John Galt
Am I Coming or Going?
Premium
join:2004-09-30
Oceanside, OR
| Network Management Software
I am looking for some suggestions of network management software. This is for a very large deployment (~28 backbone nodes and >10,000 subscribers). The specified hardware has SNMP and MIBs.
I fully expect to pay (a lot) for this, so suggestions of "freeware" or "cheapware" are not really necessary.
Price is no object (well, a $1B is a bit much)...so suggest away. A clue about the approximate cost would be helpful (so I don't have to waste a bunch of time talking to sales drones (no disrespect intended, lurking SalesDrones!).
Feel free to contact me off-list.
Thanks in advance!
--
A is A |
|
davidpaj
join:2002-04-22
| said by John Galt  :I am looking for some suggestions of network management software. This is for a very large deployment (~28 backbone nodes and >10,000 subscribers). The specified hardware has SNMP and MIBs. I fully expect to pay (a lot) for this, so suggestions of "freeware" or "cheapware" are not really necessary. Price is no object (well, a $1B is a bit much)...so suggest away. A clue about the approximate cost would be helpful (so I don't have to waste a bunch of time talking to sales drones (no disrespect intended, lurking SalesDrones!). Feel free to contact me off-list. Thanks in advance! www.ipswitch.com What's up Professional, I use it, nice product |
|
butchevans
Premium
join:2007-01-15
Malden, MO
| reply to John Galt
said by John Galt :I am looking for some suggestions of network management software. This is for a very large deployment (~28 backbone nodes and >10,000 subscribers). The specified hardware has SNMP and MIBs. What specifically are you want to do? If it is just monitoring, then there are a LOT of very nice options available. Intermapper is one of the best I've seen, though I found it a bit pricy. For your application, it will not be very much on a per node basis, however. You can find it here: »dartware.com/products/intermapper/index.html
If you are looking more for real management options, HP Openview may be a better choice, though that is likely to be a BIG difference in price. I'm not certain on their price structure, so I'm not sure about that.
These are the only 2 that I have used much at all in the commercial arena. I have a bit more experience with HP Openview, but not a lot. Intermapper is a really nice application.
I fully expect to pay (a lot) for this, so suggestions of "freeware" or "cheapware" are not really necessary. Then, there are the freeware things. Don't overlook these options. Many of these are VERY good applications. You can spend the $$ you have set aside for the software and pay an employee or consultant (not me) some bucks to learn it very well, and even some training for existing employees. I'm not one that advocates freeware over commercial just because it's "open source or die"...but sometimes it makes sense to use this option. 
Price is no object
Price is always an object. It may be that in this case it is not a primary deciding factor, but it is certainly a part of the decision.
Feel free to contact me off-list.
What, and have everyone else miss out on the fun? Nah...:)
--
Butch Evans
»www.butchevans.com/ |
|
sporkme
drop the crantini and move it, sister
Premium,MVM
join:2000-07-01
Budd Lake, NJ
| reply to John Galt
Are you looking to monitor every sub?
Here's some quick stats on some of the people who have chosen to share how many nodes/services they monitor with Nagios:
»www.nagios.org/userprofiles/quickstats.php
It's a ton of work to setup, and you'll need a beefy box to poll 10,000 nodes, but it is doable. HP OpenView or other big commercial products will also have a very steep learning curve and need lots of hardware - and possibly a "consultant" to get the whole thing running. |
|
mrbueno
join:2002-08-03
US
| reply to John Galt
HP Openview is a good choice.
»h20229.www2.hp.com/
However, cacti and MRTG should be pretty simple to deploy as well just because it's free doesn't make it bad.
Want support? Try »www.paessler.com/prtg at one time a simple to deploy and use MRTG derivitave. $1,495.00 for unlimited sensors. Demo available here: »prtgdemo1.paessler.com:8080/login.htm
Groundwork is a nice open source/commerical solution: »www.groundworkopensource.com/ with an ISO evaluation CD »www.groundworkopensource.com/dow···oad.html
Decided to use MRTG and need MIBs? »www.somix.com/support/mrtg_repository.php Somix also has a nice MRTG derivitave themselves.
All very interesting and viable solutions. Hope this list helps someone. |
|
dongato17
VIP
join:2000-07-28
Atlanta, GA | reply to John Galt
Just to clarify, is this network one that is deployed already or one that will be deployed?
-Hal
--
Harold Bledsoe
Deliberant Wireless
»www.deliberant.com |
|
LLigetfa
join:2006-05-15
Fort Frances, ON
| I use WhatsUp Pro but haven't learned to use all of the features. I upgraded it from Gold.
I had a build of MRTG that was using flat files but the performance was pathetic. Later I had a student rebuild it and told him to set it up using a MySQL db but found out that he cheated after he was long gone. I eventually decided to go with Somix.
I also have a collection of Fluke tools and software and manage my HP switches with ProCurve Manager Plus. |
|
mrbueno
join:2002-08-03
US | reply to John Galt
BTW, monitoring this many nodes too frequently will use a bit of bandwidth as well. |
|
viperm
Carpe Diem
Premium
join:2002-07-09
Winchester, CA | reply to John Galt
I say HP openview as well |
|
John Galt
Am I Coming or Going?
Premium
join:2004-09-30
Oceanside, OR
| reply to dongato17
said by dongato17 :Just to clarify, is this network one that is deployed already or one that will be deployed? To be deployed.
--
A is A |
|
AMD Phreak
Please do the needfull
Premium
join:2003-12-14 | A network that big I would use HP's implementation. |
|
gmcintire
Graham
Premium
join:2005-08-09
Blue Ridge, TX
| reply to John Galt
I'd suggest taking a look at OpenNMS (»www.opennms.org) It's open source and designed as an alternative to systems such as Tivoli and OpenView. Don't think open source = cheap product though, it's designed specifically to handle extremely large networks with a minimal amount of network traffic. |
|
Semaphore
Premium
join:2003-11-18
Arnprior On.
| reply to John Galt
A company I am familiar with operates a NMS for well over 100,000 nodes monitoring several individual (separate) company networks, using HP OpenView. I don't know the product, but they explained it to me that they have X number of collectors, which feed up to the aggregators and they feed the top level management consoles. Sure looked impressive. I also got the impression it was a PITA to configure, and wickedly expensive |
|
canadiancree
Crusin in the boonies
join:2004-02-10
Belleville, ON
 ·Bell Sympatico
 ·Cogeco Cable
| said by Semaphore :A company I am familiar with operates a NMS for well over 100,000 nodes monitoring several individual (separate) company networks, using HP OpenView. I don't know the product, but they explained it to me that they have X number of collectors, which feed up to the aggregators and they feed the top level management consoles. Sure looked impressive. I also got the impression it was a PITA to configure, and wickedly expensive As a former user of this product during my time with Hewlett Packard, I'll confirm this assessment. Most of the time they have consultants configure the thing for the customer, in fact if I recall correctly they recommend it. As for price let's just say that most of us would LOVE to have that amount for a budget.
BTW Intresting fidn on OpenNMS. Hopefully they have a topology like interface that HP's product had. I found that to be very handy. |
|
lutful
Premium
join:2005-06-16
Ottawa, ON
·TekSavvy Solutions..
| reply to John Galt
AdventNet will customize OpManager for your exact specifications including a custom NOC GUI with your logo.
You can download "off-the-shelf" versions here:
»manageengine.adventnet.com/produ···dex.html
Indian software companies are very affordable. |
|
John Galt
Am I Coming or Going?
Premium
join:2004-09-30
Oceanside, OR | reply to John Galt
Thanks for everyone's comments and recommendations.
--
A is A |
|
rfreeborn
join:2007-04-30
New York, NY
moderated:
April 30th, @12:12PM
| reply to John Galt
Re: Network Management Software
Mod note: commercial posts are not allowed. |
|
samtheham
@comcast.net | reply to John Galt
www.solarwinds.com - cirrus..
Very nice item, just started using it - priced right too.. |
|
