DSL Oberst
join:2001-11-29
| reply to Kaltes
Re: Ignorance of the Law....
said by Kaltes  :
Very well said. I am glad to see that at least one other forum user here is shocked at how accepting most of the posters here are of saddling grandma and grandpa with the risk of federal prison simply because they aren't computer security experts.
All those same posters are sitting back armchair-quarterback/general style making legal commentary when they have absolutely no clue what they are talking about.
See my reply post to BosstonesOwn.
Very well, if the users are not to have responsibility, who should be responsible for the security of a user's machine?
That is truly the question at stake here, as that is the questions this entire bill is based on. |
|
str7
join:2003-07-04
canada
| It's not because you're machine is secure that you won't necessarily get hacked, just like it's not because you're car is "secure" that it will not be broken into (or home or whatever).
As an analogy, say that getting into a car to deposit 1 pound of drugs was easy to do and something that happened every day. Add to that those cars would be put on a list easily available to everyone (who could then call to say you have drugs in your car). In such a context, would a law that says if the police finds 1 pound of drug in your car make you instantly guilty regardless of circumstances of drug dealing, facing a 250000$ penalty and years of jail be well-thought? I don't think so. |
|
Kaltes
Premium
join:2002-12-04
Los Angeles, CA
| reply to DSL Oberst
said by DSL Oberst :
Very well, if the users are not to have responsibility, who should be responsible for the security of a user's machine?
How about making the HACKER the one responsible for the wrongdoing. Can't identify/locate the hacker? Tough. Don't punish the innocent party just because you want to punish SOMEONE.
If someone broke into your garage and stole your car, then used it to rob a bank, how would you like being thrown in jail for bank robbery, simply because you didnt go out of your way to constantly update the security on your garage? |
|
