accessories or System Tools that came with Windows. For example, if an application installed multiple shortcuts (Quicken is a good example), I would delete all but just the one that I need to launch the application. In the case of Quicken, I delete the shortcut for the Bill reminder app, shortcuts for things on the web, the uninstall, the readme, and so on. You can see this with how I have Windows 8 configured as well. On my "All Apps" screen, that is what it is: Applications. The "default" ones that come with Windows are under the headings of "Windows Accessories", "Windows Ease of Access", and "Windows System Tools". You can see all the applications that I have installed (Adobe Reader, DosBox, Winzip, Winamp, etc). But as you can see, none of the other extra icons or shortcuts that come with those programs are even shown, as I took extra steps to clean up and modify the directory structure, and remove the shortcuts that I did not need. If I ever did need something, I could just go find the EXE or the file itself, as its probably stored somewhere in the Program Files folders.
--Brian -- ============================ --Brian Plencner
E-Mail: CoasterBrian72Cancer@gmail.com Note: Kill Cancer to Reply via e-mail |
|
 Mele20Premium join:2001-06-05 Hilo, HI kudos:4 | I don't understand how you can stand the ugliness of Metro start screen. It is not possible to make it nice looking or transparent. Metro, all of it, is so extremely ugly that it doesn't matter what you can do like you have done.
I finally am reasonably ok with Windows 8 but ONLY because I have Start8 and, even more importantly, Windows Blinds. I am developing my own skin with MY COLORS, MY FONTS, etc AND FULL TRANSPARENCY OF WINDOWS. So, I finally get what Microsoft (and Nivida for the transparency) gave me in ALL previous versions of Windows but decided I didn't deserve in Windows 8.
I really can't understand how anyone can actually like the hideous backgrounds, fonts and forced colors that are Windows 8 Metro and to a large extent also Windows 8 desktop. Microsoft gave us the basic right to choose what we liked in all versions of Windows prior to Windows 8 and the sad fact that they decided to take all that away and ram their colors, their backgrounds, their choice of no transparency, their awful Segoe font or be damned as no other Windows font is available, etc makes them deserve only disdain. Windows has always been about making it YOURS...until Windows 8. You have made menus and Metro Start "yours" but what you have been able to do is very crippled. I will not allow Microsoft to treat me in such a shabby manner. Windows Blinds is a godsend especially if you teach yourself how to make your own skin. -- When governments fear people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. Thomas Jefferson |
|
 darciliciousCyber LibrarianPremium join:2001-01-02 Forest Grove, OR kudos:2 Reviews:
·Frontier FiOS
| said by Mele20: Metro, all of it, is so extremely ugly that it doesn't matter what you can do like you have done.
It is ugly to YOU. It doesn't matter to YOU. -- ♬ Dragon of good fortune struggles with the trickster Fox ♬ |
|

1 recommendation | reply to Mele20
said by Mele20:I don't understand how you can stand the ugliness of Metro start screen. It is not possible to make it nice looking or transparent. Metro, all of it, is so extremely ugly that it doesn't matter what you can do like you have done. MS made the choice to force a consistent look/feel onto all platforms: PC, tablet, and phone. And since those last two don't have the battery life or horsepower to do Aero, they ripped it out of Win8 entirely.
Look, this comes down to one thing: MS likes to believe that it has the ability to see what its users will want even when the users think they won't. Steve Jobs had this very rare ability. MS decidedly does not. |
|
 OctaveanPremium,MVM join:2001-03-31 New York, NY kudos:1 | reply to Mele20
said by Mele20:I don't understand how you can stand the ugliness of Metro start screen. It is not possible to make it nice looking or transparent. Metro, all of it, is so extremely ugly that it doesn't matter what you can do like you have done.
You do realizes how subjective what you just said is don't you? Esthetics (beauty) is in the eye of the beholder and as such you have likely answered your own question. |
|
 GlennAllenSunny with highs in the 80sPremium join:2002-11-17 Richmond, VA | reply to Mele20
Have you come across this: »punchcut.com/perspectives/posts/···anifesto (all about the Win8 design etc. -- some interesting stuff)? |
|
 BlitzenZeusBurnt Out CynicPremium join:2000-01-13 kudos:3
1 recommendation | reply to Mele20
Why are you such a blowhard over it? It's so hideous, it's awful.... Get over yourself.
How about you do us all a favor, and stop using Windows then? Spend a month using linux, lets see how quickly you start realizing that windows is stable, and works so you can bitch about the gui like it's the end of the world. So please, go use linux for a month, we could use the peace, and quiet. -- I distrust those people who know so well what god wants them to do because I notice it always coincides with their own desires- Susan B. Anthony Yesterday we obeyed kings, and bent our necks before emperors. But today we kneel only to the truth- Kahlil G. |
|
 Steve MehsGun Control Is Using A Steady HandPremium join:2005-07-16
1 recommendation | reply to Mele20
said by Mele20:I don't understand how you can stand the ugliness of Metro start screen. It is not possible to make it nice looking or transparent. Metro, all of it, is so extremely ugly that it doesn't matter what you can do like you have done. Come again? |
|
 Mele20Premium join:2001-06-05 Hilo, HI kudos:4 | reply to GlennAllen
I hadn't seen that. Thank you! It explains why Microsoft has become irrelevant and will probably disappear in the next ten years. Those design principles are a lot of gobbledegook that makes little sense. Number 4 is particularly incoherent and senseless. GUI is EVERYTHING because from the user's experience all flows from GUI. If the user doesn't like the GUI and is not allowed to fix it to their liking (without having to resort to third party programs they may have to purchase and that may or not work correctly all of the time) then the game is over before it began.
I don't know if it was intentional, but that website displayed in about 250% magnification when I went to it although Zoom said it was at 100%. I had to reduce zoom to 33% and it still was too big text.
If GUI is unacceptable and I can't fix it then why would I want a computer? I could get a device that just lets me LISTEN to web pages. -- When governments fear people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. Thomas Jefferson |
|
 Mele20Premium join:2001-06-05 Hilo, HI kudos:4 | reply to BlitzenZeus
You are not making sense. If my posts bother you so much then put my posts on "ignore". Simple fix.  |
|
 Steve MehsGun Control Is Using A Steady HandPremium join:2005-07-16 | said by Mele20:You are not making sense. If my posts bother you so much then put my posts on "ignore". Simple fix. 
Marilyn, what exactly did BlitzenZeus post that doesnt make sense? Seems pretty spot on to me
|
|
 Reviews:
·Cogeco Cable
| reply to GlennAllen
I can't help but be agitated with "do more with less" when it feels like I'm doing less with less. Either they got it wrong or these simple design philosophies are a waste of breath when the majority of users require more granular attention to their computing ecosystem. |
|
 GlennAllenSunny with highs in the 80sPremium join:2002-11-17 Richmond, VA | Instead of "either/or", I think it's more of a "both/and" situation. |
|