 Peterg1Premium join:2001-12-29 Montreal, QC Reviews:
·Videotron
| reply to J D McDorce
Re: [Nexland] New Firmware Somewhat off-topic but definitely of interest to me at least, is that I started searching the forums here for mentions of Nexland. I then saw someone mention Hotbrick and stated that this was started by ex-Nexland staff.
Hotbrick are at www.hotbrick.com and it was really interesting to look at their products. Pricing is very competitive - much cheaper than what we paid for our Nexland Products (I have the Pro 800) and they state that they offer SPI (which Nexland did not) and the WAN speeds, at least for the LB2 which interests me a lot is up to 55 Mbps which is far higher than what we had with our Nexlands' which were a max of 8 Mbps. I downloaded the manual and far greater configurability than we have now with apparently great reporting capabilities. It also seems to be made of metal like my Pro 800 (I hate plastic).
Here is a review of the LB2 (came out a few days ago):
»www.guru3d.com/article/network/161/
All in all, looks very interesting to me as being a step up from the D-Link/Linksys/SMC stuff which I will not use but below the cost say of Watchguard, Sonicwall etc. I also see that there has been a firmware upgrade as of December 2004 which is heartening.
Anyhow, this looks definitely near the top of my list to investigate for my next router. As it stands now, in Vancouver I am using Telus DSL 2.5 Mbps and I did try the competing Shaw Cable for a brief while but one of the firmware bugs with the Nexland reared its head. I received packet loss with the Nexland in the chain but none when I took the Nexland out. I also note that Hotbrick have a decent distibution network already with an office in Canada and the Netherlands at least and many websites selling their products.
Peter |
|
 KAIFS V I PPremium,MVM join:2001-01-11 CHEEEESE WI | what these things have been lacking, at least in my case, is a multi-NAT translations. I have two dsl connections at home, one dynamic, another 5-static IPs. None of these dual WAN routers allow me translate all 5 IPs on one of the WANs... Just a wishful thinking here . -- Bush told us he would create jobs - he just didn't tell us they would be in China, India and the Philippines. |
|
 Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Verizon FiOS
| I believe my Xincom 502 can translate them to the DMZ. I didn't see any way to get them onto the LAN. But then, I may have missed something.
I suspect that you would need a command language router, such as the Zyxel 35 or 70 or various Cisco offerings. Unfortunately, they cost a bunch more than a 502.
You may want to ask the question in the Networking forum.
kirby |
|
 danweberPremium join:1999-07-09 Pompano Beach, FL | reply to Peterg1 Funny, it looks just like a Xincom 502 and even the config menus are almost the same. Now who is building it and who is re-branding it only? |
|
 | Yeah, I kind of noticed that too when I saw screen shots of one of Hotbricks firmware posted on other web site. (»johram.blogdns.com/networkpics/n···ics.html) It does bare a striking resemblance to Xincoms firmware interface (or vice versa). As for whos doing the re-branding of these dual WAN routers, I dont know for certain but I did make a curious observation when checking out Hotbricks website. Privacy Policies stated on web sites normally provide a companys mailing address and Hotbrick states on theirs that they are a division of Telecom Logix Inc. I tried searching that through Google to find their web site to see what they are all about but all I got was a search result to the Miami FL superpages. There is a Telecom Logix Inc listed but comes up as a plastic scrap company of a sort. What a plastic scrap company and Hotbrick have in common, I havent a clue but it was really strange that both shared the exact address in Miami FL. |
|
 Peterg1Premium join:2001-12-29 Montreal, QC Reviews:
·Videotron
| said by frankie50:snip Privacy Policies stated on web sites normally provide a companys mailing address and Hotbrick states on theirs that they are a division of Telecom Logix Inc. I tried searching that through Google to find their web site to see what they are all about but all I got was a search result to the Miami FL superpages. There is a Telecom Logix Inc listed but comes up as a plastic scrap company of a sort. What a plastic scrap company and Hotbrick have in common, I havent a clue but it was really strange that both shared the exact address in Miami FL. They also come up as a telephone installation company (same address):
»www.telecomlogix.com/
Peter |
|
|
|
 Peterg1Premium join:2001-12-29 Montreal, QC Reviews:
·Videotron
| reply to danweber said by danweber:Funny, it looks just like a Xincom 502 and even the config menus are almost the same. Now who is building it and who is re-branding it only? Looking at the specs of the 502 and the LB-2 of Hotbrick both have a 166 Mhz Risc Processor and 16MB Ram and 1MB Flash. I see that Hotbrick have a 24 port Gigabyte Switch selling now whereas the seemingly identical unit from Xincom is still to be released.
So who is building the unit(s)? I say neither One thing that I found odd with the LB-2 review I mentioned above was that the reviewer talked about the bad English. I looked at some of the screenshots etc and it seemed as if the text on the interface was written by a non-English-speaking person. Hotbrick are in Florida and Xincom are in Oregon. I am guessing that the manufacturer is in China or Taiwan.
Peter |
|
 danweberPremium join:1999-07-09 Pompano Beach, FL | I sent an e-mail to Hotbrick and they responded by saying it is the same box as Xincom. They also said that THEY employ engineers that build products but the english in the e-mail was pretty bad so I am not sure if I should assume now that they manufacture the unit for Xincom as well.
I wonder if the Hotbrick firmware can be loaded onto a Xincom box, hmm, need to try that. |
|
 Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Verizon FiOS
| Heh. Maybe they are engineers employed to repaint Xincom's boxes red. 
I expect that to hit a wholesale price point that allows Provantage to sell a Xincom 502 at $190, the fabrication has to be performed outside the US. Unless Hot Brick's street prices are as low as Xincom's, I would not assume that the true source is Hot Brick.
kirby |
|
 | Interesting thread. What i'm curious about is the difference between the hotbrick lb-2 firewall dual wan loadbalancer (apparently the same box as xincom 502) that retails for around $200, and their $300 lb-2vpn, which is everything the lb-2 is plus vpn endpoint capabilities. A closer look at specs reveals that these seem to be exactly the same box with the same architecture. I'm curious as to whether the cheaper model can somehow be easily hacked to take the firmware of the vpn+ model. It can't be as easy as just loading the lb-2vpn firmware onto the plain lb-2, but I would bet there is a workable solution to getting around whatever they did to lock out the vpn endpoint capabilities of the lb-2 since they are the same box. |
|
 Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Verizon FiOS
| The Xincom VPN counterpart to the 502 is the 503, which is about $73 more expensive than the 502 at Provantage. If you were to buy a 502 from scratch, the effort of software hacking to get to the 503 configuration would surely exceed this difference in cost. I don't recall whether Xincom offers an upgrade to bring the 502 to the 503 configuration. If so, it would answer the question of whether adding vpn is purely a software function.
kirby |
|
 aljst join:2002-06-14 Fort Lee, NJ | reply to danweber I have never played with the HotBrick, but heard good things about it. What is disheartening is that if it looks and feels like a Xincom; I own 4 Xincoms 502's and 503's I have had a lot of trouble with them. From unexplained spontaneous reboots several times a day, to freeze ups, to web interface lockdowns to wan connectivity drops, etc. Firmware upgrades resets them to default (forcing you to travel on site to upgrade them!!). Tech support is not that helpful. etc etc. I recently upgraded one of these Xincoms with a Zywall 70 which is a bit more expensive but definetly worth the money. So far it has worked out pretty well. My five cents.
AJ |
|
 aljst join:2002-06-14 Fort Lee, NJ | reply to Peterg1 Dealing with my troubles with the Xincom, at one point I had email contact with the manufacturer/designer and it was definetly in Taiwan. Furthermore When I sent my config file to them (for a 503) I stripped the passwords from the VPN configuration but left the IP's for the endpoints. The following day my routers here all started complaining about failed logins from 2 different IPs in Taiwan. I assume that they loaded my config for testing, and their test router tried to establish the VPN sessions from there.
AJ |
|
 Peterg1Premium join:2001-12-29 Montreal, QC Reviews:
·Videotron
| said by aljst:Dealing with my troubles with the Xincom, at one point I had email contact with the manufacturer/designer and it was definetly in Taiwan. Furthermore When I sent my config file to them (for a 503) I stripped the passwords from the VPN configuration but left the IP's for the endpoints. The following day my routers here all started complaining about failed logins from 2 different IPs in Taiwan. I assume that they loaded my config for testing, and their test router tried to establish the VPN sessions from there. AJ Thanks very much for the confirmation. It is thus clear to me that both Xincom and Hotbrick are simply performing "badge engineering". I would assume that the firmware between the two is essentially identical with possibly minor changes depending on the requirements of the particular company.
So when it comes to reliability, this is probably going to be dependent on one's particular situation. There is plenty of history with Nexland and I see with Xincom in various threads that with certain ADSL or cablemodem providers there are no problems but with certain providers, primarily cablemodem, there have been and are problems. The problems can be packet loss (such packet loss disappearing when the router/firewall is taken out the equation) to full-blown lockups and dropped connections.
I believe when I decide to upgrade my Nexland I will probably go with Zyxel as well (a Zyxel 5 and just forget about load balancing). The Linksys RV082 interested me a lot as it has a lot of processing power and memory but I see plenty of problems there as well with sub-par support and *also* hardware and firmware designed in Taiwan with Cisco/Linkysys doing badge engineering as well in this case.
Peter |
|
 aljst join:2002-06-14 Fort Lee, NJ | I should try to flash my XC-DPG503 with the Hotbrick Firewall LB2 VPN and see what happens. May be my flakiness is due to buggy firmware. I will post my results if I feel brave enough to try it (hopefully Hotbrick's is not as bad).
AJ |
|
 | reply to Peterg1 said by Peterg1: said by aljst:The Linksys RV082 interested me a lot as it has a lot of processing power and memory but I see plenty of problems there The RV082 and other linksys multiwan routers are all limited to 10baseT on the WAN. Weak imo. |
|
 | reply to Kirby Smith said by Kirby Smith:If you were to buy a 502 from scratch, the effort of software hacking to get to the 503 configuration would surely exceed this difference in cost. I don't recall whether Xincom offers an upgrade to bring the 502 to the 503 configuration. If so, it would answer the question of whether adding vpn is purely a software function. kirby What makes you think that it would exceed the configuration in cost? Have you taken a look at the board? Are there pinouts for either a serial or jtag adapter? I would bet there is. With jtag, it would be as easy as forcing a flash of the 503 firmware.
Although just from the feedback on this board, I'm not so hip on picking up a lb-2 afterall to experiment since it sounds like the 502 rebadged. I'll have to look into the zyxel. |
|
 Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Verizon FiOS
| Sorry, perhaps my economic comment was unclear. To be more specific, if the difference in cost between the two units divided by your pay rate is less than the time it takes to get into the unit and change the software -- a process that might require figuring out some software edits to be made with a hex editor as have been found to be needed to make Symmantec software work on some Nexland units -- then the effort is not cost effective. If you are convinced that you can make the changes in relatively little time, or your time has low per-hour value, then I certainly support your contention.
kirby |
|
 Peterg1Premium join:2001-12-29 Montreal, QC Reviews:
·Videotron
| reply to yezusuq said by yezusuq: said by Peterg1: said by aljst:The Linksys RV082 interested me a lot as it has a lot of processing power and memory but I see plenty of problems there The RV082 and other linksys multiwan routers are all limited to 10baseT on the WAN. Weak imo. Not according to these tests by Tom's networking: » www.tomsnetworking.com/Reviews-1···82-7.phpPeter |
|