moonpuppy
join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD
 ·Verizon Online DSL
| reply to fiberguy
Re: SSL
said by fiberguy  :A passport is better than a driver's license, SS or birth cirt? No they aren't. Who told you that garbage? PLESAE tell me where on the form is says "passport desired"... all forms of ID are just as acceptable as the next. Look at an I-9 form. A passport does the job of a driver's license and birth certificate when determining eligibility to work in this country. Just because you have a driver's license, doesn't mean you can work in this country.
»www.uscis.gov/graphics/formsfee/···/i-9.htm
said by fiberguy :10 million? What's the total population of the country? now figure out the percentage. Because this country puts so much stake in the state ID's, most people, including you, don't see a need for a passport. Beginning 1/1/2008, you need a passport to go to Mexico or Canada (right next door.)
said by fiberguy :No.. a passport is not a nation ID card. And SOME members of congress want debate because they want more control over the people of the states. I can show it to a police officer and he has all the information he needs to run a check on me. My Maryland license doesn't even have my SS# on it. All he needs is my name and date of birth and he can find my DL number if he needs it.
The ONLY 2 things a driver's license does over a passport (within the country) is allow you to drive and establish an address. The latter is not even that reliable in many cases.
A system is already in place, time to use it. |
|
fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
| reply to moonpuppy
A passport is better than a driver's license, SS or birth cirt? No they aren't. Who told you that garbage? PLESAE tell me where on the form is says "passport desired"... all forms of ID are just as acceptable as the next.
10 million? What's the total population of the country? now figure out the percentage.
No.. a passport is not a nation ID card. And SOME members of congress want debate because they want more control over the people of the states.
--
"Wipe out the national deficit over night... Tax the stupid!" - about 50 gMail invites available. PM if you'd like one. |
|
moonpuppy
join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD
·Verizon Online DSL
1 edit | reply to fiberguy
said by fiberguy :If we "already had a national ID system" then there would be no debate in congress on needing a "national ID card" now would there? Do you have any idea how many people in the U.S. actually HAVE a passport? You know, that document that lets you travel outside the country? While the passport is mostly used for travel outside the country, it is more than that. When you fill out an I-9 form, it is better than an ID card (driver's license) and SS card or birth certificate.
BTW, over 10 million were issued in 2005. Passports are good for 10 years (5 if you are under 18.)
EDIT: and Congress is debating this because they need something to crow about, another pork project and a vote to keep their jobs for the next election. |
|
fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
| reply to moonpuppy
If we "already had a national ID system" then there would be no debate in congress on needing a "national ID card" now would there?
Do you have any idea how many people in the U.S. actually HAVE a passport? You know, that document that lets you travel outside the country?
--
"Wipe out the national deficit over night... Tax the stupid!" - about 50 gMail invites available. PM if you'd like one. |
|
moonpuppy
join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD
·Verizon Online DSL
| reply to fiberguy
said by fiberguy :If anyone wants a point AGAINST a nation ID, look at the blown-out SSN fiasco we are faced with today and how THAT number was abused. We already have a national ID system......it's called a Passport. |
|
fiberguy
My views are my own.
Premium
join:2005-05-20
| reply to stufried
I agree... however, to put it simple, there needs to be a dynamic checks system on creidt reporting and Congress needs to pass hard core legislation on restricting the use of the SSN.
It's NOT a nation ID number and needs to quit being used like one.
If anyone wants a point AGAINST a nation ID, look at the blown-out SSN fiasco we are faced with today and how THAT number was abused.
--
"Wipe out the national deficit over night... Tax the stupid!" - about 50 gMail invites available. PM if you'd like one. |
|
stufried
Premium
join:2003-10-13
 ·Verizon BroadbandA..
| reply to fiberguy
The problem is that the SSN is already too compromised to do any good. Until 2001, these numbers were sold in commercial database files. Those files still around on many investigative databases.
State IDs are not standardized. We need to create a public id for people with some sort of rotating verification key (not just a PIN). Here is a simple (but not perfect idea).
When I put a fraud alert on my file, I could not get new credit without them calling me, but that only last 90 days. I am in the process of drafting a request to make it permenant, but this is deliberately made too difficult to get. I would like to put the additional requirement that I have to be called on my mobile phone before credit is granted.
I'd then like that mobile number and mail number in a hardened file that requires something like a letter to be sent to my previous address of record with a code that has to be punched in somewhere before it could be changed.
Our current system is too compromised. We need to invest in something more secure and we need to move it out several generations (rather than in minor increments). |
|
