Dogfather Premium Member join:2007-12-26 Laguna Hills, CA 2 edits |
I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksIf I want to watch commercials I'd watch it live.
But so long as it's not replacing anything I don't care. The only problem I see is what are we giving up in order to provide channel bandwidth for this. Is SDV really saving enough to cover this plus the addition of other HD channels. | |
|
| |
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksThat does sound rather useless, doesn't it?
HD Tivo + CableCARD = much better solution. | |
|
| | Dogfather Premium Member join:2007-12-26 Laguna Hills, CA |
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksNo SDV adapter yet for c-card TiVo and I personally don't care for TiVo's ad covered GUI. | |
|
| | | |
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksCompared to "start over" it's downright brilliant. You folks must get a lot of ads out west. We rarely see more than one or two a month, and they are unobtrusive, unlike the 4/5 screen Comcast stuffs ads into on their program guide.
Once SDV starts here I'm off to satellite anyway. Not a big issue. | |
|
| | MacLeechThe one and only Premium Member join:2001-07-14 SoCal |
to RadioDoc
said by RadioDoc:That does sound rather useless, doesn't it? HD Tivo + CableCARD = much better solution. What if you don't have a Tivo or DVR, but do have a regular cable box? What if you didn't schedule the program to record and missed part of the show? That's the intended audience for the "Start Over" service. Start Over isn't intended to replace a DVR... | |
|
| | | |
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksIt's still rather useless. They should use those resources to improve their service not implement some lame gimmick they claim differentiates them from satellite providers. | |
|
| | | | Thaler Premium Member join:2004-02-02 Los Angeles, CA |
Thaler
Premium Member
2008-Feb-8 2:06 pm
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksEh, does the "start over" work on programs you *just* tuned into, or ones that have been streaming through? If so, I would consider that more a feature than a gimic. Tuning into the last 5 minutes to a show you wanted to watch, hitting "start over", and then watching it from the beginning certainly has its merits.
...but if it comes with the sacrifice of no pause/FF/rewind function to go to the bathroom, grab snacks, ponder life, etc. for a few minutes, then yeah...no way in hell I'd make that sacrifice. | |
|
| | | | | TechyDad Premium Member join:2001-07-13 USA |
TechyDad
Premium Member
2008-Feb-8 2:27 pm
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksIt works on shows that you've just tuned into. So let's say you're running late and wind up tuning into your favorite show 20 minutes late, you could hit "Select" and then choose "Start Over." The show would then restart from the beginning. I believe it has pause capabilities, but no fast forward (so no channel skipping). It is a useful feature, but it doesn't replace a DVR box. | |
|
| | | | | | MacLeechThe one and only Premium Member join:2001-07-14 SoCal |
MacLeech
Premium Member
2008-Feb-8 4:45 pm
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thankssaid by TechyDad: It is a useful feature, but it doesn't replace a DVR box. It's not meant to. | |
|
| |
to Dogfather
Yes,
The SO content is broadcast over the same QAM's as your current VOD service thus only adding additional bandwidth load when you request for it. SDV should be able to handle this load. | |
|
| TechyDad Premium Member join:2001-07-13 USA |
to Dogfather
I've used Time Warner Cable's regular Start Over feature from time to time. (Don't watch HD content because I don't have an HD TV.) It's most useful if you've missed 5 or 10 minutes of a show. You can catch up and then jump to live TV. I have noticed a few glitches, though. For example, if you Start Over a show and then open the Guide, it will jump you back to Live TV, losing your place in the process and forcing you to Start Over all over again.
But I still would rather use the DVR since you can commercial skip. (Unfortunately, our DVR keeps bombing out, Time Warner Cable's only solution is to replace it, and they can't transfer my previously recorded shows from the old DVR to the new one.) | |
|
| Anonymous_Anonymous Premium Member join:2004-06-21 127.0.0.1 1 edit |
to Dogfather
said by Dogfather:If I want to watch commercials I'd watch it live. But so long as it's not replacing anything I don't care. The only problem I see is what are we giving up in order to provide channel bandwidth for this. Is SDV really saving enough to cover this plus the addition of other HD channels. same here they will be takeing my HD box over my Dead body AD's SUCk the Audio is OUT of Sync with the show so that is why i use the mute butten on live TV | |
|
| KearnstdSpace Elf Premium Member join:2002-01-22 Mullica Hill, NJ |
to Dogfather
is so sad Cablevision listened to the C&D order for their network DVR. why couldnt they tell the industry to go Fsck itself we are the route to your customers who dont want to go out. | |
|
| | |
Re: I'll keep my regular HD-DVR thanksBecause then the program providers--you know, the folks who produce the programming you watch and that filed the lawsuit--would yank their product leaving Cablevision with, well, whatever they produce themselves. | |
|
digiblur Premium Member join:2002-06-03 Louisiana |
digiblur
Premium Member
2008-Feb-8 11:13 am
Stretch-o-vision on Demand eh?Stretch-o-vision on Demand eh? | |
|
| |
Re: Stretch-o-vision on Demand eh?When I had TWC their on-demand stuff was absolute garbage. If you found something you liked, you probably got about 2-3 minutes of it before it just locked up, lost audio sync, or something else.
I was not a happy camper. | |
|
|
hahahaIs there really demand for this service? Why not focus R&D resources on providing faster broadband speeds, more HD channels, and HD-VOD? Seems pointless if you can't fast forward commercials. Are there people out there who are actually enjoy watching corporate advertising?? | |
|
dvd536as Mr. Pink as they come Premium Member join:2001-04-27 Phoenix, AZ |
dvd536
Premium Member
2008-Feb-8 4:16 pm
No commercial skip. . . . .Forget it! | |
|
|
|