There are other factors to include more than "who its the largest upgrade for". Attendance, dedication, skill, etc. In a world where everyone shows up to every raid and will stick with it for years to come, yes, your system would make sense.
In a system where folks come and ago and people vary on a degree of skill levels, DKP wins out. -- I melt faces.
in the guild i am in when we roll on something. the individuals look at each others gear and if they see the it is a bigger upgrade for the other they let them have it even if they won the roll. we all have become really good friends. and even a lot of them are RL friends. live together and work together.
Archivis Your Daddy Premium join:2001-11-26 Earth kudos:17
Do you guys have little parties on the weekends where one of you dresses up like a policeman, the other as an indian chief and another a construction worker?