dslreports logo
 story category
Game of Thrones Finale Sets Piracy Record
Downloaded More than a Million Times in One Day
Last weekend's "Game of Thrones" series finale set piracy records, with the program being downloaded by more than a million people in one day. According to Torrent Freak, the show set BitTorrent records specifically, with some 170,000 people sharing one copy of the show simultaneously. The massive, unprecedented piracy comes as HBO continues to refuse to make their streaming platform HBO Go available to users without a traditional cable connection. The show is expected to surpass 5 million BitTorrent downloads over the next week, with most of those downloaders coming from Australia, followed by the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom.
view:
topics flat nest 

inteller
Sociopaths always win.
join:2003-12-08
Tulsa, OK

inteller

Member

give me standalone HBOGO

and this "problem" will go away.

tshirt
Premium Member
join:2004-07-11
Snohomish, WA
kudos:7

tshirt

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

will all of you pay $150-300 a year for HBOGO?
year after year?
will it discourage others from buying HBO cable packages?
talz13
join:2006-03-15
Avon, OH

talz13

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

Or could be like many people who sign up for HBO for 2-3 months out of the year when their favorite show is airing.

delusion ftl
@comcast.net

delusion ftl to tshirt

Anon

to tshirt
This is the wrong way to do the math. If HBO were to offer internet video they could choose 20 dollars a month and get maybe a million people, or they could choose 5 dollars a month and get 10 million subscribers. Which one do you think they will choose?

They could also charge 1000 dollars a month and get 1000 subscribers. At some point their cost/return normalizes and they maximize revenue. If I were to guess, it would be around the 5-10 dollar a month rate.

In any case there is likely millions of dollars a year left on the table that they ignore by not offering internet subscriptions.

If they were really smart, they would do something like this:

Game of Thrones $2 a month
True Blood $2 a month
Boardwalk Empire $2 a month
Eastbound & Down $2 a month
The Newsroom $2 a month

All current HBO series 7.50 a month
All HBO access 10 a month.

ITALIAN926
join:2003-08-16
kudos:2

ITALIAN926

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

Oh I see, when prices come down, people will stop stealing these shows, right? NOT. People will continue this crap whether HBO cost $15 a month, or $2 a show. Lets get real here.

wesm
Premium Member
join:1999-07-29
Seattle, WA
·CenturyLink

wesm to inteller

Premium Member

to inteller
said by inteller:

and this "problem" will go away.

Don't consume content you didn't pay for and this problem will "never exist." If HBO's business model is antithetical to you, then don't partake. Only staying away from things that make HBO money--such as encouraging others to watch their shows and subsequently buy the DVDs--will encourage HBO to see what you perceive as the error of their ways and, hopefully, change it. This isn't life or death, it's a TV show.

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by wesm:

said by inteller:

and this "problem" will go away.

Don't consume content you didn't pay for and this problem will "never exist."

I suppose you're a big believer in abstinence education as well.

wesm
Premium Member
join:1999-07-29
Seattle, WA
·CenturyLink

wesm

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by El Quintron:

I suppose you're a big believer in abstinence education as well.

Don't be rude; whether or not to pay to watch a television show is in a completely different area code than reproductive education.

Besides, no, I don't.

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by wesm:

said by El Quintron:

I suppose you're a big believer in abstinence education as well.

Don't be rude; whether or not to pay to watch a television show is in a completely different area code than reproductive education.

Besides, no, I don't.

A blanket statement like "don't pirate" really isn't helpful either.

HBO wasn't even available in Canada, nor was its entire catalogue through its partners until 2008, there's a whole market issue that you ignored by making your initial statement.

wesm
Premium Member
join:1999-07-29
Seattle, WA
·CenturyLink

wesm

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by El Quintron:

A blanket statement like "don't pirate" really isn't helpful either.

HBO wasn't even available in Canada, nor was its entire catalogue through its partners until 2008, there's a whole market issue that you ignored by making your initial statement.

And the sixth season of Murdoch Mysteries isn't available in the United States unless you're a U.S. viewer who subscribes to Comcast in certain areas of the country (which, until recently, I wasn't) that provides CBC. It sucks, is annoying, and means I can't find out whether or not that time traveler was full of crap, but them's the breaks. Again, it's just TV so I'll wait until Netflix or somebody here gets it. Fortunately, Continuum is still picked up by Syfy.

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

1 edit

bionicRod

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by wesm:

Again, it's just TV so I'll wait until Netflix or somebody here gets it.

The difference being that Netflix (edit: streaming) will never, ever get Game of Thrones. You have to shell out for a top tier cable subscription every month just to watch it legally, there is no other option. Piracy will continue on this scale because of that.

PaulHikeS2
join:2003-03-06
Fitchburg, MA

PaulHikeS2

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by bionicRod:

said by wesm:

Again, it's just TV so I'll wait until Netflix or somebody here gets it.

The difference being that Netflix (edit: streaming) will never, ever get Game of Thrones. You have to shell out for a top tier cable subscription every month just to watch it legally, there is no other option. Piracy will continue on this scale because of that.

Not true. Buy the DVDs. Rent the DVDs. Borrow DVDs from library. All are legal, and while abailability of the last two may vary, in this country everyone can buy the DVDs.

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

bionicRod

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by PaulHikeS2:

said by bionicRod:

said by wesm:

Again, it's just TV so I'll wait until Netflix or somebody here gets it.

The difference being that Netflix (edit: streaming) will never, ever get Game of Thrones. You have to shell out for a top tier cable subscription every month just to watch it legally, there is no other option. Piracy will continue on this scale because of that.

Not true. Buy the DVDs. Rent the DVDs. Borrow DVDs from library. All are legal, and while abailability of the last two may vary, in this country everyone can buy the DVDs.

Season 3 is out on DVD? No. And if the past two years is any indication, it won't be until early 2014. Until then the only options are an HBO subscription (and all the other channels you have to buy before you can get that) and piracy. Netflix Streaming will never get GoT.

PaulHikeS2
join:2003-03-06
Fitchburg, MA

1 edit

PaulHikeS2

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by bionicRod:

Season 3 is out on DVD? No. And if the past two years is any indication, it won't be until early 2014. Until then the only options are an HBO subscription (and all the other channels you have to buy before you can get that) and piracy. Netflix Streaming will never get GoT.

Of course it's not out yet. What, you need it today?

I guess you also have the same issue with every single movie that comes out for theatrical release. Until it comes out on DVD/streaming services (which happen around the same time), you're choices are paying to see the movie or piracy.

(edit - changed text as a later post stated that you do not condone piracy - sorry!)

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

2 edits

bionicRod

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by PaulHikeS2:

said by bionicRod:

Season 3 is out on DVD? No. And if the past two years is any indication, it won't be until early 2014. Until then the only options are an HBO subscription (and all the other channels you have to buy before you can get that) and piracy. Netflix Streaming will never get GoT.

Of course it's not out yet. What, you need it today?

I guess you also have the same issue with every single movie that comes out for theatrical release. Until it comes out on DVD/streaming services (which happen around the same time), you're choices are paying to see the movie or piracy.

While the system has some limitations, your answer speaks more to your character.

FWIW, I am all over these boards denouncing piracy every chance I get (check out my first post in this thread). I have an HBO subscription and have bought the blu ray sets of both seasons of GoT, and have pre-ordered Season 3. I am merely pointing out that HBO's severe locking down of their content and lack of legal means to consume it encourages piracy. It's common sense.

(edit - removing text to play nice)
bionicRod

bionicRod to PaulHikeS2

Premium Member

to PaulHikeS2
said by PaulHikeS2:

said by bionicRod:

Season 3 is out on DVD? No. And if the past two years is any indication, it won't be until early 2014. Until then the only options are an HBO subscription (and all the other channels you have to buy before you can get that) and piracy. Netflix Streaming will never get GoT.

Of course it's not out yet. What, you need it today?

I guess you also have the same issue with every single movie that comes out for theatrical release. Until it comes out on DVD/streaming services (which happen around the same time), you're choices are paying to see the movie or piracy.

(edit - changed text as a later post stated that you do not condone piracy - sorry!)

Earlier posts stated it too, but thanks . But piracy in movies and other tv shows happen, sure, and no I don't condone that either. The reason HBO continues to top these most pirated lists is the level of control they exert over their content. Movies don't generally have to wait almost a year after theatrical release to be released for rental, and some tv episodes are available on Netflix or other streaming methods very soon after they have aired. The result is lower piracy rates than, say, Game of Thrones, which gets a LOT of attention but lacks methods of legal viewing for very long periods of time. Again, piracy is bad, but if it's easier to pirate than to view legally, piracy rates are going to rise because of it. If HBO wants to curb piracy (and it has been suggested by others in this thread that piracy is less expensive than other options for HBO) they need to change their business model and ease restrictions on content. If not, that's their business, but these piracy rates shouldn't come as a surprise.

88615298
Premium Member
join:2004-07-28
West Tenness

88615298 to PaulHikeS2

Premium Member

to PaulHikeS2
said by PaulHikeS2:

Not true. Buy the DVDs. Rent the DVDs. Borrow DVDs from library. All are legal, and while abailability of the last two may vary, in this country everyone can buy the DVDs.

Oh can I get the DVDs now? Nope. Heck you can't even download episodes at places like Amazon day after air like just about every other series not on HBO. Season 3 won't be available until around February. Long after everyone has torrented it. That right there would cut down on a a lot of piracy. Though I do have an issue about paying $4 per episode. Heck I have an issue with regular shows being $3 per episode.

elwoodblues
Elwood Blues
Premium Member
join:2006-08-30
Somewhere in
kudos:2

elwoodblues to bionicRod

Premium Member

to bionicRod
Here is where i stand on the issue, would i pay 10-15 month for HBO, yes. Can I no? Up here in Canada I have to shell out over $100 a month just to get to HBO which is bundled with the movie channels at some 20 or more a month.

Now I can buy it from iTunes , at $3.50/episode, and that's $35 bucks for ONE SERIES!!!!, but not in Canada.

So what's my choice? Go without, wait till the BR shows up next Winter? After the shows have been dissected, blogged analysed and speculation over S4 starts?

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron to wesm

Premium Member

to wesm
said by wesm:

but them's the breaks.

If I can't buy it, then I'm pirating it, and them's breaks.

markofmayhem
Why not now?
Premium Member
join:2004-04-08
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:5

markofmayhem

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by El Quintron:

said by wesm:

but them's the breaks.

If I can't buy it, then I'm pirating it, and them's breaks.

It's for sale, so buy it. HBO did not lock this title down.

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by markofmayhem:

It's for sale, so buy it. HBO did not lock this title down.

You're missing the point.

markofmayhem
Why not now?
Premium Member
join:2004-04-08
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:5

markofmayhem

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by El Quintron:

said by markofmayhem:

It's for sale, so buy it. HBO did not lock this title down.

You're missing the point.

I'm not, I'm trying to defend the definition of "locked down". There is certainly an argument that the premium for earlier viewership is extreme, but this is not a case where it is "not available" or locked down to alternative legal consumption.

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by markofmayhem:

There is certainly an argument that the premium for earlier viewership is extreme, but this is not a case where it is "not available" or locked down to alternative legal consumption.

Having to wait for it to be released on DVD/BluRay is not in line with what consumers want, that being said, HBOs main income stream isn't from cable subs, it's from being bundled with other channels which is why they mainly look the other way when it comes to piracy.

markofmayhem
Why not now?
Premium Member
join:2004-04-08
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:5

markofmayhem

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by El Quintron:

said by markofmayhem:

There is certainly an argument that the premium for earlier viewership is extreme, but this is not a case where it is "not available" or locked down to alternative legal consumption.

Having to wait for it to be released on DVD/BluRay is not in line with what consumers want

I'm not so sure that path is correct either:
said by link :

5.4 million viewers tuned in to "Mhysa" to witness the fallout from last week's much-buzzed-about "Red Wedding" episode. That falls just short of the season's peak viewership: The 5.5 million viewers who tuned in for episode six, "The Climb."

The fantasy saga has shown steady and impressive ratings growth through its first three seasons. Season 3 averaged 5.16 million viewers for first run episodes, up from Season 2's average of 3.8 million viewers and Season 1's 2.52 million viewers.

HBO also reported a average audience of 13.6 million viewers for "Game of Thrones" Season 3 over all network airings, on demand, HBO Go and DVR, an increase of two million viewers from Season 2.

Piracy isn't high enough for the financial-loss monster to be a motivator. The movement is growing and WILL eventually take a foothold to liberate availability of entertainment past the current pay models, but Game of Thrones Season 3 is not it...

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by markofmayhem:

Piracy isn't high enough for the financial-loss monster to be a motivator.

I've stated as much before, HBOs current cash flow isn't from subs, and it explains how they can hold on to the legacy tv model for now.
elefante72
join:2010-12-03
East Amherst, NY
·Verizon FiOS

elefante72 to markofmayhem

Member

to markofmayhem
Well if you count streaming or buying the physical media sometime in March of 2014 not locked down, I dont know what is and like $80 for the bluray. If you realize there are only 10 episodes that works out to like $8 an episode, which IMHO is crazy high. Of course I wont buy it, but if you do the math that is a serious ask considering that I can get a full year of Netflix for just the blu ray of GOT.

On the other hand, Time Warner owns it, and can go to market as they please, so it's a corporate decision...Godspeed to living in the 18th century. For the vocal minority a huge swath (20+mil just in the US) blindly subscribe, so they don't want to disrupt that very profitable channel model (they can run reruns during the offseason to keep subs or allow hbogo). So I get that for now being flexible does not make sense as they subscriber base it steady and large. If 6 million pirate, how many of them subscribe to HBO/HBOGO, buy stuff, read the books. It's not a zero sum game, and they know it. Look at how draconian Disney is with their films and how much $$$ they make on ancillary product...

If I recall in the last ten years, my top ten show are almost entirely from the Time Warner properties, so you have to pay for quality. I mean you can get teenagers running around a stage or some tropical island for "free" on broadcast.

They must have sent some of their execs to Microsoft to poison the well over there too

RARPSL
join:1999-12-08
Suffern, NY

RARPSL to wesm

Member

to wesm
said by wesm:

Fortunately, Continuum is still picked up by Syfy.

With only a 5 week embargo/delay. While a delay as opposed to running a show as it airs in its original network is nice, a slight delay is betting than holding a show back until it has finished airing. IOW: A 5 week delay is better than them running a year old (and already canceled) show like Primeval: New World.

My opinion on the "Piracy" issue tends to be it is not stealing to BT something that the provider is unwilling to provide to you which you are willing to buy. So long as HBO is unwilling to HBOGO sell me GoT (or some other of their series) they have no lo$$ if I BitTorrent the episodes (which I do not since I am not interested in that show). You can/should not claim a lost sale on something you are unwilling to sell.

Do not claim that an eventual sale of a show on DVD/BluRay next year counts as an offer to sell me the show. They are different items. The disks are an archived copy of the show to allow viewing it after it has ended its season run. HBOGO represents giving access to the episodes AS THEY AIR. BTW: Most DVD/BR sets get released just after the last episode of a season airs or a month or 2 after that point.

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

bionicRod

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by RARPSL:

My opinion on the "Piracy" issue tends to be it is not stealing to BT something that the provider is unwilling to provide to you which you are willing to buy. So long as HBO is unwilling to HBOGO sell me GoT (or some other of their series) they have no lo$$ if I BitTorrent the episodes (which I do not since I am not interested in that show). You can/should not claim a lost sale on something you are unwilling to sell.

But they ARE willing to sell it to you (if you liked GoT, which I understand you do not). You can sign up and pay for HBO right now and watch Game of Thrones to your heart's content on HBO GO, along with everything else that service provides. You just don't like the terms. Don't confuse that as refusal to sell. They're selling; you're refusing to buy.

I am very in the middle on this argument. HBO's policies are encouraging piracy, but piracy is still wrong IMO.

88615298
Premium Member
join:2004-07-28
West Tenness

88615298

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by bionicRod:

But they ARE willing to sell it to you (if you liked GoT, which I understand you do not). You can sign up and pay for HBO right now and watch Game of Thrones to your heart's content on HBO GO, along with everything else that service provides. You just don't like the terms. Don't confuse that as refusal to sell. They're selling; you're refusing to buy.

I am very in the middle on this argument. HBO's policies are encouraging piracy, but piracy is still wrong IMO.

The big issue is that getting HBO which is only $15 dollars also requires a pay TV package which is in excess of $60 a month or more. Essentially making HBO closer to $75 or more which you have to admit it a bit price gougey.

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

bionicRod

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by 88615298:

said by bionicRod:

But they ARE willing to sell it to you (if you liked GoT, which I understand you do not). You can sign up and pay for HBO right now and watch Game of Thrones to your heart's content on HBO GO, along with everything else that service provides. You just don't like the terms. Don't confuse that as refusal to sell. They're selling; you're refusing to buy.

I am very in the middle on this argument. HBO's policies are encouraging piracy, but piracy is still wrong IMO.

The big issue is that getting HBO which is only $15 dollars also requires a pay TV package which is in excess of $60 a month or more. Essentially making HBO closer to $75 or more which you have to admit it a bit price gougey.

Oh yeah that's what I have been saying. It's a piracy inducing model. But to say "It's not for sale so I must pirate" is a tad disingenuous.

88615298
Premium Member
join:2004-07-28
West Tenness

88615298

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by bionicRod:

Oh yeah that's what I have been saying. It's a piracy inducing model. But to say "It's not for sale so I must pirate" is a tad disingenuous.

I don't agree with that either. But you also need to live in reality. look at prohibition. Sure the idea that we'd have a society where people wouldn't feel the need to get drunk sounds great. FORCING that on everyone didn't work out the way they planned. So eventually even the most staunchest prohibitionist admitted they needed to let people legally drink.

In a perfect world people wouldn't pirate if they couldn't get access to their content. In the REAL world that doesn't happen and to think if you only just allow people to access content one way legally that people will take that route, is just fantasy. Companies like HBO are like prohibitionists 6 years into prohibition when it was CLEAR to everyone else it wasn't working and in fact making things worse and they just kept saying "It'll work give it time".

As I said I make a HUGE distinction between the "I want everything for free" pirate. And the person that says "Hey HBO I'm willing to give you the SAME $15 if you would just take my money."
Crookshanks
join:2008-02-04
Binghamton, NY

Crookshanks

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

If prohibition had passed fifty years ago instead of one hundred years ago it would still be in effect, even with all the negative consequences that came with it.

If anyone is inclined to dispute this assumption on my part I have a four word rebuttal for you: "The War on Drugs"

A pity we've grown so stubborn that we're lost the ability to learn from and fix our mistakes...
Crookshanks

Crookshanks to 88615298

Member

to 88615298
said by 88615298:

The big issue is that getting HBO which is only $15 dollars also requires a pay TV package which is in excess of $60 a month or more. Essentially making HBO closer to $75 or more which you have to admit it a bit price gougey.

You make a valid point, though I suspect the number of people willing to pay for just HBO without basic cable is very very small. People are either TV junkies (i.e., willing to write that fat check every month) or they're not. I fall into the second category; I get by just fine with my eight OTA channels.

Actually I was laughing about this a few hours ago at a friends house.

"Here, have the remote."
"Ok, thanks."
[page down]
[page down]
[page down]

It's just like being at home, there's nothing worth watching, the only difference is it takes longer to figure that out when you have 100+ channels than it does when you have eight.

bionicRod
Funkier than a mohair disco ball.
Premium Member
join:2009-07-06
united state
kudos:2

bionicRod to wesm

Premium Member

to wesm
I don't think HBO's model is unethical (anitethical? :P), it's their channel to do with as they please. I DO think it's stupid, antiquated, and encourages piracy. Please don't take this as me excusing people who pirate...I don't. But making content easier to access and afford reduces piracy. Locking it down only encourages it.

El Quintron
We must pray to be eaten first.
Premium Member
join:2008-04-28
Momtario
kudos:4

El Quintron

Premium Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

said by bionicRod:

But making content easier to access and afford reduces piracy. Locking it down only encourages it.

Agreed, but the CEO of HBO has stated that losses due to piracy are less than losses they would incur if they abandoned their current model which isn't to go after TV Subs but to get other channels to pay to be bundled with HBO, which is where the bulk of their income comes from.

I did read this in a reputable interview last year, so I'll try and post the link here or PM you with it at some point.

tshirt
Premium Member
join:2004-07-11
Snohomish, WA
kudos:7
·Xfinity

tshirt to bionicRod

Premium Member

to bionicRod
said by bionicRod:

... But making content easier to access and afford reduces piracy. Locking it down only encourages it.

We could stop bank robbers by giving the money first. But we have to set some standard, and the people that own the money put it in the bank for safe keeping and to earn interest.
The people that own the rights (actors, director, investors, even HBO) put the show they own on that restricted channel for safekeeping and to earn a return on their investment in the product.

If either gets stolen they will cease to have a reason to use the bank use HBO( I think that's what you are hoping) but if no safekeeping and return is available they will just stop making them.

Pirates steal from the content owners, but their failure to pay for the use of it increases the share that honest viewers pay
ie Pirates steal from YOU.

88615298
Premium Member
join:2004-07-28
West Tenness

88615298 to wesm

Premium Member

to wesm
said by wesm:

Don't consume content you didn't pay for and this problem will "never exist."

Listen as people will tell you I'm very anti-pirating. If you don't want to pay for something you should then you should do without. I also see a HUGE difference between the person that says "I should get everything for free because I'm entitled" and one that says "I'm willing to pay you the SAME money( or even more money ) you're getting now if you just make it available to me in a more convenient way"

The first person won't pay for HBO no matter how HBO offers it, the 2nd one would. So offering HBOGo won't stop the first pirate but it will stop the 2nd. So if some company has problem and there is a reasonable solution and they refuse to use that solution it's hard for me to feel sorry for them.

There fear that cable companies will stop offering HBO if they offer HBOGO standalone are unfounded and untrue.
Crookshanks
join:2008-02-04
Binghamton, NY

Crookshanks

Member

Re: give me standalone HBOGO

I'm somewhat skeptical that there is a statistically significant number of people who engage in piracy solely for want of legal means to obtain their content. Such people do exist; I have been one of them in the past. I used to pirate Dexter because it wasn't available in what I perceived to be a reasonable amount of time. While this was happening I was simultaneously forking over $3/episode without complaint to obtain Breaking Bad from Amazon.

I'm just skeptical that there are enough of these people to make a significant impact on Time Warner's bottom line, assuming they opted to release their episodes on Amazon/iTunes/etc. It might even have a negative impact on their bottom line if it adversely affected their relationship with the MSOs and other content providers. Someone alluded to this in another comment on this story.

One can assume that the folks at Time Warner have at least studied this issue, and that as a for-profit company they would give it a go if it had a reasonable chance of enhancing their bottom line.
FloridaBoy
join:2009-06-22
Bradenton, FL

FloridaBoy to inteller

Member

to inteller
How much are you willing to pay for it??

•••••

markofmayhem
Why not now?
Premium Member
join:2004-04-08
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:5

markofmayhem to inteller

Premium Member

to inteller
said by inteller:

and this "problem" will go away.

Game of Thrones is on Netflix, why is there any problem?

•••••••
noclip
join:2004-04-20
Fairfax, VA

noclip

Member

And it was all for nought

Waste of bandwidth really...It was such a boring episode. Ironically VZ gave me free HBO last week so I could watch it 100% legit.
Wilsdom
join:2009-08-06

Wilsdom

Member

Re: And it was all for nought

Keep on getting sucked into watching that show, and it is always the same poorly written padded lameness. Chick entertainment in disguise, for a society that is a girls' workhouse in disguise

88615298
Premium Member
join:2004-07-28
West Tenness

88615298 to noclip

Premium Member

to noclip
Sorry the 2 of you don't get the show. not everything needs to be stupid action action mindless action with no point other that to show blood and guts. If you actually follow the story the "boring" parts have a point. Sorry if it's too high brow for you.
zod5000
join:2003-10-21
Victoria, BC
·TELUS
·Juce Communicati..
·Shaw

zod5000

Member

HBO costs too much.

HBO makes some pretty decent content.

The problem is they rarely have more than one show airing at any given time that I would watch.

Game of Thrones, then True Blood, Then Boardwalk Empire. They are all great shows.

I can't see myself pay 15/month for one show. I'd rather buy the bluray when its done airing and have it in my collection.

ie. A streaming HBO option would have to be cheaper than what my cableco charges for it (for me to consider it).

••••

justinsoup
Premium Member
join:2002-03-18
Dallas, TX

justinsoup

Premium Member

Finale

In the description below the tag it says "series" finale. I thought that there were going to be 4 seasons. I hope there is 4 seasons.

••••••

baineschile
2600 ways to live
Premium Member
join:2008-05-10
Sterling Heights, MI

1 edit

baineschile

Premium Member

Screw this article

So, a company runs their business as they see fit; and because people think its too expensive, its ok to steal (edit: its technically copyright violation, as pointed out below. Either way, against the law)?

I live in Michigan, and right now, we are averaging the highest gas prices in the country (sans Hawaii). Maybe I should just steal some gas, because I think its too expensive.

If HBO saw profit in a standalone service, they would do it. People engaging in ILLEGAL ACTIVITY shouldnt sway a company to do things differently. Look at the previous article on this very newspage; Microsoft is being chastized for DRM and all the limitations, and Playstation is being applauded for doing the opposite.

I am fairly certain of one thing. People are going to steal regardless of how much something costs.

•••••••

mikesterr
join:2008-04-18
Lake Mary, FL

mikesterr

Member

Not supporting Piracy but....

While I agree that illegal action is not the answer to this just because its expensive. I just want to point out to those that say.. .then get HBO its not quite that simple. First if you have a limited basic subscription you can't just get HBO you have to have a higher tier basic, then you have to rent the cable box that goes with that higher tier, if you want it in HD you have to rent a more expensive box and sometimes pay a premium on the basic fees too, then you can subscribe to HBO. I think what people are rebelling against is not HBO having a premium product at a premium price but the fact that you have to buy the cable companies other products just to be eligible for HBO. I compare it to I want to own a BMW but if I buy one I am forced to only use Toll roads. Although BMW only roads might be a good market for buying one.
Taget
join:2004-07-29

Taget

Member

Real pirates...

..rape and reave and pay the iron price for their copy of Game of Thrones!


How about ..