republican-creole
site Search:


 
   
story category
Comparing 3G Data Card Service Across Carriers
Engadget takes four services out for a stroll...
by Karl Bode Wednesday 27-May-2009 tags: competition · business · wireless
Tipped by en102 See Profile
Several readers have submitted this Engadget comparison of mobile data card service from nation's big four wireless broadband networks (AT&T, T-Mobile, Sprint and Verizon). These types of comparisons are sketchy given service not only varies from town to town but often block to block -- something Engadget alludes to. Still, they found that AT&T has the best downstream speeds and Verizon Wireless has the best overall coverage (based on the not always reliable coverage maps), while Sprint and Verizon's WWAN management software were the best of the bunch. Prices remain fairly consistent across the board, with $60 for a 5GB per month data cap (T-Mobile the exception at 10GB) remaining the norm as carriers work hard to avoid competing on price.

view: topics flat text 
Post a:

DataRiker
Premium
join:2002-05-19
00000

t-mobile

If I remember correctly t-mobile has a 10 GB cap. That may have changed though.
me1212

join:2008-11-20
Pleasant Hill, MO

Re: t-mobile

I looked at their site and it said unlimited, one packages DID say it had a 5GB cap, but ALL the others said unlimited. And no where did it say anything about overages.
iansltx

join:2007-02-19
Golden, CO
kudos:2
For their mobile broadband card, it's 5GB. Just like all the other sluggards out there.
xenophon

join:2007-09-17

According to dslreports.com archive..

Biggest problem with most evaluations is that they don't test across the country with thousands of users. Dslreports.com has a great archive of users across the country. Looks like Sprint leads for cellphones today..

[url]»/mspeed?domains=1[/url]

Here are laptop card results...
Speed Test Statistics - dslreports.com

Samples Down Upload
113 747 369 Sprint Mobile Broadband:
105 727 353 Verizon Wireless
28 622 374 Cingular: US mobile provider (ATT)

These results change all the time though and some are 2g results. No provider consistently leads and all are sometimes on top. Wireless data is fickle.

djrobx

join:2000-05-31
Valencia, CA
Reviews:
·RoadRunner Cable
·AT&T U-Verse
·VOIPo
·PHONE POWER

Re: According to dslreports.com archive..

The problem with the DSLReports.com archive is that mobile IPs frequently report the wrong domain.

I frequently see "myvzw.com" using AT&T's 3G service, and sometimes other strange, non AT&T domains.
--
AT&T U-Hearse
Your funeral. Delivered.

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
I do agree that the sampling of 4 carriers through in one location (at a specific time?) is not a real scientific basis - especially for wireless.

Take what they have performed - hit at least 20 cities
Run a series of different speed tests (similar to what they have done)
Run them at different times during the day and evening
Run them in different parts of the city

Also for 'grins' run take a sample is a rural area outside of the city (farmland, etc) where there's a possibility of no users.
--
Canada = Hollywood North
xenophon

join:2007-09-17
Also see evdomaps.com

Many have seen up to 3.5Mbps with EVDO.

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA

1 edit

Re: According to dslreports.com archive..

I thought EVDO Rev A is rated to 3.1 Mbps ?
--
Canada = Hollywood North

powerspec88
Premium
join:2007-03-11
Lenexa, KS
Reviews:
·SureWest Internet
·AT&T Yahoo
·Embarq Now Centu..
·Sprint Mobile Br..

Re: According to dslreports.com archive..

It is. The fastest i've ever seen with my Sprint EV-DO card is ~2.7Mbps. On average I get between 2-2.5Mbps. »Re: How's your speed for May?

I've tested AT&T, Sprint and Verizon and Sprint has always came out on top here in Kansas City.

halfelite_guest

@pacbell.net

no true winner

I dont think there will ever be a true winner. location location location. Someone will always come out on top at a different location.
DarnellP

join:2004-10-12
Las Vegas, NV

Re: no true winner

I think that the test that Gizmodo did a while back was better comparison as they tested the cards in several different cities. Of course I don't think that t-mobile had their laptop card available at the time.
ShellMMG

join:2009-04-16
Grass Lake, MI

Alltel doen't have a cap.

Before I signed last year I had the Alltel manager in town print a copy of the contract. No mention of a cap, no hint, no discouragement of excessive download. I've also been on the phone with Alltel's tech support -- twice-- over the past two weeks and they reiterated the fact there's NO cap.

When Verizon gets finished with the merger, however...that could be a whole new ball of wax. Since Alltel is my ONLY source for internet (no DSL, cable, wiMax, etc.) I won't be happy if we're capped.
iansltx

join:2007-02-19
Golden, CO
kudos:2
Reviews:
·Comcast
·Verizon Online DSL

YMMV

Depending on tower load, network configuration etc. there's a big YMMV here. The biggest ones being the HSPA networks, which don't have near the coverage of CDMA-based systems (Verizon+Alltel and Sprint). Verizon, so I've heard, does 1 Mbit down and 500k up. SPrint here is 1.3 Mbps down and 350k up form my direct experience. AT&T is EDGE (70 kbps). T-Mobile *might* be EDGE, or it might be GPRS. AT&T *should* have 3G here "by the end of the year". Nothing from T-Mobile.

NCChtrUsr

@charter.com

Re: YMMV

Ive tried them all

Here near Lincolnton its:

AT&T - EDGE 150-200kbps
Verizon - No Service (0 bars)
Sprint - No Service (0 Bars)
Alltel - EVDO 600-750kbps (very weak signal 1-2 bars)
T-Mobile is GPRS not even worth it.

So I stay with AT&T, even though EDGE is slow at least its 4-5 bars while everyone else is crap. Although AT&T will probably never bring 3G here.
iansltx

join:2007-02-19
Golden, CO
kudos:2
Reviews:
·Comcast
·Verizon Online DSL

Re: YMMV

Wait...if you've got a 600-750 kbps Alltel signal wouldn't that be better than EDGE on AT&T? Also, since Alltel got bought by Verizon, you should be seeing better data coverage, since Verizon makes a crapload off of that and likes to parade "nation's largest 3G network" all over the place.

Saturday, 11-Feb 20:00:13 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online! © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.