site Search:


 
   
story category
HDTV & The Return Of The Antenna
Eighty year old technology makes a U.S. comeback
by Karl Bode Monday 30-Apr-2007
Tipped by Romney2012 See Profile
While Time Warner Cable and DirecTV battle over HD capacity and quality and cable giants tinker with switched digital video to reclaim bandwidth, many HDTV owners have returned to the traditional antenna for uncompressed HDTV signal that trumps all of the above. It's not news to HD fanatics, DirecTV HD owners in markets where local channels aren't served or the startups offering new antenna gear. "Eighty-year-old technology is being redesigned and rejiggered to deliver the best picture quality," says Richard Schneider, president of Antennas Direct, to the Associated Press. "It's an interesting irony."

view: topics flat text 
Post a:
page: 1 · 2
brianiscool

join:2000-08-16
40303
kudos:1

heh

Antenna is the best source
cwh

join:2006-05-14
San Antonio, TX

Re: heh

Just wait till the local stations start lowering bitrate so they can have multiple subchannels.
ke4pym
Premium
join:2004-07-24
Charlotte, NC
Reviews:
·VOIPo
·Verizon Broadban..
·RoadRunner Cable
·Northland Cable ..

Re: heh

Actually, this might not happen so much as you would think.

The FCC recently mandated that each sub channel (even if it is just weather radar) must present a certain amount of childrens programming. And, it must be counted seperately of the main channel's childrens programming content.

So, if the requirement is 20 hours a month for your main channel and you're running 3 sub channels you've now got to come up with an additional 60 hours of content.

Many of the stations in my market shut down their weather radar channel because of this requirement.
cwh

join:2006-05-14
San Antonio, TX

Re: heh

Childrens programs can have advertisements too. I bet the shutdown is only long to find content and advertisers. It seems like a dumb requirement.
ke4pym
Premium
join:2004-07-24
Charlotte, NC
Reviews:
·VOIPo
·Verizon Broadban..
·RoadRunner Cable
·Northland Cable ..

Re: heh

said by cwh:

Childrens programs can have advertisements too. I bet the shutdown is only long to find content and advertisers. It seems like a dumb requirement.
There are a lot of limitations for commercials during kid's programming. Depending on going rates, it might not even be worth it.

»www.fcc.gov/parents/commercials.html
»www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/childtv.html

I also have it on pretty good authority that those sub channels are gone for good (atleast on the stations in question here).
cwh

join:2006-05-14
San Antonio, TX

Re: heh

Given that broadcasting a subchannel is very low cost, I cant see how it would not be worth while,even if you run the childrens programs at a loss.
JimF
Premium
join:2003-06-15
Allentown, PA

1 edit

Re: heh

But if it were worth it to run the children's programming before the requirement in order to earn the advertising revenue, they would have done it. The children's programming requirement can only reduce their incentive to run the sub-channel.

morbo
Complete Your Transaction

join:2002-01-22
00000

Re: heh

now why would they do that? seriously. the FCC wouldn't do it willy nilly. does it screw over cableco's somehow and benefit telcos?
robertfl
Premium
join:2005-10-10
Mary Esther, FL

1 edit

Re: heh

If I were to encounter a programme with E/I on it, it should be commercial free. Why the FCC is allowing commercials to be put in kid's programmes is beyond me.

What a way to get kids today introduced to "ads"
(skip)

(There misleading anyway)

Rob

Hall
Premium,MVM
join:2000-04-28
Dayton, OH
kudos:1
said by ke4pym:

Many of the stations in my market shut down their weather radar channel because of this requirement.
Only one of my local stations operates a weather channel and they started it up not long before the Jan 1, 2007 deadline for this children's programming requirement. It's still running today too....

Fox McCloud
Crazy like a fox.

join:2006-07-23

Re: heh

said by Hall:

said by ke4pym:

Many of the stations in my market shut down their weather radar channel because of this requirement.
Only one of my local stations operates a weather channel and they started it up not long before the Jan 1, 2007 deadline for this children's programming requirement. It's still running today too....
I'll second that; I'm really glad they did too; while it's definitely not an exciting channel, I find it far more beneficial to watch and listen to that THE Weather Channel, but that's just me.

Either way, I really like my HD offering off of my antenna; all but one of my regular channels broadcasts in HD at some time during the week.
ricep5
Premium
join:2000-08-07
Jacksonville, FL

Re: heh

said by Fox McCloud:

said by Hall:

said by ke4pym:

Many of the stations in my market shut down their weather radar channel because of this requirement.
Only one of my local stations operates a weather channel and they started it up not long before the Jan 1, 2007 deadline for this children's programming requirement. It's still running today too....
I'll second that; I'm really glad they did too; while it's definitely not an exciting channel, I find it far more beneficial to watch and listen to that THE Weather Channel, but that's just me.

Either way, I really like my HD offering off of my antenna; all but one of my regular channels broadcasts in HD at some time during the week.
The Weather Channel has become a wasteland of enhanced weather "specials", most hosted by mr. superlative Jim Cantore. They were better when they stuck to just weather reporting and analysis instead of trying to make it a soap.
wvcaver
Premium
join:2005-04-17
Millersburg, OH

Re: heh

i used to watch them all the time!
now i would rather get my weather off of the internet!

Fox McCloud
Crazy like a fox.

join:2006-07-23
yep; I completely agree; heck, I can remember when they didn't even have a weather man, or anyone talking on the channel; it was just a 24/7 radar view with elevator music.

Subaru
1-3-2-4
Premium
join:2001-05-31
Greenwich, CT
Reviews:
·Packet8
·Verizon Online DSL
·AT&T Yahoo
·Optimum Online
·STANAPHONE

Re: heh

said by Fox McCloud:

yep; I completely agree; heck, I can remember when they didn't even have a weather man, or anyone talking on the channel; it was just a 24/7 radar view with elevator music.
Ditto now everything I seem to turn it on it's some weather show or it seems like a news reporting channel.

I kid you not I used to have it turned to the channel 24/7
--
It's NOT Ni-kon It's NE-KON!




Check out my Gallery!
»/pics/dimaging/400265



Michieru2
zzz zzz zzz
Premium
join:2005-01-28
Miami, FL

Re: heh

You are not the only one.
Time4aNAP
Premium
join:2007-04-09
Des Plaines, IL
Ironically, TWC's weather.com website is as good as TWC on cable is bad.
TACSPEED
Premium
join:2001-04-14
Tacoma, WA
I don't see where you come up with 20 hours per month. The FCC web site says 3 hours per week of core programing. Is the web site wrong?

»www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/childtv.html

In my area, no one has pulled the plug on local weather channel or the channel dedicated to a camera directed on the local airport.
--
Fiber Optics is the future of high-speed internet access. Stop by the BBR Fiber Optic Forum.

Topmounter
Sent By Grocery Clerks

join:2001-02-20
Evergreen, CO
Oh good, great idea, kids need to watch MORE television

56403739
Less than 5 months left
Premium
join:2006-03-08
Naples, FL
kudos:2
They already do it here (multiple subchannels) but the picture quality still beats the snot out of what Comcast squirts through their coax around here. And this is not a major market...

bobb cobb

@swbell.net

Re: heh

Same here and I hate it. Our ABC station has several subchannels, one a radar and the other "the CW". I wish they would at least turn off the radar (if there is no bad weather) during prime time ABC shows like they do in Dallas.

en102
Canadian, eh?

join:2001-01-26
Valencia, CA
Gotta love it...
Free (i.e. no cable/satellite bill) and better quality (no extra compression schemes).
--
Canada = Hollywood North
AJICQ499087

join:2001-12-01
Louisville, KY

Re: heh

I watch HDTV over the air for free on my 2005 XP Media Center PC and I often record the goodies to an exteral USB hard drive.
--
low cost and fast speed is what customers want in broadband
Time4aNAP
Premium
join:2007-04-09
Des Plaines, IL

Re: Compression

IIRC, ATSC uses MPEG2 compression, and DirecTV uses MPEG4. Cable can vary with the provider. IME MPEG2 gives a better picture than MPEG4. On paper, MPEG4 seems capable of providing a better overall picture. However in practice it seems to be used mostly to conserve bandwidth.
Lysis

join:2005-03-30
Brooklyn, NY

reception

not everyone gets reception, there is some website that has info on what antenna you should get depending on A)distance from broadcast 2) what obstacles are between you and the broadcast ie trees, skyscrapers etc.

if you get a hdtv tuner that happens to be bundled with the correct antenna it can be a good deal

Romney2012
Defeat Obama 2012-Chg we can believe in
Premium
join:2002-03-03
USA
kudos:4

Re: reception

said by Lysis:

not everyone gets reception, there is some website that has info on what antenna you should get depending on A)distance from broadcast 2) what obstacles are between you and the broadcast ie trees, skyscrapers etc.
Here is the web site you refer to:

»www.antennaweb.org/


But because of the Yahoo news story, they are getting so many hits that it overwhelmed their servers. Try back there in a day or two.
--
--
Internet News
My BLOG
My Web Page

RR Conductor
Happy 40th Amtrak
Premium
join:2002-04-02
Redwood Valley, CA
kudos:1

1 edit

Re: reception

I got it to work, we can get a grand total of....3 local (all out of SF, 115 miles south) stations via antenna, we currently get 25 locals on Directv.

Edit-I think you can get more in this area, but our location is surrouned by trees and hills, so it limits it.
TACSPEED
Premium
join:2001-04-14
Tacoma, WA

Re: reception

I get thirty five channels out of Seattle/Tacoma.

tschmidt
Premium,MVM
join:2000-11-12
Milford, NH
kudos:5
Reviews:
·Fairpoint Commun..
·Hollis Hosting
said by Romney2012:

they are getting so many hits that it overwhelmed their servers. Try back there in a day or two.
It is a great resource run by the Consumer Electronics Association.

Once things simmer down print out a copy of the map showing signal strength and direction.

My only complaint is it does not show all the PBS stations and repeaters.

/Tom

Hall
Premium,MVM
join:2000-04-28
Dayton, OH
kudos:1

1 edit
said by Lysis:

there is some website...
The one mentioned in the article, right ??

It doesn't know about trees, skyscrapers, etc though. It *asks* you if those things are between you and the broadcast towers though. I do believe it factors in hills and am real sure it knows about mountains.
axus

join:2001-06-18
Washington, DC
Reviews:
·Verizon Online DSL

It's difficult to find a cheap non-USB tuner

I wanted to get a gift for a friend who watched over-the-air television, I thought an HD tuner+antenna would be nice. Wow, I couldn't find anything under $200. I think it's still an early-adopter market with early-adopter prices.

There was much more competition and lower prices for USB antennas, I'm assuming they rely on the computer and driver to handle some expensive things.

The first company to design a tuner/antenna for $40+$40 will make millions when the USA switches over from analog to digital and hands out all those coupons.

See 7 replies to this post

antdude
A Ninja Ant
Premium,VIP
join:2001-03-25
kudos:2
Reviews:
·RoadRunner Cable

Had to dump my rabbit ears and get a bowtie antenna.

I got one of these bowtie antennae: »www.antennasdirect.com/DB2_Indoo···nna.html (30 miles). It works better for analog feed too, but channels 2, 4, and 5 aren't clear still.

See 8 replies to this post
RayW
Premium
join:2001-09-01
Layton, UT
kudos:1

It works

We are about 45 miles from the transmitters and my neighbor uses the antenna (a normal VHF/UHF that he has had for years) for HDTV and the small dish for all else. He says broadcast HDTV works better than the satellite feeds.

I think I will wait another couple of years, then move my antenna out of the attic and get a HDTV (mine will be about 9 years old anyway).
--
I am not lost, I find myself every time.

See 10 replies to this post

WeSRT4

join:2000-11-20
Mobile, AL

Antenna FTW

I'm currently running a Radioshack VU-90 with the Radioshack antenna mounted amplifier. This way I get all the HD I want with the exception of Discovery HD. Can't beat the price.

No to ESPN

@sbcglobal.net

Antenna for the Masses

Bought a 23 inch HDTV this Xmas and have been running it off a set of rabbit ears. I am trying to figure out how to get a feed from the big antenna in the attic to the HDTV in the kitchen but there are quite a few barriers such as walls, a staircase and getting from the second story to the first. Having said that the picture on the HDTV with the rabbit ears is quite a bit better than the cable HDTV in the neighborhood. In fact the antenna feeding the old Sony 36 inch XBR tv in the living room produces a better picture than the cable HDTV most of the time. Satellite quality is almost the same but I ain't paying $ 50 to 100 dollars a month so my antenna is a lot better!

In addition, some of the sub-channel stuff is actually pretty good. My wife is hooked on a sub-channel that plays popular music all day long.

If you live within 50 miles of the broadcast antennas like I do I would recommend the trial of reception antenna. There is no need for a special HDTV antenna as the signal is still UHF/VHF. An amp may be needed in some cases. Trees and building can be a problem. Enjoy.

inteller
Sociopaths always win.

join:2003-12-08
Tulsa, OK

great for locals....useless for everything else.

sorry, I'll stick to cable. I cant exactly get ESPNHD, MHD, and National Geographic over the air.

See 11 replies to this post

Jwobot

join:2002-08-14
Sterling Heights, MI

simple

I can get HD channels with this.

Uhdudh

@mb.ca

But...

How many people are in markets where there is OTA HD signal?
RadioDoc
58ef2c0
Premium,ExMod 2000-03
join:2000-05-11

Re: But...

Almost all of them.

koolman2
Premium
join:2002-10-01
Anchorage, AK

1 edit
Many. Hell, in Anchorage Alaska, I can get OTA HD NBC, PBS, and CBS.
--
There's no place like ::1.

RR Conductor
Happy 40th Amtrak
Premium
join:2002-04-02
Redwood Valley, CA
kudos:1

1 edit

Hah! Nope.

The nearest TV station to us is in Santa Rosa, 70 miles south (most of the channels come out of SF, 100 miles south), all the signals here are broadcast from a repeater on Spanish Mountain. There is a grad, hunkin' total of 3 locals available here, on Directv we get 25 locals No thanks, I'll stick with my Directv

Edit-Our locals come out of the SF Bay Area.

See 8 replies to this post

HRM
God Bless America
Premium,MVM
join:2002-02-03
Darien, CT
kudos:1

1 edit

Big Problem here in NY is the broadcast Quality

No station but PBS ch 13 routinely broadcasts 1080i. Even the superbowl was crap HD. Calling 480i HD has given all the stations an out which they gladly take. Why bother using the bandwidth if the general public is too dumb to know the difference.

I can't believe most people are OK with less than the best signal, but I have no doubt that the quality of "HD" will always be less than what it could be if people would demand the best that technology can produce on current equipment.

EDIT: For example, no network show that I know of is broadcast at 1080i. No matter how much money they rake in, they never bother to give us the best our sets can deliver. I think of it as robbing us of the money we waste on sets that can display resolutions they refuse to broadcast.

See 13 replies to this post

rudnicke
Premium
join:2004-10-23
Rantoul, IL
kudos:1

Split

Can you split a single HD antenna between three HD TV's?
russotto

join:2000-10-05
West Orange, NJ

Re: Split

Yes, depending on available signal strength you either need an ordinary 3-way splitter, or an amplifier plus a splitter.
RadioDoc
58ef2c0
Premium,ExMod 2000-03
join:2000-05-11
There is no such thing as an "HD antenna". Get a simple splitter, hook it to the antenna feed, and connect your TVs. If you are in Rantoul you should have no problem picking up any of the Champaign locals with a small antenna.
--
Toolmaster of La Grange.

MadMANN
Premium
join:2005-08-19
kudos:2

Re: Split

said by RadioDoc:

There is no such thing as an "HD antenna".
Shhhh. Don't tell Radio Shack.

»www.radioshack.com/family/index.···e%2FHDTV

Andypro

@mindspring.com

I have the opposite problem

I live within a mile of most all the transmission towers. The multipath interference is too much for my DVICO Fusion HDTV tuner to handle. In fact, pointing my indoor antenna *away* from the window frequently improves performance. But I couldn't fully replace cable with my setup because it's simply too unreliable.

Poor signal strength is one thing, but multipath interference is just as bad.
russotto

join:2000-10-05
West Orange, NJ

Re: I have the opposite problem

Maybe it's overload rather than multipath? An attenuator might help.

Alex G Bell

join:2002-07-02
Boston, MA

1 edit

Antennas

"Antennas are cheap, and they're old technology so the price likely won't be changing soon."

Not so fast, friend; recent antenna technology has benefited from computer modeling. The newer Winegards, etc., are good designs and affordable, especially if you buy them at the wholesale price. Since HD is carried on UHF frequencies, the antennas tend to be small compared to VHF antennas for a given amount of gain. It is not a bad idea to buy the highest gain "outdoor" antenna you can afford. If the signal level is too high for the input of your set, pad it down with a pad at the input to the TV. The idea is to obtain as much signal as possible from the desired direction; the higher gain antennas are also the most directional and thus less prone to multipath interference. Use quad-shield RG-6 cable with the "snap-and-seal" F-connectors, seal all outdoor connections with stuff made for that purpose (found at Radio Shack), use lightning protection, and don't bend the cable too sharp (sharp bends cause standing waves in the cable).

The inexpensive antennas work well outside in climates like Southern California. In places like New England, if you can get by putting one in your attic, do so. You will sacrifice at least 3 dB of gain, but your antenna won't corrode (and thus act like a diode) or blow apart. Where I live I would not dare put a large inexpensive antenna on my roof; it would easily blow down within a few months.

If you really want a good outdoor antenna that is built to last in severe weather, buy a Scala. They are expensive (over $350.00) but they are the best made period. See:

»www.kathrein-scala.com/uhf-tv.htm
--
"Remember, Comrade, people who are willing to destroy an efficient telephone system may not be playing with a full deck."

See 6 replies to this post

brycarp75

join:2000-11-18
Loveland, CO

Remember when cable was "a better antenna"?

How much chance do you think I would have to convince Comcrap to feed me my local digital channels over the raw cable so I could just tune them on a regular ATSC tuner like I would from an antenna. Hah! Doesn't quite fit their revenue models now.

See 11 replies to this post
houselog442

join:2005-10-05

Silver Sensor is all you need

I use the Silver Sensor to pick up channels over the air. It is the best UHF indoor antenna that I ever had. With a small amp I can get up to 50 miles, and when in lived in Citrus County, I was able to get WTSP in Holiday, and it is 60 miles away!
russotto

join:2000-10-05
West Orange, NJ

Re: Silver Sensor is all you need

Alas, what works in flat Florida won't always work for the rest of us.

ColorBASIC
8-bit Fun
Premium
join:2006-12-29
Corona, CA

OTA works great

Great pic and most new DBS HD boxes integrate OTA into the onscreen program guide. My old HD-DirecTiVo and MPEG4 D* boxes did and my MPEG4 ViP boxes from E* do. And I definately see a difference in quality flipping between E* delivered network HD and OTA HD.

FutureMon
Keep your Mitts off RMoney
Premium,ExMod 2002-05
join:2000-10-05
Seaside, CA

Antenna

I've got one of these mounted to a pole on the side of my house. It's about 15 feet above my roof and has coax coming down from it.

I tried connecting the coax to the input to my house wiring, but it didn't seem to do much in regards to reception...

- FM
--
Undisputed BBR Karaoke Champion! Care to challenge me?
russotto

join:2000-10-05
West Orange, NJ

Re: Antenna

Is it pointed the right way? (small end towards the towers)? Are there elements broken off of it? If you connect the coax directly to a TV (rather than involving the house wiring) does it work well?

Is it possible there's a pre-amp on it? That would be a small box mounted on the mast beneath the antenna. If so, you need a power injector to make it work. But you'll need to see what kind it is.

Probably you'll have to take it down or get up to it to see if there's any broken or bad connections.

FutureMon
Keep your Mitts off RMoney
Premium,ExMod 2002-05
join:2000-10-05
Seaside, CA

Re: Antenna

heh yeah a couple of the "arms" have come loose and they are just hanging by their wires. There is a box attached to it as well. I just tried connecting the coax to the input to the house wiring. Never tried connecting directly to a TV. It's pointing due south.

- FM
--
Undisputed BBR Karaoke Champion! Care to challenge me?

CatSnak
RIP Splashy - We miss you
Premium
join:2001-05-06
Lakeside, CA

Re: Antenna

said by FutureMon:

heh yeah a couple of the "arms" have come loose and they are just hanging by their wires. There is a box attached to it as well. I just tried connecting the coax to the input to the house wiring. Never tried connecting directly to a TV. It's pointing due south.

- FM
Broken antenna's don't work very well. You can get a new one at Wal-Mart fairly cheap.
--
Founding member, 2002-2003, 2005-2006 Director of Communications, 2004-2005 Secretary for the Crunchenstein Project
russotto

join:2000-10-05
West Orange, NJ
Looks like most of your stations are actually E-NE, and those broken elements don't help.

Since Antennaweb is down you can try this site to find your local stations:

»www.2150.com/broadcast/

JukeBoxHero
Premium
join:2001-12-30
USA
kudos:1
Reviews:
·Comcast

Best Picture Quality

Looks like the old days have returned with the resurgence of the antenna. Wait until people find out that the the best HDTV picture quality is still the CRT over Plasma and LCD! Back to the future.

Monday, 04-Jun 21:57:53 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.