Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
| Tweak and a question.
I tweaked myself and used Jazzman's tweak to see which one was better. So which one should I use. The larger rwin always has a better tweak test, no re-transmissions.
Jazzman's rwin tweak of 64240 always has tweak test re-transmissions. But Jazzman's tweak is much faster on a speed test to the same site.
What's your opinion. Is the tweak test more important, so use my tweak. Or does speed rule, and use Jazzman's tweak ?
Here's my results. This is just a fun question and isn't to serious.:) What's your opinion ?
»ny-monitor.dslreports.com/tweak/···a=normal
Seattle 4352 / 452
»/speedtests/43···70797670
»ny-monitor.dslreports.com/tweak/···a=normal
Seattle 4856 / 484
»/speedtests/48···70797910
--
b11ng00 ++ |
|
GeekNJ
Premium
join:2000-09-23
Waldwick, NJ
 ·Verizon FIOS
| I'd suggest using the lowest RWIN that gives you the most consistent speeds. You could up your RWIN to 999999 and you might see a speed improvement but if there's any retransmissions or packet loss anywhere between you and the machine you're communicating with, the 999999 will slow you down.
--
Have you tweaked your OOL connection? |
|
Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
1 edit | Just did another tweak test with my rwin, not Jazzman's. And the tweak test was right on. No re-transmissions or sacks sent. Look.:)
»ny-monitor.dslreports.com/tweak/···a=normal
--
b11ng00 ++
Edit. Now I'll try Jazzman''s tweak again. |
|
GeekNJ
Premium
join:2000-09-23
Waldwick, NJ
·Verizon FIOS
| Like I said, make it any number you want. Double what you have.
If there's no issues between you and the server it won't matter how high you make your RWIN.
--
Have you tweaked your OOL connection? |
|
Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
| Here's Jazz' tweak. Looks fine.
»ny-monitor.dslreports.com/tweak/···a=normal
I hear you GeekNJ. I'll use my tweak.
--
b11ng00 ++ |
|
Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
| I left window scaling on. And time stamping off. It fixed what was wrong with Jazzman's tweak. Would never have thought of that tweak.
--
b11ng00 ++ |
|
sargeeld
Sgm Retired
Premium
join:2002-12-16
Raeford, NC
clubs:  | reply to Ol_OO_ll_Ol
The time stamping off is probably what fixed it and not the Windows scaling. |
|
garp123
Premium
join:2001-12-06
Duncan, OK
| Scaling doesn't do anything with RWIN below 65536.
Timestamps are usually beneficial with very a large RWIN or very high latency.
Im with GeekNJ on this one. Use the lowest RWIN that alllows your speed.
--
Free the West Memphis Three |
|
Bubba
GIT-R-DONE
Premium,MVM
join:2002-08-19
Around, Us
 ·Comcast
| reply to Ol_OO_ll_Ol
said by Ol_OO_ll_Ol  :
What's your opinion. Is the tweak test more important, so use my tweak. Or does speed rule, and use Jazzman's tweak ?
My opinion is that your approach is boarding on not neccesarily questioning the ability of jazzman916 but attempting in a rather sarcastic way thumbing your nose at someone in the Tweak Forum that devotes many hours in assisting folks like yourself.
I read the part about...."This is just a fun question and isn't to serious"....so don't take my post wrong either. This is just a personal comment from someone who has always appreciated the work this Forum has dished out over the years I have been here. Hopefully jazzman916 will drop by and maybe he'll see a need to offer his comments of why he felt you would be better served with an RWIN of 64240
--
"I R 1" |
|
Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
1 edit | No. I'm not mocking Jazzman....
Using his tweak and taking the tweak test I kept seeing retransmissions and sacks sent.
I'm using this now. (See the Jpeg)
No retranmissions or sacks sent. It has something to do with the window scaling and time stamping I'm sure. Since when I set those and used Jazzman's tweak the tweak test was fine.
--
b11ng00 ++
Edit. Oops. My mtu is off. I'll fix that right now. |
|
Ol_OO_ll_Ol
Rock And Roll.
join:2003-11-23
Canada
1 edit |  My speed is sad.
»/speedtests/28···70856911
»ny-monitor.dslreports.com/tweak/···a=normal
--
b11ng00 ++
2889 / 56 |
|
Bubba
GIT-R-DONE
Premium,MVM
join:2002-08-19
Around, Us
·Comcast
| Perhaps if you would become pingable the Tweak Tester could be a more accurate representation.
It's part of step one in case you over looked it.
• 1. A Tweaks test from this page. Simply post the tests URL. Please make yourself pingable
Notes and recommendations:
Become pingable
if you need basic packet loss tests done
Check tweak FAQ
--
"I R 1" |
|
