dslreports logo
 
    All Forums Hot Topics Gallery
spc
uniqs
30
lutful
... of ideas
Premium Member
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON

lutful to robbin

Premium Member

to robbin

Re: [Appliances] sanitizing ice makers

said by robbin:

said by lutful:

There is no risk of "corrosion" of evaporator coils or electrical circuits from the salt or bleach or ammonia or vinegar if you follow the manual and common sense.

References please

I have done this several times in tropical countries where un-sanitized ice makers actually kill people. I also designed the cooling guts of a portable thermoelectric ice maker when compliance with NSF/ANSI standard 12 was highlighted to me. You have to make all surfaces sanitizable and reasonably protect the electronics.

Anyway Google for that document and many references to it - they always have this phrase:

Machines with non-removable ice contact surfaces that are NSF/ANSI Standard 12 listed are designed to have sanitizing solutions circulate through the machines. If available, follow the manufacturer’s recommended cleaning and sanitizing procedures.

*** Detailed steps provided in one of several hundred such references: »www.co.san-diego.ca.us/d ··· ines.pdf

1. Remove any residual ice from the ice reservoir or shoots. Turn off the machine to
allow any other ice in the machine to melt.

2. Turn the water supply and electricity on. Drain sufficient water through the
machine to flush any residual water and dirt from the machine.

3. Run the machine through 2 or 3 freezing cycles. Discard any ice made.

4. Turn the water supply off.
5. Drain the water and any ice inside the system.

6. Circulate a warm water cleaning solution through the machine for at least 2
minutes. Drain the system.

7. Circulate clean potable water for 2 minutes. Drain the system.

8. Circulate a sanitizing solution. Use either a quaternary ammonia compound
following manufacturer’s instructions, or use 1 ounce household bleach in 3
gallons of clean potable water. Run the solutions through the machine for at least
2 minutes. Drain the system.

9. Wash, rinse, and sanitize any storage bins.

10. Return the drain valves to their normal position and start the machine.
11. Discard the first ice produced.

*** I suggested lukewarm saline solution ONLY to speed up step 1 ... rest of the steps will flush out all traces of salt from the system.

Tex
Dave's not here
Premium Member
join:2012-10-20

Tex

Premium Member

Those instructions are for a commercial ice machine. I don't believe I've ever seen a residential refrigerator ice maker that has a circulate or drain feature.

Jack_in_VA
Premium Member
join:2007-11-26
North, VA

Jack_in_VA to lutful

Premium Member

to lutful
The issue is a refrigerator not a commercial Ice Machine.
54067323 (banned)
join:2012-09-25
Tuscaloosa, AL

2 edits

54067323 (banned) to lutful

Member

to lutful
said by lutful:

I also designed the cooling guts of a portable thermoelectric ice maker when compliance with NSF/ANSI standard 12 was highlighted to me.

I doubt you will find a NSF listed ice maker in a residential refrigerator, none the less, considering contained within the front housing of a standard non-commercial residential, in refrigerator ice maker is a cam, a thermostat and some micro-switches and to the rear of the ice maker is a multi prong plug connected to 120 VAC, I would strongly recommend that no-one go about spraying any liquid that is conductive, such as salt water anywhere around the ice maker or back by the evaporator where it can get into the connections for the circulation fan, defrost heater and over-temp switches. Now in some icemakers all of that in in the rear of the machine but none the less it is still there.

Doing so could be quite dangerous and depending on how well grounded the person doing the spraying is, maybe even deadly.

It is simple common sense to not spray those types of liquids or allow their over-spray to make contact with electrical equipment.
54067323

1 edit

54067323 (banned) to Tex

Member

to Tex
said by Tex:

I don't believe I've ever seen a residential refrigerator ice maker that has a circulate or drain feature.

Heck they don't even have drains, just ask someone who has had the cam hangup on the fill cycle or a failed solenoid valve. The kitchen floor becomes the drain.

In residential you don't see re-circulation or drains until the units get up to the under-counter size or about 30-40 pounds per day.

Those types of units like their commercial brethren will have a re-circulation pump, a mould or sheet evaporator and hot wire cutter and a drain for the storage bin and re-circulation sump.

And as I am sure you know, they can and are to be cleaned with some nasty stuff called ice machine descaler and cleaner many of which contain Phosphoric Acid.

cdru
Go Colts
MVM
join:2003-05-14
Fort Wayne, IN

cdru to Tex

MVM

to Tex
said by Tex:

Those instructions are for a commercial ice machine. I don't believe I've ever seen a residential refrigerator ice maker that has a circulate or drain feature.

My work has an ice machine that is under the counter. Looks just like a dish washer until you open it. The instructions aren't identical to the above, but they are pretty close. I would not call the ice maker a commercial unit, but it is a dedicated ice unit that would be typical for a wet-bar type area.

Tex
Dave's not here
Premium Member
join:2012-10-20

2 edits

Tex

Premium Member

N/M
lutful
... of ideas
Premium Member
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON

1 edit

lutful to Tex

Premium Member

to Tex
Click for full size
said by Tex:

Those instructions are for a commercial ice machine. I don't believe I've ever seen a residential refrigerator ice maker that has a circulate or drain feature.

That reference was to show the steps which use potentially corrosive chemicals. US military procedure (screenshot above) includes both commercial and residential ice makers.

You can clean residential ice-maker assemblies (such as the older GE model shown above) using either vinegar or dilute bleach solution. You can definitely "circulate" the cleaning solution from water inlet at the back of the fridge all the way to the ice dispenser or tray.

All the fear-and-doubt about corrosion and electrical damage started because I had suggested using lukewarm saline solution to speed up melting of a solidly frozen assembly.
54067323 (banned)
join:2012-09-25
Tuscaloosa, AL

2 edits

54067323 (banned)

Member

said by lutful:

All the fear-and-doubt about corrosion and electrical damage started because I had suggested using lukewarm saline solution to speed up melting of a solidly frozen assembly.

Which considering the conductive and corrosive nature of salt water is a dangerous thing to be using around electrical appliances.

You can clean residential ice-maker assemblies (such as the older GE model shown above) using either vinegar or dilute bleach solution.

As for using bleach, both Amana and Frigidaire warn end users not to use corrosive chemicals such as bleach when cleaning their residential refrigerators, which is noted in the screeshot you posted as for G.E. they recommend using a solution of a tablespoon of baking soda mixed into a quart of water not bleach.
54067323

2 edits

1 recommendation

54067323 (banned) to cdru

Member

to cdru
said by cdru:

I would not call the ice maker a commercial unit, but it is a dedicated ice unit that would be typical for a wet-bar type area.

Which I already described a few posts up and is not found within a refrigerator.

Internally those back bar/under counter units operate in the same manner as the large machines found in say restaurants and many times are NSF listed which requires them to be designed to be cleaned to NSF standards, unlike the in-fridge/freezer units which are not listed and cannot be cleaned in such a manner.

Note the listing on this under-counter machine.

mant30.pdf
377545 bytes

Tex
Dave's not here
Premium Member
join:2012-10-20

1 recommendation

Tex to lutful

Premium Member

to lutful
You can post all the Army, Navy, Marine Corp and Air Force documentation you want, but in order for the water to circulate, as in a commercial ice machine, there would need to be a pump to circulate the water. There would need to be a water reservoir. No residential refrigerator ice maker that I'm aware of has these features. Nor do the ice makers have drains.
lutful
... of ideas
Premium Member
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON

lutful

Premium Member

said by Tex:

... in order for the water to circulate, as in a commercial ice machine, there would need to be a pump to circulate the water. There would need to be a water reservoir. No residential refrigerator ice maker that I'm aware of has these features. Nor do the ice makers have drains.

All this started with my suggestion to speed up the ice melting process using warm saline solution. I have done this several times for relatives and also used vinegar to clean the (plastic) assemblies and trays.

If you really wanted to run a cleaning solution from the water entry at the back of the fridge, you could run a tube from the ice tray to a nearby sink or a bucket on the floor and let gravity assist you. There are also inexpensive manual fluid pumps at auto stores.

Trying to prove that periodically cleaning the icemaker in a residential fridge is either impossible or ridiculous ... is an insult to people doing it regularly. If you are unwilling to do it, please do not prevent others from even considering it.

robbin
Mod
join:2000-09-21
Leander, TX

1 recommendation

robbin

Mod

There is no way for the average person to flush the lines of a residential ice maker. There is also no way to flood and drain the ice freezing tray. At most, you can direct a little spray from a pump spray bottle into it and then try to wipe it out. Suggesting anything else is truly ridiculous.

As far as salt water -- bad idea.
54067323 (banned)
join:2012-09-25
Tuscaloosa, AL

1 edit

54067323 (banned) to lutful

Member

to lutful
said by lutful:

Trying to prove that periodically cleaning the icemaker in a residential fridge is either impossible or ridiculous ... is an insult to people doing it regularly.

It has nothing to do with sanitizing an ice maker and everything to do with proffering advice that dangerous, and recommending spraying salt water on electrical equipment is just that.

See the device with the 0/1 on it in the picture you posted?

That's a switch that operates the ice maker and it switches 120 VAC as such using salt water anywhere near that switch or any of the other switches under that plastic cover is flat out wrong and dangerous.




And trying to walk it back by renaming salt water, saline, doesn't change that fact nor make it any safer.

printscreen
join:2003-11-01
Juana Diaz, PR

printscreen to lutful

Member

to lutful
said by lutful:

I have done this several times in tropical countries where un-sanitized ice makers actually kill people.

Well, I live in a tropical country and I am yet to see anyone killed by an ice maker. Commercial ones perhaps need this kind of attention, but a residential unit fully enclosed inside a freezer... don't see how anything can grow in there that could kill people.
lutful
... of ideas
Premium Member
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON

lutful to robbin

Premium Member

to robbin
said by robbin:

There is no way for the average person to flush the lines of a residential ice maker. There is also no way to flood and drain the ice freezing tray.


But reasonably smart 12-15 year old kids could flush once a year ... as an educational project.

Place container of vinegar water on top of the fridge.

Clip one end of water filled plastic tube in that container.
Insert other end of tube in the fridge water inlet.

Clip one end of another water filled plastic tube in the ice collection tray.
Put other end of that tube into a large bucket on the floor.

There will be no "flooding" if the container on top of the fridge is small. You can fill with salt water on first few passes, then vinegar water, and finally with clean water.
said by robbin:

At most, you can direct a little spray from a pump spray bottle into it and then try to wipe it out. Suggesting anything else is truly ridiculous.

For regular cleaning of the icemaker assembly with salt, you don't have to spray or even wipe.

Turn off icemaker. Wait.
Sprinkle salt on remaining ice. Wait.
Turn back on. Wait.
Discard salty ice.
said by robbin:

As far as salt water -- bad idea.

Yes, it is a bad idea if you deliberately spray salt water directly on electrical stuff outside the PLASTIC icemaker assembly.

Tex
Dave's not here
Premium Member
join:2012-10-20

Tex

Premium Member

From the Army document:

Cleaning and disinfecting procedures for residential
ice-making machines.
(If available, follow the
manufacturer’s recommendations.)

1. Determine if ice maker is completely or partially removable.

If removable:

2. Run ice maker through 2 or 3 freezing cycles. If refrigerator has a built-in water dispenser then a longer flush is required to flush the water reservoir.

3. Remove ice storage bin, ice maker unit, and any other removable components.

4. Wash in hot soapy detergent solution.

5. Rinse in clean potable water.

6. Sanitize parts in a solution of 1 ounce unscented household bleach in 3 gallons of clean potable water. Leave parts in solution for at least 30 seconds. Let parts air dry.

7. Wash hands thoroughly. Reassemble the unit and return the ice machine to service.

8. Discard the first ice produced.

9. Let the bin or reservoir fill and run bacteria samples on water supply and ice.

10. If negative, ice can be used for food operations. If positive, reclean and sanitize machine and check for problems with the potable water supply.

If not removable:

2. Run the ice maker through 2 or 3 freezing cycles or flush the water supply line including the water dispenser and water reservoir.

3. Discard ice and return the ice bin to the freezer.

4. Use a spray bottle with a chlorine solution (1 ounce household bleach to 2 gallons of water. Spray all exposed surfaces including ice shoots and freezing surfaces. Let surfaces air dry.

5. Clean and sanitize ice bin and any other removable parts. Follow procedures for ice machines with removable ice surfaces, above.

6. Wash hands thoroughly. Reassemble the unit and return the ice machine to service.

7. Discard the first ice produced.

8. Let the bin or reservoir fill and run bacteria samples on water supply and ice.

9. If negative, ice can be used for food operations. If positive, reclean and sanitize machine and check for problems with the potable water supply.

Jack_in_VA
Premium Member
join:2007-11-26
North, VA

Jack_in_VA

Premium Member

"From an army document"

That says it all. Useless for a home refrigerator ice maker and cold water dispenser.

I re-read my owners manual for my refrigerator and nowhere does it mention anything about "flushing" the ice-maker.

printscreen
join:2003-11-01
Juana Diaz, PR

printscreen

Member

said by Jack_in_VA:

I re-read my owners manual for my refrigerator and nowhere does it mention anything about "flushing" the ice-maker.

Mine says to discard the first few cycles from the ice maker. Also when connecting for the first time or relocating recommends to run the water dispenser for 5 minutes or so to remove air bubbles and to flush the system.

Jack_in_VA
Premium Member
join:2007-11-26
North, VA

Jack_in_VA

Premium Member

Mine says that too and I think all of them probably do also. That is not the same as routine "flushing".