| Anon | Approved Comcast Modems Modem List I just wanted to add a list of current Comcast modems, it took me a while to find
it. So I thought I would start a new one and try to make it easier for people
to find it.
It was originally posted here
And was posted by Teriwyn
Who I would like to thank for this fine list. THANKS A LOT Teriwyn
3Com 3CR29220
3Com external CMX 2940
Bestdata CMX300
Cisco UBR 905
Cisco UBR 904
Cisco UBR 925
Com21 CM CP-3001(DP1010)
Com21 CM DP101
Com21 CM DP111
Com21 CM DP1110
D-Link DCM100
D-Link DCM200
Ericsson PipeRider HM200c
High Speed Surfing SM100
High Speed Surfing SM200
Linksys BEFCMU10 Ver 2
Linksys BEFCMU10 CW 01
Motorola SB3100
Motorola SB3100D (telco return)
Motorola SB4100
Motorola SB4101
Motorola SB4200
Samsung SCM-140U
Samsung SCM-120U
Samsung CM 100R
Scientific Atlanta Webstar DPX110
Scientific Atlanta DPX100
TCE/RCA DCM105
TCE/RCA DCM205
TCE/RCA DCM215
TCE/RCA DCM225
TCE/RCA DCM226
TCE/RCA DCM235
TCE/RCA (Thompson) DCM245R and DCM245 (same modem)
TCE/RCA 305
Terayon ECM-110
Terayon ECM-210
Terayon ECM615 aka TJ615
Toshiba PCX2000
Toshiba PCX2200
Toshiba DAZ8801F
Toshiba DAZ8811F
Toshiba DAZ8813F (PCX1100U)
Toshiba PCX2500
Zoom 5011
Zoom 5041
ZyXel Prestige 941
SMC SMC 8002
Aastra/Ericsson
In testing:
Motorola SB4220
US Robotics USR 6000
Intel CCCM 5200 (PCI Based CM) | |
|
 
CGMason14
Nj Roaddog
join:2002-07-22
Mountainside, NJ | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List said by Krona:
Intel CCCM 5200 (PCI Based CM)
Its about time internal cable modems came out. I've heard about them for years when the DOCSIS spec was finalized, but they never appeared until now. | |
|
makaze6
join:2002-01-04
| There has always been internal modems, just none that comcast wanted to use.
they may be a nightmare to work with though.
imagine, right now if lightnign hits yer cable line, it'll just blow out your modem.
imagine if the modem is in your pc! | |
|
 | |
| pmokover
join:2001-12-02
Ventnor City, NJ | said by makaze:
imagine, right now if lightnign hits yer cable line, it'll just blow out your modem.
You mean you don't have a surge suppressor on your cable line??? You should. | |
|
| | 
items
Is Items Good For America?
join:2002-06-26
Lancaster, PA
clubs:
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List I have found NONE that don't introduce any sort of noice ingress or signal loss. My modem already has one H of a time staying connected. All I need is another few dB of loss. What kind of miracle suppressor (brand, model) do you use?
Mike
--
As always, Talking Points Memo appreciates your comments.
/ hasps.net North America | |
|
| | | |
| | | rsi582
join:2001-08-03
Princeton, NJ | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List i have a toshiba pcx 1100, leased from and installed by comcast...funny, its not on the list, if the list is accurate ??? | |
|
| | | | 
jkonrad
Konman
Premium
join:2001-10-04
Mount Airy, MD | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List It's 7th from the bottom 
Toshiba DAZ8813F (PCX1100U) | |
|
|
| | Anon | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List mbernste
I can't get your modem list to work
When I click on your Approved Modem List link I cane briefly see the list then
I get to the next page with THIS | |
|
| | 
mbernste
Boosted
Premium,MVM
join:2001-06-30
Piscataway, NJ | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List It should be fixed now. Thanks for letting me know! | |
|
Teriwyn
Neko Girl
Premium
join:2002-06-06
Germantown, MD | I will try to keep you updated when that list changes, mbernste. I'll probably just dredge up this topic when doing so.. but if you want, I can shoot you a PM for you to update your page, as well. Just let me know. | |
|
|
mbernste
Boosted
Premium,MVM
join:2001-06-30
Piscataway, NJ
 ·Comcast
·Optimum Online
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List Whatever is easiest for you. I put a mail link on the listing page for any updates, so you can do it that way as well. Maybe we can post it in a separate posting and make it "sticky."
--
Visit and support DSLR/BBR on irc at irc.zerolimit.net #BBR Come on and chat! | |
|
JTRockville
Data Ho
Premium,MVM
join:2002-01-28
Rockville, MD
clubs: | Oooooooooooooooh, our first "sticky"! | |
|
DonLibesBad
join:1999-12-10
Potomac, MD
| Any chance of adding some additional columns? One to indicate whether or not each modem has user-accessible diagnostics/logging. Another column to indicate whether it has separate send/receive lights.
To start things off, the Toshiba PCX1100U (my modem, sigh) has neither. | |
|
| madasuk
join:2001-01-01
New Haven, CT
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List "To start things off, the Toshiba PCX1100U (my modem, sigh) has neither"
The PCX1100 has SNMP capability (user-accessible)....unfortunately Comcast disable it via the Config file
It has an IP address of 192.168.100.1 (you have to manually set your IP address to something in the same subnet) and you will have to connect directly to the Modem (without a Firewall box). You can disconnect the RF feed on the Cable modem, Power it off/on and then SNMP to it, but when you reconnect the RF, bye bye SNMP access
Unfortunately the data is useless without the Connection to Comcast
Regards
Graham | |
|
|
|
makaze6
join:2002-01-04 | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List I know its not a complete list, but go to www.neotechcc.org
they list the stuff there :P | |
|
T u r b o
@turbolink.net
| The cisco UBR904 is on the list (as is the UBR905 and UBR925), but absent is the UBR924. Is this simply an oversight, or does anybody think that the UBR924 wouldn't work?
I found a great place to get one cheap and was just about to order one. I can't imagine that the UBR904 works but the UBR924 doesn't, unless there's some very specific problem (or they've decided to disallow it for some reason)...
- Mike | |
|
|
makaze6
join:2002-01-04 | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List The cisco UBR 924 isnt on thier list. They probally wont provision it either. | |
|
Qumahlin
Never Enough Time
Premium,MVM
join:2001-10-05
united state | I'd say get the modem as long as their is a return policy. The SB2100 is not listed yet I know for a fact comcast will provision it just fine. | |
|
btdude
join:2002-01-28
Manassas, VA
| Not sure if someone has asked this already, but I went to the motorola web page just looking for whatever there may be for "firmware". I noticed that my trusty SB4100 has been discontinued? What's that about? I am hopeful that Comcast has already "updated" my modems firmware, before the model became obsolete. Do you think this is anything to worry about? Do I need the state of the art already? | |
|
| sunman9
join:2002-09-13
Nashville, TN
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List MY Toshiba pcx1100u works fine when it's hooked directly to the pc but I can't get to work throgh my linksys BEFSR41 V.2 Router. Linksys tech support says they have issues with this modem. If I want to use their Router I have to install a Hub between the moden and router.
Anybody else have this problem. | |
|
|
Tabasco Joe
@motorola.com | I didn't see anything on the WEB page about the 4100 being discontinued. Even if it was I wouldn't be worrying about firmware support going away. There are millions of them out there. | |
|
Teriwyn
Neko Girl
Premium
join:2002-06-06
Germantown, MD
| »www.gi.com/noflash/surfboard.html
(Accessed by www.motorola.com > "Products and Services" > "Cable modems" > "Motorola SURFboard® Cable Modems")
This location does list the 4100 as a discontinued model. | |
|
|
Tabasco Joe
@motorola.com | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List Interesting the internal page doesn't show it as discontinued but the factory says they don't build em any more. Thanks for the link. | |
|
| | 
beerbum
Premium
join:2000-05-06
Reading, PA
clubs:
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List nevermind
[text was edited by author 2002-09-21 00:38:48] | |
|
bulldog5
join:2002-03-05
Owings Mills, MD
| I just received my new DOCSIS 2 modem from Comcast. No major problems but they told me that if any modems are not DOCSIS 2 compatible, they won't work after Sept 30. Is this possible? For instance, they say that no Linksys Modems are DOCSIS 2.0 compatible. Anybody have any info on this. Thanks. | |
|
Qumahlin
Never Enough Time
Premium,MVM
join:2001-10-05
united state | bulldog. They mean docsis. Not docsis 2. gotta remember who you are talking to when talking to comcast heheh | |
|
| bulldog5
join:2002-03-05
Owings Mills, MD | Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List No they mean DOCIS 2.0. Increased upload speeds, etc. I have conformed and reconfirmed this with COmcast Modem Upgrade dept. DOCSIS 2.0 to be implemented on Sept 30. | |
|
| |
Qumahlin
Never Enough Time
Premium,MVM
join:2001-10-05
united state
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List said by bulldog5:
No they mean DOCIS 2.0. Increased upload speeds, etc. I have conformed and reconfirmed this with COmcast Modem Upgrade dept. DOCSIS 2.0 to be implemented on Sept 30.
Um comcast isn't offering increased uploads or any docsis 2.0 features. As someone stated comcast is not even docsis 1.1 and 90% of the modems out there are NOT 2.0 compliant
They are only cutting service to NON docsis modems..don't spread info that is false thanks | |
|
| | |
See 6 replies to this post |
|
Samandy
join:2002-07-08
Potomac, MD | OK, you have my attention. I own my SB4100, and I do not think it is DOCSIS 2 compliant. Does that mean I have a problem in a couple of weeks? | |
|
pazuzu5
join:2001-06-14
King Of Prussia, PA
| Yeah right. Comcast isn't even DOCSIS 1.1 yet. How are they gonna all of a sudden jump to 2.0? Show me an average cm customer who's actually seen a SB4220, let alone using one. FYI, none of the popular SurfBoards (4200, 4100) are DOCSIS 2.0 ready (go read their prod specs if you don't believe me). Unless Comcast wants to piss off a whole bunch of its customers who purchased their own modems, DOCSIS 2.0 is not gonna happen any time soon, certainly not by 9/30. | |
|
pazuzu5
join:2001-06-14
King Of Prussia, PA | Geez, only the SB4220 implements DOCSIS 2.0's A-TDMA. Nowhere is DOCSIS2.0 mentioned in the same sentence with SB4200/4101/4100 on Motorola's pages. One'd think if those could be used for DOCSIS 2.0, it'd be plastered all over the place by now. | |
|
| percosan
join:2002-03-13
San Francisco, CA
| Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List Good catch.
Yes, the 4220 does support A-TDMA as defined in DOCSIS 2.0. However, CableLabs has a very strict set of rules for how a company can use "2.0" in their literature. The 4220 is certainly capable of working as a 2.0 modem on cable plants that have a CMTS that is configured to use the A-TDMA flavor of 2.0.
Peter
said by pazuzu5  :
Geez, only the SB4220 implements DOCSIS 2.0's A-TDMA. Nowhere is DOCSIS2.0 mentioned in the same sentence with SB4200/4101/4100 on Motorola's pages. One'd think if those could be used for DOCSIS 2.0, it'd be plastered all over the place by now.
| |
|
gax2
Premium
join:2002-07-14
Philadelphia, PA
| surfboard wee
[text was edited by author 2002-10-05 22:20:55] | |
|
|
| (topic locked) |
|
·
Re: Approved Comcast Modems Modem List