site Search:


 
   
story category
Who's Afraid of DSL?
No cable reductions in face of price cuts
by Karl Bode Monday 26-Jan-2004 tags: prices · stats · world
Industry stat farm Point-Topic notes that despite DSL price cuts, the cable industry still isn't flinching. While we've been quick to point out some competitive markets where we are seeing short-term cable deals, cable execs in general aren't scared enough to begin broader-scale price cuts. This Point-Topic analysis of 16 cable operators in 13 countries shows only a 0.69 reduction in prices. The firm notes that Canada remains the least expensive broadband market world-wide. Not only that; as evident by Bell Canada's push to 3mbps as a standard, their DSL providers are doing more than simply slashing prices and hoping for the best.



Point topic used a formula dubbed 'Purchasing Power Parity' to compare bandwidth prices around the world instead of focusing on exchange rate (though they claim the pattern is similar regardless). Sweden, Hong Kong and the UK fall behind Canada but slightly ahead of the U.S. in terms of inexpensive cable bandwidth.

view: topics flat text 
Post a:
junglists

join:2004-01-14
Sudbury, ON

1 edit

Oh Canada

oh Canada!!
We will take cheap broadband in exchange for the cold.
nemmesis

join:2002-12-19
Washington

1 edit

Re: Oh Canada

maybe they need to get there advertisments out more.
up here where i live there is DSL avalable but you wouldnt know it.
on the flip side though cable has deals and commercials all the time about there service. i dont see any commercials besides ride the light from qwest,but it never says anything about dsl,high speed internet or anything.
and there even cheaper than cable by 20 bucks you would think they would want to let customers know. cause i know alot of poeple that just want somthing faster than dial up.
and 640 /256 would be just peachy for them to the almost double price from cable. so in my opinion they need to advertise better.

Gbcue
Almost P.E.
Premium
join:2001-09-30
Santa Rosa, CA
kudos:8

Where's the fibre?

Who's afraid of fibre? All the DSL and Cable providers!

rameus
Who's got my pickle?
Premium
join:2001-01-28
Martinez, CA
Reviews:
·SONIC.NET

Re: Where's the fibre?

Why would they roll out FTTC or FTTH when lighting up RTs is so much cheaper at this point? Besides, even if they did and sold 10.0/10.0 connection plans, the modems and or PCs would be the bottleneck. Current consumer RAM and VRAM couldn't process data that fast. You wouldn't be able to see the difference.
--
One ping only, Please.

sickened

@dsl.emhril.ameritech

Re: Where's the fibre?

all of my computers here handle 100mbit LAN just fine.

My old 200mhz pentium machine seems to cope with serving up files at around 11,600 kbytes a second...

Consumer RAM is capable of gigabytes a second bandwidth.. the bottleneck is the network card/linespeed. And it probably will be for a long time.

I dont see japanese ISP's with 100mbit fiber having problems with ONU's coping...

Vamp
5c077
Premium
join:2003-01-28
MD
kudos:1

1 edit
said by rameus:
Why would they roll out FTTC or FTTH when lighting up RTs is so much cheaper at this point? Besides, even if they did and sold 10.0/10.0 connection plans, the modems and or PCs would be the bottleneck. Current consumer RAM and VRAM couldn't process data that fast. You wouldn't be able to see the difference.

thats the funniest post I ever read... you do know besides the processor the ram is the fastest component in your PC? like said above they are in the Gigabits/sec speed. The bottlenecks would be in the HD, and network equipment.

Maybe you should do more research on ram before posting something so stupid

Edit: and the differents might not be so great when browsing, but the latency and transfer speeds will be about 10 times better.
--
Best game ever > »www.desertcombat.com

Gbcue
Almost P.E.
Premium
join:2001-09-30
Santa Rosa, CA
kudos:8
Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
You wouldn't see the difference between 200 megs/sec and 1000 megs/sec since your HD's can only handle about 150 megs/sec eh?

But you WOULD see the difference from 1.1 megs/sec(what I have), and 100 megs/sec.
--
I want to go back to HIGH SCHOOL! My BLOG! N B 4 DA' LOCK! | In the great state of Kahlifoania.
army5

join:2002-04-30
Oklahoma City, OK

Re: Where's the fibre?

Don't get Megabits (Mb) confused with Megabytes (MB). For example, common DSL downloads are 1.5 Mbps (Megabits/sec) where common data transfer rates for HD's are 133 MB/sec (Megabytes/sec). A Megabit is 1 million bits. A Megabyte is 1 million bytes. 8 bits = 1 byte. As you can see there is a huge difference.

Jeff
--
To fill the hour, that is true happiness - Ralph Waldo Emerson
Freezone

join:2000-09-29
Southfield, MI

Re: Where's the fibre?

HD's can not tranfers anywhere near their interface specs. Except burst to and from the buffers. With a 100Mb connection, who needs a hd anyway? Just get everything realtime
army5

join:2002-04-30
Oklahoma City, OK

Re: Where's the fibre?

I'm not sure what your point is. I was trying to explain that MB does not equal Mb. I wasn't getting into the technical specs of HD's. Rather I was using common numbers used in the industry as performance marks (i.e. ATA 100/133) as a reference to my explanation.
--
To fill the hour, that is true happiness - Ralph Waldo Emerson
dirtrat4

join:2001-10-08
Woodland, CA
Why should they be afraid of that? Fibre is a LONG way from being in every household. MANY people still don't even have access to cable and DSL yet and are stuck with dial-up.

said by Gbcue:
Who's afraid of fibre? All the DSL and Cable providers!


StrykerX
StrykerX -GMLH-

join:2004-01-13
Ontario

Pfffttt!!

Riddle me this,
Riddle me that!
Who's afraid of the BIG BLACK BAT!!
--
Aries, The Beginning--END TRANSMISSION--

SuperJudge
Magus
Premium
join:2002-11-14
Albany, GA

Re: Pfffttt!!

"I am the terror that flaps in the night! I am the grade curve that gives you an 'F'! I am DarkWing Duck!"
--DarkWing, Class Reunion
--
MediaXPeer

Stewy85
Premium
join:2003-01-16
Sharon, WI

Catchy Title

Where's Charter?

J D McDorce
Premium
join:2001-12-29
Westland, MI

1 edit

Apples to Apples?

In looking at the posted rates, the question that immediately comes to mind is whether the rates are normalized for CATV subscriber versus non-CATV subscriber. The rate listed for Comcast is the non-CATV subscriber rate. I don't have enough background on the others to tell at a glance whether the rates listed are CATV subscriber or non-CATV subscriber rates, however, many look suspiciously like the CATV subscriber rate.

Karl Bode
News Guy
join:2000-03-02
kudos:29

Re: Apples to Apples?

It marks Comcast at $57.95 USD at PPP, so I assume your answer is sans CATV.
MrJames

join:2003-05-19
Jacksonville, FL

1 edit
Doesn't Comcast consider $57.95 the base price for HSI with a bundled discount to $42.95 if you have cable? This allows them to charge the extra $15 for those who don't have CATV service.
nemmesis

join:2002-12-19
Washington

1 edit

Re: Apples to Apples?

yes that is correct, they charge 15 more if your a non cable tv customer. man for that price your paying for limited cable without getting limited cable ..lol
limited cable(locals and a few other channels) is only 15 bucks..lol

pnh102
Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty
Premium
join:2002-05-02
Mount Airy, MD
We should also add the cost of a phone line for DSL service if we're going to be that particular.
--
Do the world a favor, Saddam. Kill yourself.

dvd536
as Mr. Pink as they come
Premium
join:2001-04-27
Phoenix, AZ
kudos:4

Re: Apples to Apples?

said by pnh102:
We should also add the cost of a phone line for DSL service if we're going to be that particular.

Except with all the BS charges and fees the telcos lop on it is more than $15.
--
You can never be too rich, too thin or have too much Bandwidth

pnh102
Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty
Premium
join:2002-05-02
Mount Airy, MD

Re: Apples to Apples?

said by dvd536:
Except with all the BS charges and fees the telcos lop on it is more than $15.
True... and for people like me, a landline phone is a completely useless waste of cash, and if I were to have DSL, I'd have no choice but to add its cost onto the cost of the service. When I factor in the $20-$30 (at least that's what my last landline phone bill was) plus the cost of the DSL service itself (and all the BS fees that get tacked onto that) then DSL doesn't seem to be a bargain either.
--
Do the world a favor, Saddam. Kill yourself.

LegoPower77
Abecedarian
Premium
join:2002-08-03
Midlothian, VA
My Cox HSI is 39.95 plus another c. $10 for basic cable. The HSI alone I think is $59.95, but I'm not sure about dat.

ctceo
Premium
join:2001-04-26
South Bend, IN
Reviews:
·magicjack.com
·AT&T U-Verse
·AT&T Midwest

2 edits

Re: Apples to Apples?

As long as your cable is running to the home and delivering internet, Cable providers can't stop the cable tv signal (very basic) that comes along with it. (only available in areas where you have the old Tocom type service (or they haven't discontinues it yet), not the new X-Box sized cable boxes, that digital cable junk.

I personally think that these prices are a bit skewed as pointed out by those who "have cable tv service" in addition to Internet, and the acknowledged price difference between them.

I pay $29.99 a month for ADSL (1.5 down/256 up), but If I didn't have SBC as my phone service provider, I wouldn't be able to get it at all, or the price would be jacked so high it makes it not worth it to even get, some where around $70/mo for half the speed!

My friend is paying $40.84/mo for BASIC Comcast Cable, No TV, For that he has the much better and cost effective DirecTV @ 27.99/mo (comes with SciFi & TechTV, Comcast Doesn't). He was informed that if he wanted Digital Cable that he could sign up for the "basic digital plan" for an additional $38.99/mo + taxes on top of his $40.84, what a JIP. ~$86 (after taxes) Are you crazy, Between My Phone Bill with DSL & My Satt Bill I only Total up to about ~$73.

So with that said, Nevermind.
--
K8T Neo - 2GB DCDDR400 - AXP 64 3400+ - 3DLabs WC4 7210 - CL Audigy 2 PP - WD SATA150 36GB + Hitachi GST 250GB - Plextor PX708A + Sony CRX300A - Dual 535 Watt PSU's, Full Tower El Cheapo Case W/ Sound Padding & Thermal vents.

toby
Troy Mcclure

join:2001-11-13
Reviews:
·CenturyLink

Re: Apples to Apples?

said by ctceo:
As long as your cable is running to the home and delivering internet, Cable providers can't stop the cable tv signal (very basic) that comes along with it.

They can and they do block the signal.
Freezone

join:2000-09-29
Southfield, MI

Re: Apples to Apples?

If a comcast tech comes by and sees you have cable tv going and you are just a cable modem sub, they are required to filter you.

ctceo
Premium
join:2001-04-26
South Bend, IN
Reviews:
·magicjack.com
·AT&T U-Verse
·AT&T Midwest
"By the way my cable man, I know you are gouging my eyes out in my internet costs, right now, but why don't you go ahead and inspect all my other TV's & VCR's while your here to see if I'm getting cable TV. I have this One TV in the basement it's hooked up to the old Cable wire, and for some funny reason it works like an antenna, pulling all these cool stations".

Somehow I doubt the above situation happens...
--
K8T Neo - 2GB DCDDR400 - AXP 64 3400+ - 3DLabs WC4 7210 - CL Audigy 2 PP - WD SATA150 36GB + Hitachi GST 250GB - Plextor PX708A + Sony CRX300A - Dual 535 Watt PSU's, Full Tower El Cheapo Case W/ Sound Padding & Thermal vents.

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

1 edit

Which is why I left...

It just amazes me how cable subscriber growth is continuing. After 2 years as a CC HSI customer I jumped ship for the much cheaper VoL the second they deployed an RT in my 'hood. And as I face yet ANOTHER CATV price increase (just had 2 last year and 1 the year before that) this coming Feb., I'm on the Dish Network free HD box waiting list. The day they install is the day I say bye to CC forever. But again, looking at subscriber growth I'm part of a tiny minority of disgrunted CATV and cable HSI customers who actually jump ship rather than just complain but continue to write the cable pig their ever increasing check amounts.
--
Mac Truth »members.cox.net/clyqz/macs.html
mikehd
What day is it?
Premium
join:2000-07-11
Lebanon, OR

Re: Which is why I left...

Dish just sent me my price increase warning. Cable is not the only ones pigging out.

What's the Dish Network free HD box? Where do I sign up??:D
--
"Get your haggis, right here! Chopped heart and lungs boiled in a wee sheep's stomach! Tastes as good as it sounds. Good for what ails ya!"

dropshadow

join:2000-12-17
Plano, TX

Re: Which is why I left...

i have direcTV, but at one point i was going to go with dish under the assumption that they locked in your rates for one year upon signup?

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

1 edit

Re: Which is why I left...

said by dropshadow:
i have direcTV, but at one point i was going to go with dish under the assumption that they locked in your rates for one year upon signup?

DN is currently locking new customers who sign up at the old rates through 1/2005.
--
Mac Truth »members.cox.net/clyqz/macs.html

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

3 edits
The price increase I saw for the top 100 was $1. Comcast has raised my rates over $15 over the past 2 years and now wants more...on top of them already being more than DBS.

A $1-$2 increase every few years which is what type of increase we see with DN is reasonable. 3 increases amounting to double digit percentage hikes in 2 years is IMHO not.

The free 811 box which also includes on OTA HD tuner is for new subs and is shown on the promotion page »www.dishnetwork.com/content/getd···ex.shtml The only requirement is 12 month contract for their $10/mo or $110/yr HD tier. I don't know what an upgrade charge would be for current subs. Because of the free box promotion the 811 box is in short supply...typically a 4 week wait.
--
Mac Truth »members.cox.net/clyqz/macs.html
mikehd
What day is it?
Premium
join:2000-07-11
Lebanon, OR

Re: Which is why I left...

Makes me want to quit Dish to become a new customer. Point being, they don't do squat for you once you're in. But if you're out...

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

Re: Which is why I left...

Before I was with CC, I had DN and was treated well in the form of no price increases and them adding content pretty regularly. They also had decent upgrade deals for current customers.

But everywhere has those come-on ads. Look at Comcast. $19 digital cable, $19 HSI for a whole year for DSL customers, $200 credit if you're a DBS customer...but once they have you it's less content, less channels and higher prices, higher prices, higher prices...forever.

Whether it be DTV or DN you get more and pay less...now and in the future.
--
Mac Truth »members.cox.net/clyqz/macs.html

dvd536
as Mr. Pink as they come
Premium
join:2001-04-27
Phoenix, AZ
kudos:4
said by mikehd:
Dish just sent me my price increase warning. Cable is not the only ones pigging out.

What's the Dish Network free HD box? Where do I sign up??:D

i thought DISHNETWORK wasn't going to do a price increase until 2005? guess they want a bigger piece of the pie too.
--
You can never be too rich, too thin or have too much Bandwidth

GNXPower
Got Boost?
Premium
join:2003-12-18
Huntington Beach, CA

1 edit

Re: Which is why I left...

As I mentioned earlier, the increases are $1-$3 depending on the package. New signups get locked in at the old price through at least the end of the year. The increases represent about a 3%-4% increase...better than the 13% hike I got with Comcast last year...and they're coming back for another 5% this year.
--
Mac Truth »members.cox.net/clyqz/macs.html

DaveDude
No Fear

join:1999-09-01
New Jersey
kudos:1

DSL, and 128

Why would i buy DSL at 128 up, when i can get cable for nearly the same price at 512up.
--
Alright DR. Slotkin do your worst.
Freezone

join:2000-09-29
Southfield, MI

Re: DSL, and 128

Most cable tos do not allow servers. So even 128k can be better than 512k if you wanted to run a web/mail server.

I get 768k up with static ip and hosting is legal but that is relative to my area, or areas that have coverage by MCI(1.5/768) or Covad(3.0/768). Everyone has different levels of service and exp. So the cable v dsl debate has no clear winner.
moonpuppy

join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD

Let's look at the differences....

There will always be this cable vs. DSl war but why?

1) DSL is distance sensitive while cable has a much farther reach. You are over a certain distance from the CO, DSL won't be as fast as cable (in most places.)

2) Cable had a head start in deployment while the baby bells still cry about line sharing.

3) Cable is, for the most part, easier to install. Connect modem to cable line. DSL requires filters in most cases.

4) DSL does have a greater variety of ISP's than cable.

This is by far no where near a complete list.

I have said it many many times. If the bells had deployed DSL with thought and a commitment to make it work, they would have a goo hold on the technology. However, they chose to "hope" people would come to them.

They lost with DSL, it's time to go fiber and kill cable once and for all.

See 19 replies to this post

jjoshua
Premium
join:2001-06-01
Scotch Plains, NJ
kudos:1
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS

Still no DSL service

Verizon should get off their *ss and make DSL available first, then we can all talk about their wonderful prices.

I'm in an extremely populated area of NJ and I still seem to be 18k from the CO. I've also got 6 pair of copper coming into my house. You'd think that I'd be able to get some sort of service.

MikBo
Just Happy To Be Here
Premium
join:2002-01-04
Lynchburg, VA

Re: Still no DSL service

Just got DSl here,768/128,and have cable at 3000/256,if I drop the cable will save $40 a month.Latency for dsl is 25ms max over 11 hops,wish I could say the same for the cable.Looks like I am going to make the switch.
--
"Things will get better,despite our efforts to improve them!"--Will Rogers

IGotThePower
Samsung Sucks
Premium
join:2003-06-07
Japan Inc.

Fake prices

I wonder who got the prices for JCOM... Here are the real prices: 8/2Mbps - 47$, 30/2Mbps - 52$, and in my area 20/2Mbps - 47$. Get real, for that price, you can get fiber.
--
Want an OC-192 ? All your base are belong to us.‹NŽ€‰ñ¶
damox
Premium
join:2002-01-07
Olympia, WA
Reviews:
·Comcast Formerl..

DSL spells DISMAL in the Northwest

I cannot speak for other parts of the country, but here in the western Washington, DSL is DISMAL! It can in no way be construed as competitive! Last time I checked, Qwest had reduced the price for their co-branded MSN package and had upped their speeds to a whopping 640/256. Yeah, I really want to give up my 1700/256 for dsl. Yes I do, and I also want to trade in my new Camry for a clunker. Certainly sounds like a no-brainer to me.
--
DAMOX

Sunday, 12-Feb 04:45:05 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online! © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.