Search:  

 
 
   News
newer
Data Hogs and Glass Ceilings
Mobile companies reconsider 'unlimited' plans
(old news - 03:14PM Tuesday Jan 07 2003)
tags: wireless · bandwidth
Mobile providers are backpedaling on unlimited data offerings and trying to close loopholes as more and more customers are finding ways to connect their mobile phones to their laptops, allowing them to gobble additional bandwidth without paying for the pricier service plans. According to Jeffrey Nelson, a spokesman for Verizon Wireless, their definition of unlimited seems....somewhat limited. "Nonstop downloads—that is, you're downloading the content of the Library of Congress using [Code Division Multiple Access] 1X and are connected 24-by-7....are not allowed."

Related:
  1. AT&T Kills Off $20 Unlimited Pre-Paid Data
  2. AT&T Wants HSDPA/LTE In....Everything
  3. Sprint CEO Says They're Working On Pro-Rated ETFs
  4. Verizon Wireless Kills Pay As You Go Data Plans
  5. T-Mobile Plots LTE Course
  6. Tethered iPhone: $30/Month, 5GB Cap
  7. Ultra-Mobile-Broadband (UMB) Officially Dead
  8. Virgin Announces In-Flight Broadband Deployment
Forums » Data Hogs and Glass Ceilings
view: topics flat text 
Post a:

GlobalMind
Domino Dude, POWER Systems Guy
Premium
join:2001-10-29
Hollywood, FL

Once again....

quote:

"Nonstop downloads—that is, you're downloading the content of the Library of Congress using [Code Division Multiple Access] 1X and are connected 24-by-7....are not allowed."

Don't advertise the service as "unlimited" if you aren't prepared to live up to your end of the deal.

K.
--
"We can go from boom to bust, from dreams to a bowl of dust. We can fall from rockets red glare, down to 'Brother can you spare' -- another war -- another waste land -- and another lost generation. . ."
Nightwchtr

join:2001-09-10
Falls Church, VA

Re: Once again....

Agreed, this kind of switch and bait BS is getting old and hopefully people are getting tired of it aswell. If only people would rally to stop this type of BS advertising I would definately support it.

TheMadSwede
Premium
join:2001-01-30
Holland, MI
·Charter Pipeline

Re: Once again....

said by Nightwchtr See Profile:
...this kind of switch and bait BS is getting old...
You need to bait before you can switch. But anyhow...

Providers need to have some sort of foresight as far as establishing their plans. A bigger problem than them backpedaling on their originally offered plans is that they didn't stop to think that someone would go bandwidth/call/download crazy if they made something unlimited. If they'd stop and think about the future for once instead of being giddy beyond belief with the idea of new subscribers and more dough, then stuff like this wouldn't happen.
--
Sure would be nice to be eligible for broadband..any kind of broadband.

Mashiki
Balking The Enemy's Plans

join:2002-02-04
Woodstock, ON
·mybrighthouse
·Rogers Hi-Speed

Re: Once again....

said by TheMadSwede See Profile:
You need to bait before you can switch. But anyhow...

Providers need to have some sort of foresight as far as establishing their plans. A bigger problem than them backpedaling on their originally offered plans is that they didn't stop to think that someone would go bandwidth/call/download crazy if they made something unlimited. If they'd stop and think about the future for once instead of being giddy beyond belief with the idea of new subscribers and more dough, then stuff like this wouldn't happen.

You even said it yourself, that is a bait and switch.

trparky
Bite My Shiny Metal Ass
Premium,MVM
join:2000-05-24
Cleveland, OH
clubs:

Re: Once again....

Once again, we need what is above. BS, jese, can't we just get rid of it?

Unlimited means just that, unlimited, not what you think. Until the dictionary says otherwize, unlimited in my book means, without any limit of any kind.
--
WedgeAntilles250

Eat Me

join:2002-09-25
Sussex, NJ
clubs:

Re: Once again....

LOL thats funny. Are you batman by any chance?

TheMadSwede
Premium
join:2001-01-30
Holland, MI
·Charter Pipeline

said by Mashiki See Profile:
You even said it yourself, that is a bait and switch.
And?

My first point was that it's called bait and switch, not switch and bait.

My second point was that they wouldn't have to look back and scramble to think of some legal crap to cover their rears when realize that they're operating illegally if they would just take the time to think through the decisions they make in the first place. Wouldn't you prefer that they make good decisions that they don't have to weasel out of than what is happening right now?

I think some folks around here seriously prefer when a company screws up just so they can bash them.
--
Sure would be nice to be eligible for broadband..any kind of broadband...and don't tell me about satellite.
lesopp

join:2001-06-27
Land O Lakes, FL

Re: Once again....

This what happens when you hire wiz kids that do not know squat about the product.
moonpuppy

join:2000-08-21
Glen Burnie, MD
·Verizon Online DSL

said by TheMadSwede See Profile:

I think some folks around here seriously prefer when a company screws up just so they can bash them.

We bash them not so much for screwing up but for changing the rules mid-game. Don't sell us one thing and then say, "OOOPS, sorry. We need to reduce our responsibility but we won't reduce the price."

What VZ did was not think through their decision. They wanted to get in the game so badly, they forgot to check the details. Someone at VZ screwed up big time.

I have seen cell phone companies advertise unlimited nights and weekends. So if I call a friend Friday at 9pm and leave the phone on and connected until Monday at 5am, is that wrong? No because that is what they offered me. If they want to limit me then don't give me unlimited and then redo my yearly contract. You promised, now deliver.

detth
Onemhz On Aim

join:2000-10-06
Astoria, NY

Actually

I have not heard anyone advertise unlimited amount of data can be downloaded.
Unlimited downloads - thats different. download 1 million 1 byte files....
Unlimited use is also different - how you use it is another story.

I guess its kind of those deals with the phone companies - switch to us from your 10 cents per call flat rate -to get unlimited calls! that usually gets lots of people, then they get charged like 8 cents per minute for every call.
- How were my calls restricted or not limited before? lol - get the picture?

GlobalMind
Domino Dude, POWER Systems Guy
Premium
join:2001-10-29
Hollywood, FL

Re: Actually

Well the article was quoting the plan as:

quote:

. . .unlimited PCS Vision data access at no extra charge for three months and an additional $10 per month after that.

I don't think a claim that "access" and "downloads" are different things really works. I think that's just mincing of words and really is meaningless.

When they say "unlimited data access" -- what are they saying then? You can connect 24x7 but only download 2k per day? If that's the case then they need to say so.

This is just a simple case of the carrier using vague twists of terminology...and a failure on their part to manage their contracts.

K.
--
"We can go from boom to bust, from dreams to a bowl of dust. We can fall from rockets red glare, down to 'Brother can you spare' -- another war -- another waste land -- and another lost generation. . ."
lashmun
Premium
join:2002-12-14
Novi, MI

Re: Actually

It depends on what the definition of 'is' is ;~}

GlobalMind
Domino Dude, POWER Systems Guy
Premium
join:2001-10-29
Hollywood, FL

Re: Actually

Ok thumbs for that...funny, damn funny...

K.

clyde_
It's A Chrysalis, Not A Cocoon
Premium
join:2001-05-02
Easley, SC

Sprint PCS actually has a clause in their contract against hooking their phones up to a computer and downloading large amounts of data. Not to say it cannot be done, but they have plans with matching prices for that kind of usage. Obviously Verizon didn't have the foresight to see this coming and place limits within their contract.

My question is what kind of people are trying to download 24/7 off their cell phones? Current wireless Internet speeds are just barely broadband. Downloading lots of large files would probably still entail a lot of wait time when compared with cable and DSL speeds. I would hardly find it worthwhile unless you're still on 56K or AOL.
--
"It's a butterfly!" -- kid from the MSN 8 commercial

detth
Onemhz On Aim

join:2000-10-06
Astoria, NY

Re: Actually

No one is limiting you from accessing their network. If that was the case, then rules would be set such as -
you may only access on Fridays and Mondays at such and such a time. You can access the network whenever you want with no restriction. The data transfer is what seems to tick them off.
--
B.S Computer Science,CCNP,CCNA,CNA,CCSA,CCSE, A+Network +
pierce2

join:1999-09-22
Santa Cruz, CA

Re: Actually

yeah, cool. access it all you want, just don't USE it for anything? is that it?
vic102482
Premium
join:2002-04-30
Upper Marlboro, MD

edited

Re: Actually

HAHAHAHAHA!!! I know right
[text was edited by author 2003-01-08 02:46:52]

KrK
Heavy Artillery For The Little Guy
Premium
join:2000-01-17
Tulsa, OK
Right, just like the new Broadband plans, or Long Distance, or Telephone service.

Unlimited access.... but don't actually *use* it... just *pay* for it.

roamer1
sticking it out at you

join:2001-03-24
Atlanta, GA
clubs:
·VoicePulse Connect
·Teliax VOIP
·Speed Factory
·Cingular Wireless

said by clyde_ See Profile:
Sprint PCS actually has a clause in their contract against hooking their phones up to a computer and downloading large amounts of data.
The SPCS $10/mo "unlimited Vision" plan includes browsing from the phone ONLY; for ANY tethered (laptop/PDA) connectivity customers must subscribe to other plans -- but people have figured out how to use their laptops/PDAs on the $10 plan anyway. Similar applies to Nextel, which offers unlimited WAP for $3.50 to $15/mo depending on what sites you want to access and what messaging services you want, but they plugged the "free tethered data" hole long ago by issuing only private IPs (and restricting access from those private (10.0.0.0/8) IPs to their WAP gateway only) to WAP-only customers and public IPs only to PacketStream/PowerApps customers.

VZW's WAP does not use packet data (even brand-new phones use old-style CSD -- VZW is more or less alone in not supporting WAP via packet data) so there is no "loophole" to cheap access like there is with SPCS and used to be with Nextel. VZW's "unlimited" Express Network data plan is $100/mo -- MUCH, MUCH more than the $3.50-15 SPCS and Nextel charge for unlimited WAP...

Hence, the SPCS/Nextel situation and the VZW situation are IMO apples and oranges -- the former is people gaining unauthorized access to their data networks (a legitimate beef), the latter is "excessive use" of a connection marketed as unlimited (a questionable beef.)

-SC
--
No-Bull SE US Wireless Info: »www.sewireless.info/
Atlanta Apt/Condo Cable & Broadband Info: »www.atlaptcable.info/

anon4

@charter.com

Wrong.

Actually, I got the Connection Cable *from* a PCS store, when I was *paying* for an 8mb/month plan. At that point, they had NO problem with using the phone with a laptop.

The 'contract' *changed*. After I paid $70 for the cable and connection kit, and got an 8mb plan, they "automatically" switched me to the unlimited plan and said I couldn't use the cable.

So, no, we aren't all bad guys trying to take advantage of poor, poor little Sprint.
vic102482
Premium
join:2002-04-30
Upper Marlboro, MD
·Verizon FIOS

Well your voice is data, all modern cells are digital so its data so what are they talking about? If you are allowed to speak for unlimited times you should be allowed to download for unlimited times.
--
I tie a rope around my penis and jump from a tree, don't you wanna grow up to be just like me!!!!

garagerock
Premium
join:2002-06-14
Louisville, KY

Lionel Hutz would say....

"do these sound like the actions of a man who had all he could eat?"

Go Chargers7
Fa Shizzle Ma Nizzle
Premium
join:2002-09-24
Huntington Beach, CA

WTF?

Whether it's me lipping off or my laptop chirping and squawking, you're paying for the airtime...now they want to regulate what noises can be made with the cheap airtime?
--
Made in America; tested in Japan.
Foxbat121

join:2001-04-25
Herndon, VA

Re: WTF?

said by Go Chargers7 See Profile:
Whether it's me lipping off or my laptop chirping and squawking, you're paying for the airtime...now they want to regulate what noises can be made with the cheap airtime?

You don't pay any airtime for your data access (hence 'unlimited'). We're talking about the new '3G' network here. Not the old school wireless web.

cyberthugin

join:2002-03-12
Kew Gardens, NY


edited

Dictionary

These phone companies should read the dictionary more often.

un·lim·it·ed adj. Having no restrictions or controls:

Don't false advertise something and then bitch about it, biatches!!.
[text was edited by author 2003-01-07 16:02:30]
hysteria1

join:2002-11-29
Saint Louis, MO

Typical!

It is typical for these companies to advertise anything to get you to sign and then renig on the deal. But you can be sure if you try to cancel or not pay, there will be hell to pay!
--
Just because you think they're out to get you doesn't mean they're not!

purplejello

join:2001-08-23
Reno, NV
clubs:
·personalsites.org

I understand that they can't offer 'unlimited'...

... but they shouldn't be advertising it if they can't deliver!!!

Someone further up in this thread made a note about 'unlimited downloads' rather than 'unlimited bytes' or something to that extent. Well, the minimum possible size is a bit. So let's say someone downloads an infinite number of one bit files. Hmm... they've now both downloaded an infinite amount of files and and infinite amount of bits!

Cheers,

James
--
If God is life, and life is warez, anti-piracy is deicide.

:.: Death Ring :.: - Drinking Games, Mixed Drinks, Hot-Or-Not, Girls, Games, Cheats, Hacks, Topsites

Buck Fush
Great Minds With Great Debts.

join:2001-02-24

Re: I understand that they can't offer 'unlimited'...

Exactly, in order for 'downloads' to be unlimited; the 'bytes' have to be unlimited as well. So the 'unlimited downloads' vs 'unlimited bytes' theory doesn't hold. Next?

alanhdsl
Premium
join:1999-10-09
Phoenix, AZ

Unlimited*

The odd thing is that there usually is an explicit "catch" for the "free" nights and weekends plans -- they're actually limited to 1000 or 2500 minutes, or something like that.
N2DEEP

join:2000-08-26
Malvern, AR

The norm is...

Try it unlimited and get used to it or find the bugs they missed. Then they have a clause to change your plan and usage at anytime. They change the plan and either you stay and pay more or you pay $200 to leave them. Either way they get there money. We just thought 3G was the next generation is internet solutions. LOL It worked half ass for the day I tried it out at my home, and my cable I got from my work (RS) worked just fine with the FREE software (Sprint) they give anyone who wants to download it.

keefed_out

@attbi.com

Cell Phone Server

wonder what the upload is from a cell phone
N2DEEP

join:2000-08-26
Malvern, AR

Re: The norm is...

I tried it only once so far on my vision phone and got 35/57 as my speed. I live on the edge of service so it goes in and out. Like dial up speeds for browsing.
--
Gary N2, DPC DRS White, ver 4.0.3.9, NOW!1370 freq, Win XP Pro
Forums » Data Hogs and Glass Ceilings


Friday, 21-Nov 10:50:31 Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Hosting by www.nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo | feedback | contact
over 9 years online! © 1999-2008 dslreports.com.