Pashune
Inhaling at 675 KB per sec.
Premium
join:2006-04-14
Gautier, MS
 ·CableOne
 ·AT&T Southeast
| Versalink 327w sensitive to lightning like Westell 6100?
I'm curious as to if Westell's other modems/routers are as sensitive as their 6100 model. I heard a few tell me the 2200 works great in storms, but one question remains. What about the Versalink 327w? How well does it function in the event of a storm as compared to the 6100? |
|
heels_fan
1.20.09 The start of Socialism
Premium
join:2003-02-07
Columbia, TN
| like i have mentioned before in other threads.
My 6100 does not go out in any Lightning/Thunderstorms.
We get our fair share of storms here and my modems stays up and working.
Where do people get that the 6100's are bad in thunderstorms?
--
Take your hatred of our Government out of the Technical Forums! |
|
Pashune
Inhaling at 675 KB per sec.
Premium
join:2006-04-14
Gautier, MS
·CableOne
·AT&T Southeast
| said by heels_fan  :like i have mentioned before in other threads. My 6100 does not go out in any Lightning/Thunderstorms. We get our fair share of storms here and my modems stays up and working. Where do people get that the 6100's are bad in thunderstorms? I'm not exactly sure. My guess? Westell modems just don't like me. =( I have 2 6100's. Both just as faulty when thunder is present. Can't figure it out at all.  |
|
heels_fan
1.20.09 The start of Socialism
Premium
join:2003-02-07
Columbia, TN
| said by Pashune :said by heels_fan :like i have mentioned before in other threads. My 6100 does not go out in any Lightning/Thunderstorms. We get our fair share of storms here and my modems stays up and working. Where do people get that the 6100's are bad in thunderstorms? I'm not exactly sure. My guess? Westell modems just don't like me. =( I have 2 6100's. Both just as faulty when thunder is present. Can't figure it out at all. Maybe it is something with your line.
--
Take your hatred of our Government out of the Technical Forums! |
|
Pashune
Inhaling at 675 KB per sec.
Premium
join:2006-04-14
Gautier, MS
·CableOne
·AT&T Southeast
| said by heels_fan :said by Pashune :said by heels_fan :like i have mentioned before in other threads. My 6100 does not go out in any Lightning/Thunderstorms. We get our fair share of storms here and my modems stays up and working. Where do people get that the 6100's are bad in thunderstorms? I'm not exactly sure. My guess? Westell modems just don't like me. =( I have 2 6100's. Both just as faulty when thunder is present. Can't figure it out at all. Maybe it is something with your line. Don't think so. Have had a tech inspect my line twice. Removed a bridged tap, replaced my drop, and fixed some grounding. Even installed a DSL splitter. No dice. =( Not to mention I had this same problem when I was living elsewhere, with the same modem. I say I don't think it's my line because my old, clunky 2 Wire even manages to hold sync when there's a severe storm in the area. |
|
ncguy68
join:2006-10-14
Kings Mountain, NC
1 edit | reply to heels_fan
The Westell 6100 has trouble holding sync during EMI. If your line stats are marginal the problem is more noticable. I have a friend who has good line ATTN and S/N ratios and he does not have the problems I had with the Westell 6100. I have an ATTN around 55 and S/N ratio of 12. During a distant storm (20 miles away) I would lose sync. The Netopia 2241N does not have any problems holding sync till the storm is close and by that time you should turn everything off and unplug it.
I've never used the Versalink model(s) so I can't jugde how they would do. Sorry. |
|
heels_fan
1.20.09 The start of Socialism
Premium
join:2003-02-07
Columbia, TN
| said by ncguy68 :The Westell 6100 has trouble holding sync during EMI. If your line stats are marginal the problem is more noticable. I have a friend who has good line ATTN and S/N ratios and he does not have the problems I had with the Westell 6100. I have an ATTN around 55 and S/N ratio of 12. During a distant storm (20 miles away) I would lose sync. The Netopia 2241N does not have any problems holding sync till the storm is close and by that time you should turn everything off and unplug it. Well, I should count myself lucky then, huh?
--
Take your hatred of our Government out of the Technical Forums! |
|
FAQFixer
Premium
join:2004-06-28
Powder Springs, GA
| reply to Pashune
said by Pashune :Don't think so. Have had a tech inspect my line twice. Removed a bridged tap, replaced my drop, and fixed some grounding. Even installed a DSL splitter. No dice. =( Not to mention I had this same problem when I was living elsewhere, with the same modem. I say I don't think it's my line because my old, clunky 2 Wire even manages to hold sync when there's a severe storm in the area. Maybe it is a simple bonding issue. My brother lives in Daytona and that area is considered the lightning capital of the US, and he doesn't have issues. Of course your line is on the very edge of service to begin with so you would not have any margin when the storms get close. |
|
mikes60
Stop Socialism Now
Premium
join:2001-07-31
Boynton Beach, FL
·AT&T Southeast
| reply to Pashune
I'm in South Florida, and lightning this time of the year is a daily event.
I'm now using a 327W, but had a 6100 for a couple of years. Even during the wildest lightning storms, I have never lost my connection. I have pretty good stats, and all our utilities are underground. Maybe that combination helps.
--
No good deed goes unpunished. |
|
Pashune
Inhaling at 675 KB per sec.
Premium
join:2006-04-14
Gautier, MS
·CableOne
·AT&T Southeast
| Ah, well, that's that. Though I'm denial that my stats are to blame (Because my old 2Wire modem has no trouble with it), you guys are probably right. No big deal for now. Going to try to get a Netopia.  |
|
