said by nickz:Who are you talking to, Vonage or Tivo? VoIP is not a dial-up replacement, so I wouldn't blame Vonage. It sounds like Tivo needs to fix this because the modem is trying to connect at too high a speed.
I blame Vonage. Their webpage has had this statement for an incredibly long time.
"We do not currently support DirecTV and TiVo connection through the Phone Adaptor. We anticipate a solution shortly."