dslreports logo

story category
Comcast Still Advertising Capped Service As Unlimited?
Updated with response from Comcast at bottom...
by Karl Bode 08:57AM Wednesday Mar 03 2010
For many years, Comcast Communications advertised their broadband service as unlimited, despite the fact that there were obvious limits in place. Those very real limits resulted in users getting letters warning them about excessive consumption and threatening account termination. Our users spent the better part of a decade complaining that the carrier kept warning them they were using too much bandwidth -- without clearly defining how exactly Comcast defined "too much."

Click for full size
In October of 2008 the company imposed a clear 250 GB monthly cap for all residential user tiers. We assumed that all older marketing material (like this flyer from 2003) were no longer being used. But according to The Consumerist, the carrier is still marketing their service as "unlimited" in some markets. One user in Charleston says he received a flyer advertising unlimited service back in January, then was surprised to run into Comcast's caps:
I was told I used more data than they allow (250GB). I do not argue that I used over 250GB, in fact I went quite a bit over. Though I did want to ask for proof that affected their network, I figured it wasn't the nicest way to start the interaction. I informed them that I used this because it was sold as "Unlimited usage for a flat, monthly rate." He then told me it said "access." I had the brochure right next to me and quoted, "Unlimited usage for a flat, monthly rate." He told me their website says something different, and my local franchise overstepped its bounds.
Given that Comcast has been doing a much better job being direct with consumers lately, we're guessing the local Charleston franchise in question either napped through an Xfininity meeting or they're using older marketing material, though we dropped a note to Comcast just to double check. We prefer the new, more transparent Comcast, where if there are going to be network limits -- they're at least clear to the consumer. Hopefully this is just a glitch and the company isn't taking a step backward.

Update: Comcast spokesman Charlie Douglas confirms to Broadband Reports that this isn't standard company procedure, and that something's wrong with Charleston-area marketing:
We had an error in how our Internet service was described in customer notifications in Charleston, SC and Augusta, GA. We are sending a corrected notice to our customers in these markets right away and we apologize for any confusion it may have caused. We believe that this is an isolated incident, but we are conducting a thorough audit of our marketing materials to be certain they are accurate.

164 comments .. click to read

Recommended comments

reminds me of the danse russe
Chandler, AZ

2 recommendations

reply to r81984

Re: Pathetic...

said by r81984:

Just wow, thanks for trying to prove me wrong with comments about congestion which does nothing to justify caps.
wrong, yet again.
you seem to feel entitled that by paying $60/month for your residential internet connection, that you should be able to use it the same as someone who pays $4000/month for their fractional ds3. additionally, people who feel justified in using the connection 24/7 are not *helping* the situation, but exploiting a finite resource.

i see full speeds on my line all the time. i've monitored my line with cacti. i *never* see over 150gig/month usage, with no cable tv and working from home. all video is streamed (via web or hulu) and my career requires remote access to multiple customer sites. i see full speeds all the time, usually more due to powerboost. there is no problem with cox delivering speeds promised to my home.

if *you* feel justified in being able to use your connection 24/7, then you are doing nothing than making the problem worse. the reason you are able to pay $60/month for a 15/1 connection is through statistical averages and oversubscription. don't like it, ask your local mso what it would cost for a truly dedicated line at those speeds. you simply feel nothing more than entitlement, and that can't be fixed; its your deficiency - not mine or your providers.

"...if I in my north room dance naked, grotesquely before my mirror waving my shirt round my head and singing softly to myself..."