nasadude
join:2001-10-05
Rockville, MD
 ·Comcast
| reply to Ronin4740
Re: If it's my hardware........
said by Ronin4740  :
...Yep, the modem is your hardware and yep you can use it to connect to the cable modem network but read the AUP for practically any cable internet service and you items which prohibit uncapping modems and/or modifying firmware.
I'm not questioning the AUP of the cable companies and obviously, if you rent your modem you have no right whatsoever to modify it.
However, if you buy and own your own modem, this amounts to the cable company restricting your use of your property. It's similar to the MPAA saying you can't skip commercials on a DVD you own or the phone company saying you can only make 5 phone calls an hour over our network.
If they don't want people uncapping their modems, maybe they should move control of the caps to the CMTS. Or not let people use their own modems. |
|
Aggie Dan
Stop... Reverse That.
Premium
join:2001-01-30
Frisco, TX
clubs:
| said by nasadude :
or the phone company saying you can only make 5 phone calls an hour over our network.
Or... Ummm... Maybe having the cell phone company restricting the number of minutes you can use on their network?
Outrageous I tell you.
[/sarcasm]
--
Note : The statements made by myself are my own and not the opinions of my employer or of my coworkers. 14.327 GHz Crunching Power | The Ryan Foundation for MPS Children |
|
AthlGrond
Premium,MVM
join:2002-04-25
Aurora, CO
·Comcast
1 edit | reply to nasadude
said by nasadude :
However, if you buy and own your own modem, this amounts to the cable company restricting your use of your property. It's similar to the MPAA saying you can't skip commercials on a DVD you own or the phone company saying you can only make 5 phone calls an hour over our network.
I disagree.
The cable company places no restriction on what you do with your equipment, they place restrictions on the type of equipment that is allowed connected to their network. (Mod your modem all you like, they don't care so long as you don't try to plug it in to their network.)
So it's not really a restriction on what you can do with your property, it's more a restriction on what you can do with Their's. |
|
Clocker1000
join:2001-05-24
Sterling Heights, MI
·Comcast
·WOW Internet and C..
| I agree. It's just like the laws we have with respect to driving cars.
My car can go over 100mph but I'm restricted with how I can drive it on my 'network' of roads (which I pay for with my tax dollars).
The same goes for my cable modem. I can use it on the network but I better conform with the network rules. Some people just have to have something to bitch and complain about I guess.
C |
|
tonekilla
Pipe Dreams
Premium
join:2003-07-26
Gunnison, MS
clubs: | reply to Aggie Dan
What are you talking about? they want you to use the hell out of their network, so they can then charge the hell out of you.
--
Gotta love SBC's 6000/608 plan for $44.99! |
|
Aggie Dan
Stop... Reverse That.
Premium
join:2001-01-30
Frisco, TX
clubs:
| If you look at the higher charges once you go over your time allotted by your package as a penalty... Then the overage charges are similar to any fines or loss of network connection that your cable company would do.
Granted, the cable company takes a harsher stance. But, they are in effect the same thing.
This is, of course, neglecting the prepaid cell phones. Once those run out of minutes, you're done until you go buy some more minutes.
--
Note : The statements made by myself are my own and not the opinions of my employer or of my coworkers. 14.327 GHz Crunching Power | The Ryan Foundation for MPS Children |
|
Jeremy341
Bye
Premium
join:2000-01-06
localhost
| reply to nasadude
said by nasadude :
However, if you buy and own your own modem, this amounts to the cable company restricting your use of your property.
You can do whatever the hell you want with your own cable modem, and nobody will say a word. But once you plug it into your cable company's network, you're using their service, and you're agreeing to their rules. If you don't like their rules, you can lease a modem, or go somewhere else. |
|
insomniac
Oh Yeah
Premium
join:2002-09-22
Naperville, IL
clubs:
 ·AT&T Midwest
| reply to AthlGrond
said by AthlGrond :
The cable company places no restriction on what you do with your equipment, they place restrictions on the type of equipment that is allowed connected to their network. (Mod your modem all you like, they don't care so long as you don't try to plug it in to their network.)
That's right. I think this is the same thing as blue-boxing on my phone line, except the penalties for stealing phone service can be harsher since there are specific laws against it.
--
If everything seems to be going well, you've obviously overlooked something. |
|
pilferk3
join:2004-02-11
Pine Meadow, CT
| reply to nasadude
I'm not sure that's a valid analogy. People own DirectTV set tops, yet DirecTV controls content to that box. There are plenty of content providers who "control" the content via some sort of "control" on consumer owned equipment.
There is consumer choice: Connect to the providers content and allow them some measure of control over the equipment you own OR choose not to conncet to the providers content. Thus, the reason for the EULA/TOS agreement.... |
|
