dslreports logo
 story category
Apple Vs. Rogers: The Fight That Isn't
When a simple inventory shift becomes a pro-consumer crusade...

Last week it was rumored that Apple was cutting back on Canadian 3G iPhone stock as a retaliatory move against Rogers, whose iPhone pricing and obnoxiously low caps have been universally laughed at. Now Apple Insider suggests that Apple won't be selling the iPhone 3G in their Canadian retail stores as a follow up attack on Rogers. The only problem being Apple never had any plans to do so in the first place, according to iPhone Atlas.

quote:

Apple never planned to sell the iPhone 3G at its retail locations in Canda. In fact, the Apple is not — at least at launch — selling the iPhone 3G at any of its retail locations outside the United States. Australia, Japan, Italy, and UK retail stores will also not have initial stock of the iPhone 3G, forcing customers in those countries to visit official carrier stores or third-party partners like Fido in Canada.
While the idea that Apple cares enough about consumers to fight against mean 'ole Rogers' pricing plans probably appeals to many people's brand idealism, it's just as likely that Apple was simply tinkering with global inventory.

If Canadian consumers really want to protest high prices and low caps affixed the iPhone in Canada, their best option is to not buy one. Unless you really think $115 a month for a 2GB cap with a mandatory three year contract is fair...
view:
topics flat nest 

Mike
Mod
join:2000-09-17
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:2

Mike

Mod

Not buying one?

Whining > Thinking

Matt3
All noise, no signal.
Premium Member
join:2003-07-20
Jamestown, NC
kudos:12

Matt3

Premium Member

Ha ha

Steve Jobs doesn't care about anything but how he can make a buck.
firewire9999
join:2004-07-11
Livonia, MI

firewire9999

Member

Re: Ha ha

LOL - Oh How Evil He Is To Want To Make A Dollar$.

MysticGogeta
The Robot Devil
Premium Member
join:2005-03-14
Katy, TX

MysticGogeta

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

said by firewire9999:

LOL - Oh How Evil He Is To Want To Make A Dollar$.
Same could be said about Bill Gates. Yes I went there.

Bender_2k
join:2003-01-12

Bender_2k

Member

Re: Ha ha

Woah woah...lets not go treading that territory...
ender7074
join:2006-11-21
Saint Louis, MO

ender7074 to MysticGogeta

Member

to MysticGogeta
Yes but people get all upset if it's Gates. Jobs is a tool who loves his little cult following. Oh and I love how he goes on and on about originality and how they were "pioneers" and that MS stole their ideas from Apple. Their entire GUI was based on IP theft from, you guessed it, Steve Jobs. Wonder how Xerox feels about Apple......
wolfhouse
join:2001-03-01
Westfield, NJ

wolfhouse

Member

Re: Ha ha

so where is that Xerox OS you are talking about again?

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

1 edit

Dogfather

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

It's no secret that Jobs got the GUI bug when we went to PARC to see their goodies.

And if you want to base innovation on how many copies of an OS gets sold then MS owns everyone.

Apple took the GUI and brought it to the desktop. Gates obviously saw the writing on the wall after seeing Apple's work and used what he saw to develop Windows.

True ground up innovation is very rare. Most consumer revolutions come from someone who was smart enough to take existing elements and combine them in a way that could be considered innovative.

Just like proportional typefaces. Microsoft was actually working on it a year before the Mac came out (and Xerox long before that) but the Mac combined proportional typefaces with their printer and the Macs bitmapped screen...an "innovation" in affordable personal desktop publishing.

elwoodblues
Elwood Blues
Premium Member
join:2006-08-30
Somewhere in
kudos:2

elwoodblues

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

What everyone is missing, is that Xerox threw everything away.
Ethernet, the GUI, the Laser printer, Object Oriented Programming, thats just to name a few.

Imagine what Xerox would be today if they hadn't just dismissed those technologies?

Don't blame Jobs or the WOZ for seeing an idea and running with it.

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

Dogfather

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

That's the thing. Even if they tried to do somethign with it...did they have the 'art' in them to actually apply these brilliant technologies into something consumer oriented?

We've seen through recent PC history (mid-70's on) great ideas that flopped because they were poorly applied.

en102
Canadian, eh?
join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA

en102

Member

Re: Ha ha

Right - anyone remeber the Commodore Amiga?
Basically cross between PC, Mac and Unix. Since it was never sold as a proper business machine, and more of a 'game' device, it flopped.

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

Dogfather

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

On a more minor scale, OS-9 on the TRS-80 Color Computer was awesome, multi-user, multi-tasking, very powerful but on a weak selling computer in a saturated market...it didn't sell well. Much like the Newton, it was just way ahead of its time.

N3OGH
Yo Soy Col. "Bat" Guano
Premium Member
join:2003-11-11
Philly burbs
kudos:2

N3OGH

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

I love how the discussions of today's computer environment heads down the road of geekdom it does here at BBR.

All of you pretty much hit the nail on the head as far as the origins of modern computer interfaces goes.

It makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside knowing I'm not the only geek in the world with this information tucked safely in the back of my brain.

I'm going to go boot my Apple II+ and run some BASIC programs, just for old time's sake

supergirl
join:2007-03-20
Pensacola, FL

supergirl

Member

Re: Ha ha

said by N3OGH:

I love how the discussions of today's computer environment heads down the road of geekdom it does here at BBR.
You would think they have pron to download, huh?
yabos
join:2003-02-16
London, ON

yabos to Dogfather

Member

to Dogfather
In case you didn't know, Apple licensed the concept from Xerox, whereas Microsoft did not and just up and copied it. Also, Xerox had absolutely no plans to use anything they were coming up with at the time.

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

4 edits

Dogfather

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

said by yabos:

In case you didn't know, Apple licensed the concept from Xerox, whereas Microsoft did not and just up and copied it. Also, Xerox had absolutely no plans to use anything they were coming up with at the time.
Huh? Xerox had Alto features in the Star 8010 (incl. full Alto GUI, lots of RAM, 40MB HDD, 2 button mousing, ethernet, email, etc) which came out in '81, long before the Mac and Win 1.0. But like Lisa, it was super expensive ($17K) and failed in the marketplace. Xerox absolutely tried to market their GUI born from the Alto. It was an amazing machine, but few could afford it. Even the Lisa wouldn't come out for another 2 years.

And from what I understand Microsoft had licensed elements of the 8010 from Xerox. MS also had licensing of Mac OS elements and Apple of future Windows elements, that from the Nov. 1985 agreement with Sculley.

Everyone copied, no one stole.

mlerner
Premium Member
join:2000-11-25
Nepean, ON
kudos:5

mlerner to Matt3

Premium Member

to Matt3
said by Matt3:

Steve Jobs doesn't care about anything but how he can make a buck.
Except when he can't get a buck. He probably already got some $$ from carriers but if no one is buying the phones that means no itunes, apps or electronic sales of any kind.

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

Dogfather to Matt3

Premium Member

to Matt3
said by Matt3:

Steve Jobs doesn't care about anything but how he can make a buck.
Like you don't.
Kearnstd
Space Elf
Premium Member
join:2002-01-22
Mullica Hill, NJ
kudos:2

Kearnstd to Matt3

Premium Member

to Matt3
with caps like those hes better off not making those bucks because people wont even be able to use the primary features.
Kearnstd

Kearnstd to Matt3

Premium Member

to Matt3
General Electric believe it or not once did computers and they dismissed them as they wernt light bulbs or stoves. many people say if GE had kept its full force behind computers that it would be GE as the big player in big iron and not IBM.

Dogfather
Premium Member
join:2007-12-26
Laguna Hills, CA

1 edit

Dogfather

Premium Member

Re: Ha ha

There's certainly a lot of sore asses in these corporate giants (from kicking themselves).
EPS4
join:2008-02-13
Hingham, MA

EPS4

Member

Re: Ha ha

What about AT&T? They only agreed to give up the local telephone operating companies out of a hope of getting into the computer business- which didn't really last too long.
UofMiamiGrad
Premium Member
join:2001-02-03
Great Neck, NY

UofMiamiGrad

Premium Member

Where is Canda?

"Apple never planned to sell the iPhone 3G at its retail locations in Canda"

Someone needs to use spellchecker

ninjatutle
Premium
join:2006-01-02
San Ramon, CA

ninjatutle

Member

Re: Where is Canda?

These are bloggers, enough said!
Syncognition
join:2008-01-12
Winter Park, FL

Syncognition to UofMiamiGrad

Member

to UofMiamiGrad
said by UofMiamiGrad:

Where is Canda?
Just North of 'Merica.


ninjatutle
Premium
join:2006-01-02
San Ramon, CA

ninjatutle

Member

Re: Where is Canda?

No no, Canaduh is what's norte.
houselog442
join:2005-10-05

houselog442

Member

Re: Where is Canda?

Isn't that country a communist country?
ender7074
join:2006-11-21
Saint Louis, MO

ender7074

Member

Re: Where is Canda?

Its well on its way to being one. Just give it a couple more years.

WhoGivesAchit

Anon

Slap Some Horns

....On that sucker!

Kind of looks like Karl's Evil Twin!
BellACancer
join:2008-06-04

BellACancer

Member

Apple = Sony

Apple is acting exactly like Sony : back in the 80's, Apple always priced its Mac way too high and refused 2 stores in the same market. That's why it lost against the PC.

Sony lost with Beta but still didn't understand some basics principles : it still prices its Blu-Ray way too high.

Consumers will buy other similar but much cheapers goods.
ender7074
join:2006-11-21
Saint Louis, MO

ender7074

Member

Re: Apple = Sony

Blu-Ray players are no more expensive than DVD players were when they first came out. Hell, a PS3 gives you a good player for 400 bucks. The media is expensive but, again, so were DVDs when they were released. Since the end of the little format war the price on many BluRay moves has started to drop. It will be in normal range soon.

dadkins
Can you do Blu?
MVM
join:2003-09-26
Hercules, CA
kudos:18

3 edits

dadkins to BellACancer

MVM

to BellACancer
BDA - Blu-ray Disc Association.
»www.blu-raydisc.com/en/a ··· ies.html

Blu-ray is not solely Sony.

BTW, there is no similar, cheaper products comparable to Blu-ray.
HD DVD died, remember?

My first DVD player... that was one of those $600 - $700(more? Been a while) things - back when a dollar was worth something.

nappyd
@65.50.54.x

nappyd to BellACancer

Anon

to BellACancer
there's a few other things affecting slow bluray sales like the pricing of higher-end (read: bigger) flat screens. even with more movies getting put out in better quality blu-ray (the first ones were barely better than regular dvd's) most people still need a tv of around 50" or bigger to hear/see a difference between bluray and an upconverting DVD player.

and most people aren't quite ready to buy the same movies that they only recently "owned today on dvd" in bluray.

gattaca
Premium Member
join:2003-05-28
USA

gattaca to BellACancer

Premium Member

to BellACancer
said by BellACancer:

That's why it lost against the PC.
That depends on how you define success.

Seriously though, I would argue that gaining the most marketshare is not necessarily indicative of "winning." In that sense, Camry's and Tauruses triumph big time over BMWs and Mercedes.

NetAdmin1
CCNA
join:2008-05-22

NetAdmin1

Member

So, in other words, the little story that couldn't ?

You have to love when facts deflate "conspiracy theories" like this one.

Iphone boycotter
@rogers.com

Iphone boycotter

Anon

:(

Apple sucks,
Rogers sucks,

but on good note Rogers stock fell nearly 10% with news of this "fight"

Titus
Mr Gradenko
join:2004-06-26
kudos:1

Titus

Member

The most interesting

part of this article - for me - is that 'Fanboy' is now part of Merriam-Webster's dictionary.
"Brand Idealism" indeed.
--

nanook
MVM
join:2007-12-02
·TekSavvy DSL

nanook

MVM

Robbers listened -- sort of...

Rogers caves to complains, unveils new data plan
quote:
Bowing to public pressure, Rogers Wireless Inc. has opted to slash its data fees as the launch of the iPhone draws near.

Customers who purchase an iPhone and sign up for a three-year contract any time between July 11 – when the device goes on sale – and the end of August will be eligible for a $30-per-month data plan giving them access to 6-Gigabytes of data. Rogers previously had charged $100 for a 6-GB plan...

The special plan is available not just to iPhone customers, but any Rogers customer with a 3G next-generation smart phone.

“We listened to our customers, everybody from those who are very tech savvy to those who just knew they wanted this device and were really enthusiastic and didn't know how they were going to use the data but knew it was a data device,” Rogers spokeswoman Liz Hamilton said.

“So this will give them a great opportunity.”
filizaragoza
join:2006-01-11
Falls Church, VA

filizaragoza

Member

TELCEL in MEXICO is worst

THEY OFFER 3 PLANS... THE CHEAPEST

50.00 DLS a Month GETS YOU:
200 minutes
100MB of DATA, but it's MB in Ad's, and Mb in Billing.
100 SMS
The Phones Cost:
8GB is 297Dlls
16GB 400 Dlls

For 60Dlls a Month you get
300 Minutes
150MB Data
150 SMS
The Phone Cost are:
8GB 188 Dlls.
16GB: 297Dlls

For 80Dlls a Month
400 Minutes
200MB Data
200 SMS

Notes:
Does not include Taxes...
Only thing is you do not get to pay for incoming calls.
unless you are roaming out of your're City Area.
filizaragoza

filizaragoza

Member

THEY OFFER 3 PLANS... THE CHEAPEST

50.00 dolar a Month GETS YOU:
200 minutes
100MB of DATA, but it's MB in Ad's, and Mb in Billing.
100 SMS
The Phones Cost:
8GB is $297.
16GB is $400.

For $60 a Month you get
300 Minutes
150MB Data
150 SMS
The Phone Cost are:
8GB: $188.
16GB: $297.

For $80 a Month
400 Minutes
200MB Data
200 SMS

Phones are:
8GB $77
16GB $187

With 2 Year Contract/Commitment

Notes:
Does not include Taxes...
Only thing is you do not get to pay for incoming calls.
unless you are roaming out of you're City Area.

Exchane Rates are about 10.20 - 10.30 Per Dolar depends on the day so substact from 1-3 Dolars per plan/equipment

Guspaz
Guspaz
MVM
join:2001-11-05
Montreal, QC
kudos:24

Guspaz

MVM

Re: TELCEL in MEXICO is worst

Which currency is that in, though? CAD, I presume?

Rogers plans are actually not all that bad now that they've announced that you can take any voice plan and combine it with a 6GB for $30 deal.

This means that for about $50-60/mth (plus fees), you can get something like 200 minutes and 6GB.

It's still not unlimited like you can get in the US, but it's much more reasonable.
dfc6
join:2008-06-23

dfc6

Member

Geez you guys think you have problems!!!

Check out what we get in Australia.:
»www.optusiphone.com.au/g ··· ing.aspx

»store.vodafone.com.au/iphone/

borest
@rogers.com

borest

Anon

Good PR spin pretending there was no pressure from Apple. If this is true why did rogers cave and offer the 6 GB data plan?

Because they care about their customers

HAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHHAAHA

sure they do


How about ..