dslreports logo
 story category
Comcast Sees Itself as the Mercedes of Cable

Comcast cable CTO Sree Kotay says the company is not satisfied being Netflix, and wants to be seen as the Tesla or Mercedes of cable service. In the age of flexible and cheap alternative streaming options, cable companies have been forced to justify what's increasingly seen as as an unsustainable price point for cable service. Mercedes is often used as a brand high water mark; departed Time Warner Cable CEO Rob Marcus saying cable prices are high because they offer Mercedes-grade product.

Click for full size
Obviously this narrative doesn't work particularly well for an industry with arguably the worst customer service and satisfaction rankings of any industry in America. That doesn't stop cable execs from using the argument often.

"We kind of don't want to be Netflix. We don't want an $8 or $9 product," Kotay told Comcast’s hometown paper, the Philadelphia Inquirer.

"Not to knock them or anything, but we want to be a Tesla or a Mercedes and be a premium product," Kotay said. "The point of empowering our product and development teams is fundamentally not just about direction and ambition, it's also about tapping into their creativity, and that's how you make great products.”

Comcast has pretty frequently suggested that its X1 set top box platform is so incredibly innovative, the company doesn't have to compete on price. It has also fought recent FCC attempts to bring competition to the cable box, arguing that such competition would only hamper this innovation. The problem is all of the X1 features in the world can't help fix Comcast's utterly abysmal customer service, which has been the butt of jokes for more than a decade now. Charging more money for the same broadband service (aka usage caps) isn't helping matters.

Premium prices need to be matched with premium products and support. And while Comcast promises annually that improving customer service is its top priority, brands like Mercedes are likely the last thing on the minds of anybody that has to spend more than five minutes talking to Comcast support on the telephone.

Most recommended from 86 comments


dbamber
join:2003-02-07
Bandon, OR

dbamber

Member

Mercedes-Benz of Cable Providers?

Mercedes-Benz just had their 114th anniversary. If their customers experiences were like that of Comcast subscribers, they would have gone out of business about 100 years ago.

Mike
Mod
join:2000-09-17
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:2

Mike

Mod

The Tesla of cable?

Yeah maybe when Autopilot screws up

karlmarx
join:2006-09-18
Signal Mountain, TN
·EPB Fiber Optics
·Xfinity

karlmarx

Member

Comast has a plan

They're going to be GREAT again! They are gonna get YUUUUGE!
A vision for America, not a specific vision, a GREAT vision, the BEST vision. Comcast has a plan to make this country great again, what plan? a Great Plan. A plan that will work, because it is the BEST! Why? Because Comcast knows good people. Which people? The best people. People who aren't stupid, like other people. People who know how to get deals done. What deals? Great deals. The biggest deals. Deal or No Deal. Let's make a deal. Make america great again, support comcast
--
Fear of god isn't the beginning of wisdom, it's the end.
axiomatic
join:2006-08-23
Tomball, TX
·Xfinity

axiomatic

Member

Nope...

Comcast with its ancient cable transmission model is more akin to a 1989 Cadillac Fleetwood Brougham.



TestBoy
Premium Member
join:2009-10-13
Irmo, SC
kudos:1
·Time Warner Cable
·tw telecom

TestBoy

Premium Member

LOL!

No wonder their market seems to be 'okay' with caps and fees!

But wait... if they were the "Mercedes" wouldn't these things come "standard" on a "luxury" service?

I literally laughed out loud when I read this

battleop
join:2005-09-28
00000

battleop

Member

Hahahah

Their core network is a Bugatti but their customer facing network is a Fiat.
heaterseakel
join:2011-02-20
Las Vegas, NV

heaterseakel

Member

They're a Monopoly Utility, not an Optional Luxury

""We kind of don't want to be Netflix. We don't want an $8 or $9 product," Kotay told Comcast’s hometown paper, the Philadelphia Inquirer.

"Not to knock them or anything, but we want to be a Tesla or a Mercedes and be a premium product,""

The problem with that statement is that Comcast is supposed to be a utility. Any municipality that grants them their monopoly and sees that statement should immediately revoke it. It's one thing to want to be a premium company in a competitive environment. It's another thing to want that when you're a utility with a captive market.

Anona55d7
@bresnan.net

Anona55d7

Anon

Actual satisfaction ratings

Mercedes-Benz: 83 (»www.theacsi.org/index.ph ··· des-Benz)
Netflix: 76 (»www.theacsi.org/index.ph ··· =Netflix)
Comcast: 62 (»www.theacsi.org/index.ph ··· +Service)

Looks like Comcast should shoot for Netflix and then start thinking about Mercedes.
tmc8080
join:2004-04-24
Brooklyn, NY

1 edit

tmc8080

Member

old media vs

And what does that make Google?

I'm thinking $200 a month triple play is not going to be getting many takers in the coming years, but less than $100 gigabit broadband will.

cypherstream
MVM
join:2004-12-02
Reading, PA
kudos:4
·ProLog

cypherstream

MVM

X1 may be nice but the signal transmission and lack of HD stink!

X1 is really nice but no way can you call Comcast the mercedes of cable. First off many area's are still only 750 MHz and lower. System in my area your lucky to get 46 db upstream at the TAP. Add 100 ft drop, splitters, etc and your over the limit. The system is in needs of a rebuild. They need to take it to node+0 if possible or node+1 at the most, go 1.2 GHz forward path and take the upstream higher as well. Get rid of all the 26 and 23 value taps!!!! Replace 40 year old spans of hardline!

Mercedes of cable lol... they need to fix up the transmission system for sure. Don't get me started on how many HD channels they are missing or how overcompressed they are!

Tursiops_G
Technoid
MVM
join:2002-02-06
Norwalk, CT
kudos:2
·Optimum Online
ARRIS TM1602
TP-Link TL-WDR4300

1 edit

Tursiops_G

MVM

Comcast can Get Bent...

An Oldie, but Still Relevant...
(Content Caution: Language/NSFW...)

»youtu.be/KMcny_pixDw
mmay149q
Premium Member
join:2009-03-05
Dallas, TX
kudos:48

mmay149q

Premium Member

LMFAO

As someone who has owned a Mercedes before I'd say they're spot on with their analogy, they over charge for a crap brand, I had to sell the Mercedes when I still owed $5k on it because within 3 months I had $10k in repairs that needed to be done I couldn't afford.
--
Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tomorrow. The important thing is not to stop questioning. -Albert Einstein
ihafro
join:2004-01-05
Champaign, IL

ihafro

Member

PreApproved cable bill, act now, low 27.8% APR!

Well, they kind of are right, monthly service from Comcast does have about the same payment *as* a Merc.
Slyster
join:2015-01-08
Sugar Grove, VA

Slyster

Member

This is why mega corps suck..

To them Price = Quality of your product. Their product is terrible but because it is expensive it is a " premium " product.

How does Netflix not offer a premium product? Amazon?

Idiotic reasoning.

cowboyro
Premium Member
join:2000-10-11
Shelton, CT

cowboyro

Premium Member

Mercedes...

CLA or S-Class? Or maybe the Smart car.. small, slow, and overall lousy?
And Tesla is coming with Model 3... or did he mean a fully loaded Model S?

How about ..