site Search:


 
   
story category
France Begins Tracking, Booting Millions Of P2P Users
Up to 150,000 IP requests per day could be generated
by Karl Bode Friday 24-Sep-2010 tags: business · alternatives · content
France was one of the first countries to impose laws that require ISPs terminate the service of users who repeatedly engage in copyright infringement. French anti-piracy outfit Trident Media Guard this week began tracking offenders, and will be submitting infringement claims to ISPs. ISPs must then tie the IP to a name, send letters to users, then ultimately disconnect them after repeat offenses. The size and expense of the operation is fairly staggering, as Torrent Freak explores:

The copyright holders will start relatively 'slowly' with 10,000 IP-addresses a day, but within weeks this number is expected to go up to 150,000 IP-addresses per day according to official reports. The Internet providers will be tasked with identifying the alleged infringers' names, addresses, emails and phone numbers. If they fail to do so within 8 days they risk a fine of 1,500 euros per day for every unidentified IP-address.

For scale, Time Warner Cable recently complained about similar lookup requests in relation to the "lawsuit-o-matic" campaign being conducted by the U.S. Copyright Group -- arguing that the maximum number of such requests they could handle was 28 per month -- each of which Time Warner Cable claimed cost them $45. Of course in France, consumers are simply flocking to direct download, UseNet or other un-tracked piracy options, while ISPs are left footing the bill for the entertainment industry's latest Sisyphean endeavor.

view: topics flat text 
Post a:

cableties
Premium
join:2005-01-27
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS

Au revoir!

Bonjour,
Vous êtes un voleur, selon la RIAA / MPAA des chiens aux États-Unis de porc capitaliste.
Par conséquent, nous devons démarrer vous de la internets. Mais seulement temporairement. Vous voyez, nous avons déjà une. Vous stupide, Kanniggetts anglais!
Au revoir!
gpmoo7

join:2009-01-03
Montreal, QC
said by cableties:

Bonjour,
Vous êtes un voleur, selon la RIAA / MPAA des chiens aux États-Unis de porc capitaliste.
Par conséquent, nous devons démarrer vous de la internets. Mais seulement temporairement. Vous voyez, nous avons déjà une. Vous stupide, Kanniggetts anglais!
I'm French and I can tell that's not French ... Google Translated French at best.

Transmaster
Don't Blame Me I Voted For Bill and Opus

join:2001-06-20
Cheyenne, WY

Re: Au revoir!

said by gpmoo7:

I'm French and I can tell that's not French ... Google Translated French at best.
Usually Google translation does a better job then it did this time. I tried to find out what Kanniggetts means to no avail is it a proper name used as an insult?
--
I am quite sure now that often, very often, in matters concerning religion and politics a man's reasoning powers are not above the monkey's.
- Mark Twain in Eruption

N3OGH
Yo Soy Col. "Bat" Guano
Premium
join:2003-11-11
Philly burbs
kudos:1

Re: Au revoir!

French.

Surrender to it! They do.....

AZ_OGM

join:2007-01-12
Phoenix, AZ
Kanniggets: a butchering of the word knights as used by the French Taunter in Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
"Now go away or I shall taunt you a second time"

Transmaster
Don't Blame Me I Voted For Bill and Opus

join:2001-06-20
Cheyenne, WY

Re: Au revoir!

said by AZ_OGM:

Kanniggets: a butchering of the word knights as used by the French Taunter in Monty Python and the Holy Grail.
"Now go away or I shall taunt you a second time"
Thank you! I'll pull up "holy Grail" and watch it again.
--
I am quite sure now that often, very often, in matters concerning religion and politics a man's reasoning powers are not above the monkey's.
- Mark Twain in Eruption
Alky

join:2001-08-12
Cleveland, OH
Well, if you are a Monty Python fan, Kaniggets was a bastardized word meaning knights.
stewie3128

join:2008-11-20
He's paraphrasing a scene from Monty python and the search for the holy Grail.

mmainprize

join:2001-12-06
Houghton Lake, MI

Re: Au revoir!

I don't even know what he said but reading the reply i have to say it is funny. LMAO.

Good old Monty Python and the flying cirus
DabberDan

join:2004-11-15
Gatineau, ON
Reviews:
·NBTel now Aliant

Re: Au revoir!

said by gpmoo7:

said by cableties:

Bonjour,
Vous êtes un voleur, selon la RIAA / MPAA des chiens aux États-Unis de porc capitaliste.
Par conséquent, nous devons démarrer vous de la internets. Mais seulement temporairement. Vous voyez, nous avons déjà une. Vous stupide, Kanniggetts anglais!
I'm French and I can tell that's not French ... Google Translated French at best.
I too am French and that made no sense.

cableties
Premium
join:2005-01-27
Bonjour gpmoo7!

You are correct! I just typed in to Google and translated it to French (well, Google translate).

Hope folks got a chuckle (that figured it out)...

Transmaster
Don't Blame Me I Voted For Bill and Opus

join:2001-06-20
Cheyenne, WY

Re: Au revoir!

said by cableties:

Bonjour gpmoo7!

You are correct! I just typed in to Google and translated it to French (well, Google translate).

Hope folks got a chuckle (that figured it out)...
This is a prime example of why I will never use these translation programs you never know just how it translates out. However

رئيس جمهور محمود احمدی نژاد به خوردن ساندویچ گوشت ران خوک


so take that....
--
I am quite sure now that often, very often, in matters concerning religion and politics a man's reasoning powers are not above the monkey's.
- Mark Twain in Eruption
xenophon

join:2007-09-17
said by gpmoo7:

I'm French and I can tell that's not French ... Google Translated French at best.
Do French Canadians and Euro French even understand each other?

milnoc

join:2001-03-05
H3B
kudos:1

Re: Au revoir!

Funny, but true story. I'm a French Canadian who visited Paris a few years ago. One night in my hotel room, I was channel flipping when I found a French Canadian television show that had French subtitles!

When I realized just how much the spoken and written word were widely different even though they were the same language, I said to myself "ostie d'tabarnak qu'on parle un lousy french!"

Just try and Google translate THAT!
--
Watch my future television channel's public test broadcast!
»thecanadianpublic.com (click "Watch Live!")
xenophon

join:2007-09-17

Re: Au revoir!

said by milnoc:

Funny, but true story. I'm a French Canadian who visited Paris a few years ago. One night in my hotel room, I was channel flipping when I found a French Canadian television show that had French subtitles!

When I realized just how much the spoken and written word were widely different even though they were the same language, I said to myself "ostie d'tabarnak qu'on parle un lousy french!"

Just try and Google translate THAT!
Crazy Frogs, why can't they speak Canadian.

Parogadi
What? Stop Looking At Me Like That
Premium
join:2003-03-31
Racine, WI

»www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rJAw-fuYHk
RichNice

join:2003-01-09
Columbia, MD
SHUT UP WITH THAT FILTHY PIG LATIN!!!!
MaynardKrebs
Premium
join:2009-06-17
kudos:3

The death of the independent ISP

It's an easy way for the entertainment companies to takeover the ISP's -- hit them with hundreds of thousands of request per day that can't possibly be resolved, wait for the penalties to mount, then ask for a default judgment against the ISP. ISP goes bust. Entertainment company, as lagest creditor, takes over ISP in lieu of payment.

Et voila, The Disney ISP.

Then watch the screws be put to customers for 'infringement'.
amungus
Premium
join:2004-11-26
America
Reviews:
·AT&T DSL Service

Re: The death of the independent ISP

AOL is likely frothing like mad right about now to bring "the internet" back to "Channels" - Disney (who also owns ESPN btw) is also likely very interested, as are many other such companies who would LOVE nothing better than to spoon feed people "the internet" as THEY see it...

I hope you are wrong, but we may be witnessing the beginning of the end of the internet as we know it.

jaa
Premium,MVM
join:2000-06-13
kudos:2
Reviews:
·Optimum Online
·Vonage
said by MaynardKrebs:

It's an easy way for the entertainment companies to takeover the ISP's -- hit them with hundreds of thousands of request per day that can't possibly be resolved, wait for the penalties to mount, then ask for a default judgment against the ISP.
The 150,000 is across all ISPs. I could do 150,000 in a day on my PC. I would create a print file, and then outsource it to a mail house.

$45 per letter?? Outsource it to me for half that!!
--
NOTHING justifies terrorism. We don't negotiate with terrorists. Those that support terrorists are terrorists.

Romney2012
Defeat Obama 2012-Chg we can believe in
Premium
join:2002-03-03
USA
kudos:4

Couple points

1 - TWC is full of it. The process could be easily automated. All it is is a database lookup on 2 databases. Check the log files and check the customer database. Pump out a list; a form letter; and a dozen clerks to check for errors and make sure the forms are mailed. TWC has no problem mailing out bills to tens of millions of customers per month.

2. It will be interesting to see the French results as they crack down and how they automate that process due to the threat of gov't action hanging over their head. The ISPs will adjust and like any ongoing process they will find ways to lower the costs.

Video Guy

@ameritech.net

Re: Couple points

Who's side are you on, anyways??

Romney2012
Defeat Obama 2012-Chg we can believe in
Premium
join:2002-03-03
USA
kudos:4

Re: Couple points

said by Video Guy :

Who's side are you on, anyways??
I'm on the side of the copyright holders who would like to get paid and not have their product taken without compensation.

See 15 replies to this post
chimera

join:2009-06-09
Washington, DC
It's not that simple since they don't have a single centralized database for all routing statements in the entire company. Instead it often takes a senior engineer who has the right to find where the IP address is on their network, then what the MAC address of said device is, then the household that is registered with said MAC address which is then forwarded to the billing department where this can be sorted out.

mmainprize

join:2001-12-06
Houghton Lake, MI
said by Romney2012:

1 - TWC is full of it. The process could be easily automated. All it is is a database lookup on 2 databases. Check the log files and check the customer database. Pump out a list; a form letter; and a dozen clerks to check for errors and make sure the forms are mailed. TWC has no problem mailing out bills to tens of millions of customers per month.

2. It will be interesting to see the French results as they crack down and how they automate that process due to the threat of gov't action hanging over their head. The ISPs will adjust and like any ongoing process they will find ways to lower the costs.
You are full of it.

If they did what you say over half of the people that got these letter would be in error. IP's can be changed evey hour and if they start this crap you will see user changing there IP many times a day. That in turn will make it even harder for the ISP to correctly ID the IP during that hour of use.

Remember the logs are on many different servers all over the USA and each user is only stored in a location where he lives on the day, hour, minute, and second he made the connection to some thing illegal or they made a connection to him.

This is a lot of work and it must be triple checked, or the accused customer will come back and sue the ISP for falsely give out the wrong information.

If they start do 150,000 customer a day the ISP will go broke when all this customer accounts are terminated for a repeat offense.
Kearnstd
Elf Wizard
Premium
join:2002-01-22
Mullica Hill, NJ
I side with the Pirates, simply because the entertainment industry keeps wanting to take away our rights as customers.

As someone who buys movies I have to deal with their "Anti-Piracy ads", Previews, FBI and Interpol warnings even before i get to the menu. If one pirates the movie they get right to the movie. What a great industry we have, where the legit copies keep getting more and more work for the consumer. PC Games are the worst in this, some of their DRM has broken systems.
--
[65 Arcanist]Filan(High Elf) Zone: Broadband Reports

HesDeadJim

@verizon.net
said by Romney2012:

1 - TWC is full of it. The process could be easily automated. All it is is a database lookup on 2 databases. Check the log files and check the customer database. Pump out a list; a form letter; and a dozen clerks to check for errors and make sure the forms are mailed. TWC has no problem mailing out bills to tens of millions of customers per month.
BULL. Pure bull. They send the bills easily because a system already exists. They probably don't set up databases that track each ip a customer uses since they never thought they'd have to keep track of it other than in raw logs.

said by jaa:

The 150,000 is across all ISPs. I could do 150,000 in a day on my PC. I would create a print file, and then outsource it to a mail house.

$45 per letter?? Outsource it to me for half that!!
BULL for the same reason. Unless you were trying to be funny.

Romney2012
Defeat Obama 2012-Chg we can believe in
Premium
join:2002-03-03
USA
kudos:4

Re: Couple points

said by HesDeadJim :

said by Romney2012:

1 - TWC is full of it. The process could be easily automated. All it is is a database lookup on 2 databases. Check the log files and check the customer database. Pump out a list; a form letter; and a dozen clerks to check for errors and make sure the forms are mailed. TWC has no problem mailing out bills to tens of millions of customers per month.
They send the bills easily because a system already exists.
So create a system. Big deal. Even mediocre programmers could code this in a few days.

Thespis
I'm not an actor, but I play one on TV.
Premium
join:2004-08-03
Keller, TX

Re: Couple points

said by Romney2012:

said by HesDeadJim :

said by Romney2012:

1 - TWC is full of it. The process could be easily automated. All it is is a database lookup on 2 databases. Check the log files and check the customer database. Pump out a list; a form letter; and a dozen clerks to check for errors and make sure the forms are mailed. TWC has no problem mailing out bills to tens of millions of customers per month.
They send the bills easily because a system already exists.
So create a system. Big deal. Even mediocre programmers could code this in a few days.
So ISP's should spend money to create a system to generate income for an outside entity?
What's the incentive?
--
Fast. Cheap. Safe.
Pick two...

mmainprize

join:2001-12-06
Houghton Lake, MI

Re: Couple points

You got that right and you can add to that, the fact if they do this the ISP will have to terminate there own customer and will be cutting off there own arm.

dcurrey
Premium
join:2004-06-29

2 edits

Just tag everybody

At 150,000 ips a day it would take roughly 427 day to to hit the entire population of 64,000,000. Surly not everybody has an IP, Yet.

Wouldn't it just be quicker to hand over all the isp user info since thats what they want anyway.

Video Guy

@ameritech.net

Re: Just tag everybody

Le Proxy?
AVonGauss
Premium
join:2007-11-01
Boynton Beach, FL

150,000?

150,000? Thats absurd, how about change the law to fine the submitter if they submit a duplicate request within a 30 day period and see what happens.
tmc8080

join:2004-04-24
Brooklyn, NY
Reviews:
·Optimum Online
·Verizon FiOS

conflict of (shareholder) interests

I doubt an ISP would like to lose 1% of their customer base per day on such nonsense. In less than a year... no users... time to shut down the company. Piracy built the internet from what is was (government & academic) network, to dialup- then broadband networks. Not much application for capitalism.. it's the residential customer who transformed the network to world-wide use and BILLIONS in profit for teleom industry (cable companies included).

Much like getting rid of drivers on the road who can't drive a car for speeding. Tell GM, Ford, and Chrysler that they have to make 1/200th the amount of cars they're used to making beause we won't let anyone drive anymore. You can't rid yourself of the pirates and remain a $ PROFITABLE $ network for very long. Watch how (inevitably) the pendulum swings back....
chimera

join:2009-06-09
Washington, DC

Re: conflict of (shareholder) interests

Don't worry, this will most likely result in riots. France likes riots.

El Quintron
... a faint odor of kerosene
Premium
join:2008-04-28
Etobicoke, ON
kudos:2
Reviews:
·TekSavvy DSL
·voip.ms
·WIND Mobile
·TekSavvy Cable

Re: conflict of (shareholder) interests

said by chimera:

Don't worry, this will most likely result in riots. France likes riots.
Something we should be having more of in North America everything our governments or their corporate masters get dim-witted ideas like these.
--
Everything in Moderation... including moderation.

disconnected

@snet.net
said by tmc8080:

Much like getting rid of drivers on the road who can't drive a car for speeding. Tell GM, Ford, and Chrysler that they have to make 1/200th the amount of cars they're used to making beause we won't let anyone drive anymore. You can't rid yourself of the pirates and remain a $ PROFITABLE $ network for very long. Watch how (inevitably) the pendulum swings back....
The reason the people are even allowed to drive at all is because the government figured out long ago that a mobile population earns more TAXABLE income. If no one could drive, we'd be back to an agrarian economy and the IRS would be out of business.
TheGuvnor9

join:2006-06-23
Beverly Hills, CA

Umm...

So the RIAA is Evil, ISPs are Evil, Artists Suck...

If Artists suck so bad, why are people stealing music...?

Simple solution to all this, stop thieving media...

See 6 replies to this post

tiredofit999

@bellsouth.net

Better solution

Here is another simple solution, stop listening to music. Stop buying it stop downloading it stop listening to it stop singing it stop humming it stop thinking about it at all!

Starve these big rich companies out of business and see how they like being oppressed for a while. Ultimately, no company in the world could exist without customers. A company could make all the content it could possibly make but if nobody wants it AT ALL that company will go out of business.

All of this is about greed, GREED is destroying the world! stop greed before it kills us all. When a loaf of bread is $1000 at the grocery store and only big greedy rich music executives can afford it then you will see some rioting all over but by then it will be too late and greed will be the victor. Whats that greedy guy fav saying on cnbc money channel? oh yeah, STOP TRADING! so it is better to just STOP BUYING!

Maybe as consumers we can use greed to our advantage by hoarding our money and don't buy anything that is not neccessary like only buy food clothing and pay bills? Don't even turn the radio on in the car anymore, don't watch or go to the movies anymore. Who needs to spend hundreds of dollars on concert tickets when you can spend more time with your family/friends instead? We don't really NEED any form of entertainment at all. If we stop bothering with all forms of entertainment for one year or two years we will force the weak to go out of business and only the strong and the smart will survive and figure out they better not mess with us again.
munky99999
Munky

join:2004-04-10
canada
Reviews:
·Cybersurf Intern..

ISPs turning away customers?

What industry can actively turn away customers at gigantic rates and then expect to stay in business?

What democracy can actively piss off loads of citizens at gigantic rates and expect to stay in business?

Sorry but copyrights are becoming worse then patents. Copyright trolls are doing far more damage then patent trolls.
LJGoose

join:2008-08-31
Middle Island, NY

LOL

Damn, the French can't even win an internet war. Typical!!

LMAO

maartena
Elmo
Premium
join:2002-05-10
Orange, CA
kudos:1
Reviews:
·AT&T U-Verse
·DIRECTV

They just go elsewhere.

As noted in the newspost itself, users will just flock to other piracy options. Usenet was mentioned, but also "other untrackable" options....

encrypted p2p is already here, but it is slow because not a lot of people use it. Additionally, you can spend $10-15 a month or so on a VPN (in a country other then France) which would allow you to download using a completely different IP address, in a country that does not answer to any French laws, essentially making you completely anonymous, as such VPN providers simply don't keep records.

People WILL get their pirated materials. And the deeper you push the pirates, the harder it will be to track them. The industry just keeps on shooting their own feet here.
--
"I reject your reality and substitute my own!"

jap
Premium
join:2003-08-10
038xx

1 edit

Re: They just go elsewhere.

said by maartena:

...the deeper you push the pirates, the harder it will be to track them. The industry just keeps on shooting their own feet here.
It's so true. They've completely lost touch with consumer realities and clung to old licensing & distribution models.

There are legions of self-limited infringers who think it's wrong to download but they're gonna grab that french cop TV series or bollywood film they cannot, for myriad antiquated reasons, purchase in their own market. Below is what I consider a historically accurate expat pathway to compromised ethics.

Learns bittorrent to get that brit soap s/he can't live without, learns to update router firmware to resolve connection loads, finds a treasure trove of quality BBC/C4/ITV content and friendly expats just like him/her rejoicing in their britTV reunion, buys a faster ISP tier, invests in a slew of harddrives and TV-PC conversion hardware, can now barely tolerate inferior local TV (yes. it's true) and is downloading more, gets nervous about MsM PR/legal static and the transparency of bittorrent, buys usenet access and and learns how to manage nzb and par2 software, direct-download hosting sites emerge so s/he says goodbye to usenet costs & hassle, ddl hosts enjoy an patronage explosion so increases barriers to free use, s/he buys pre-paid access, a hundred ddl sites crop up and the desired content gets fragmented across a dozen sites, the hassle increase & dirty scam feeling of these anti-social ddl sites gets too much, s/he moves back to the bittorrent community and mitigates risk by purchasing an off-shore VPN + server space.

Now s/he's a technical pro using automated RSS downloads with painless streaming to TV and watching content s/he cannot otherwise obtain and .... cancels the local cableTV service.

People can vilify the moral decline of this person all day long but it's a totally reactive chain of events driven by, in this case, a failure of Brit TV to go global. This consumer got what s/he wanted by expending non-trivial effort and expense. Free marketeers take note.

Riplin

join:2002-05-13
canada

Bread and butter

Kick your bread and butter off

There's a business model that will work
dforan

join:2000-12-09
Willoughby, OH

RIAA MPAA and tthe other do nothings

Maybe, naw, but maybe they track down all the spammers and jail their rotten useless butts OR because they in bed with the ISP around the world fix their e-mail to prevent spamming

gatorkram
KaBOOM Baby
Premium
join:2002-07-22
Winterville, NC
kudos:2
Reviews:
·Suddenlink

Counter productive.

I don't know, but if you ask me, kicking people off the internet for stealing music, or movies, or whatever, makes it impossible for them to reform, and consume newer forms of distribution.

Maybe that is the point, and the plan?

They can say that alternative distribution options are failing, so why should they support them. They will neglect to mention the majority of the people who might have been interested in this alternative, are now banned from the network in which they could have done do.

Bravo!
--
Give me bandwidth or give me death!
»/testhistory/661871/4f240

Com6

@comcast.net

Why

So they start booting off users, what are they gonna do when they boot off so many users that they can't stay in business anymore?

Snakeoil
Ignore Button. The coward's feature.
Premium
join:2000-08-05
Mentor, OH
kudos:1
Reviews:
·RoadRunner Cable
·magicjack.com

Out with the new, in with the old.

Sneaker net anyone?
Sure it's slower and less reliable then P2P or usenet, but hey, it worked.

I remember working at a TV repair shop. The owner had a customer that would drop by every week. He had screener copies of movies. The quality was ok to pretty good.
In exchange for the screeners the guy got free TV repairs.
--
Care Bear This: If anything I say offends you, then you have a problem. As I am a stranger to you, so my words should have zero emotional impact on you. If they do, please seek help from Dr. Phil.
Tardfarmers, the home of Dr. Dan.

captnhook

join:2001-02-20
NY

1 edit

France Begins Tracking, Booting Millions Of P2P Users

sacrebleu !

Monday, 04-Jun 11:08:14 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.