Roleplay, especially enforced, reminds me way too much of the Goldshire-WoW incidents.
I can fully appreciate people wanting a dynamic human-based story event, but I cannot immerse myself fully into something like that.
In order to immerse myself into something like that, it usually requires me to play a single-player game where I know everything is an NPC. Does mean I'm limited? Yes, but it doesn't destroy it for me.
A government big enough to give you everything you want, is strong enough to take everything you have. -MLK