dslreports logo

story category
OpenDNS CEO Speaks Out Against COICA
A 'terrible precedent for the U.S. government to set'
by Karl Bode 12:02PM Monday Dec 06 2010
David Ulevitch, Founder and CEO of OpenDNS, offers an interesting blog post focused specifically on COICA. COICA (or the Combating Online Infringements and Counterfeits Act) would create a website blacklist and give the entertainment industry lawyer stocked Department of Justice the ability to censor or shut down certain websites deemed "dedicated to infringing activities" -- without Judicial review. Despite the bill having significant First Amendment issues, the bill has seen broad support from several misguided politicians, who keep trying to speed the bill through the legislative process. Ulevitch argues the bill is a "terrible precedent" to set:
...as we’ve seen with the ongoing Wikileaks.org saga, the government will try and utilize whatever resources it can to take sites offline. There is absolutely no need to arm them with a tool to automate it, let alone one that sits outside of any judicial review as COICA does. Blocking a domain name is black and white act, meaning that if the Justice Department decided that one aspect of a website was enough to make infringement “central” their only recourse would be to block the entire website rather than systematically removing the infringing portion. For many sites this would lead to massive censorship of data and speech that was non-infringing.

76 comments .. click to read

Recommended comments

·Google Voice
·Future Nine Corp..

2 recommendations

reply to Harddrive

Re: Welcome to the Communist United States!

When are people going to wake up and realize that regardless of political party, our politicians are in the pocket of large business. Of late we have only our courts to protect us from ever growing government, and they aren't doing such a hot job.
"People demand freedom of speech as a compensation for the freedom of thought which they seldom use."

Proud American and Infidel since 1968.

2 recommendations

reply to chimera

Actually it it should be called The United States of Corporate America.
Liberty is allowing other people to do the things you disapprove of.


2 recommendations

reply to FFH

Re: Funny coming from a site who's business based on blacklists

Here is the difference. You pick what you don't want not some Government removing what they see fit for any reason they please.