republican-creole
site Search:


 
   
story category
Verizon, Time Warner Bicker Over NYC HD Channel Counts
TWC has 150 to Verizon's 133...
by Karl Bode Thursday 26-Aug-2010 tags: Video · competition · business · cable · content · consumers · Verizon FiOS · Time Warner Cable
Time Warner Cable hasn't exactly set land speed records with their deployment of DOCSIS 3.0 technology, only deploying faster services "tactically," in markets where the company competes with Verizon FiOS. In New York City, where Time Warner Cable competes with FiOS, they have upgraded -- and are now bragging that they have 150 HD channels to Verizon's 133. Verizon was quick to fire back, insisting that Time Warner Cable only has more channels due to Cablevision's vise-like grip on local sports programming:

"Time Warner Cable can make a claim of having a few more HD channels than Verizon FiOS, but our service still blows them out of the water with more VOD, more HD VOD, more interactive features, better picture quality, faster Internet speeds, the only place to get Facebook, Twitter and YouTube on TV - the list goes on." In addition, the cable operator's claim of having all nine New York sports teams in HD "is only possible because of an FCC loophole used by Cablevision [Systems] through which they share the HD feeds for some of these channels with their cable brethren, but withhold the channels from us."

Of course new FCC rules will eventually force cable operators to stop hoarding access to local sports programming, though regulatory progress on this front seems typically glacial. Meanwhile, since only about a third or less of Time Warner Cable markets see FiOS competition, most Time Warner Cable markets aren't seeing this kind of fighting for consumer affection whatsoever.

view: topics flat text 
Post a:
curls310

join:2007-09-26
Hillsdale, NJ

TWC blows

I used to have their service. Poor pic quality, slow internet and frequent service interruptions. Now I have FOIS. Couldnt be happier with my service. Paid for 25/25 and getting 35/30 speeds. You would NEVER see TWC giving you a free kbs let alone free mbs. If VZ gets their act together in Manhattan, it's game over for the TWC monopoly.
bkz81
Premium
join:2010-08-16
united state

Re: TWC blows

I couldn't agree more. I got FIOS about 2 weeks ago and love it! Verizon is hitting my area hard with door to door salesman, and i also see a Verizon truck in the area almost every day. IF they continue to expand in NYC then Time Warner may be in trouble.

TWfan

@rr.com

And You're point is?........

You guys are in competition, That's how it is

aztecnology
O Rly?
Premium
join:2003-02-12
Murrieta, CA

Re: And You're point is?........

said by TWfan :

You guys are in competition, That's how it is
Not for long, bwahahahaha....
--
.:|:. This link for rent...!

lakerfan82

join:2009-01-30
Corona, CA

1 edit

MSG/RSNs?

So verizon doesn't have access to the MSG/RSN channels? How many channels is that, like 4 at most? What's Verizon's excuse for the other ~13 channels?

Nanoprobe
Crunching in memory of Mom
Premium
join:2003-05-11
Crab Nebula
kudos:1

Re: MSG/RSNs?

*yawn* Who cares?

lakerfan82

join:2009-01-30
Corona, CA

Re: MSG/RSNs?

Real constructive...If you don't care, why did you read, and then comment on, this article?

Nanoprobe
Crunching in memory of Mom
Premium
join:2003-05-11
Crab Nebula
kudos:1
Reviews:
·magicjack.com
·Skype

Re: MSG/RSNs?

said by lakerfan82:

Real constructive...If you don't care, why did you read, and then comment on, this article?
Cuz I can.

Maybe I shouldn't have yawned. These endless threads about one provider or another are really quite amusing. Carry on.
--
Luke 16:19-31
Which side of the chasm will you be on?


JeepMatt
C'mon the U
Premium
join:2001-12-28
Wilmington, DE
kudos:2
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
said by lakerfan82:

So verizon doesn't have access to the MSG/RSN channels? How many channels is that, like 4 at most? What's Verizon's excuse for the other ~13 channels?
VZ's excuse is that they got caught sleeping behind the wheel for the 2nd time in 3 years and are currently out of channel capacity.
--
"ONE team - ONE city - ONE dream!!"

lakerfan82

join:2009-01-30
Corona, CA

Re: MSG/RSNs?

If what you say is true, to me, that is a far bigger story than Verizon's fight with MSG. How is it possible that a FTTH provider has less QAM space available for HD than a Cable Company that is supporting broadband AND analog in that same space? Obviously, TW must be compressing the shit out of their HD channels, but that only accounts for some of the bandwidth...
DrDrew

join:2009-01-28
Apple Valley, CA
kudos:6

1 edit

Re: MSG/RSNs?

SDV (switched digital video) allows cable ops the ability to broadcast some channels only when requested by customers. FIOS doesn't have it.

Also cable ops fit 3 HD channels in the space FIOS fits 2. It's not all HD, only ones that make sense in terms of bandwidth. When done correctly no extra compression is needed and pic quality is unaffected.
markofmayhem
I can haz competition?
Premium
join:2004-04-08
Pittsburgh, PA
kudos:4

Re: MSG/RSNs?

FiOS built out on 870mhz coax plant, from the demarcation point where fiber ENDS to your TV. It's full. Verizon limited next gen tech to last gen constraints. IPTV (a form of SDV) can solve it, but questions arise to backwards compatibility as FiOS is a CableCard mandated operator. Upgrading all STB's to 1ghz tuners is another temporary fix. Using variable bit rate mux is yet another, as null bits to fill 3mhz of space for 720p video fills up a network quickly (ABC, ESPN, etc).

FiOS has been mismanaged from the beginning. Fiber to the home: cool, from the point on was a failure. At least the guide and software was fixed early, the bandwidth should have been as well.
--
I can haz competition?

runzero

join:2005-09-16
DC
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·DSL EXTREME

1 edit

Re: MSG/RSNs?

Just wait a few more months until IPTV is deployed. It's already in the works.

Verizon recently tested 3 HD to 1 QAM in Texas with several (IMO) low-bandwidth channels. The results were awful and they quickly reverted it, so there goes the whole "extra compression is fine" thing you're suggesting.

If FiOS were mismanaged, it would turn out looking out more like U-verse. Now that's mismanagement. FTTN has dug AT&T into a deeper hole than they can get out of right now.
--
This signature has consumed several bytes of your bandwidth.
guppy_fish
Premium
join:2003-12-09
Lakeland, FL
kudos:1
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS

No MSG For You

Will never happen on FIOS, ever, MSG was spun of and is legally a separate company which then excludes it from the regulatory terrestrial loop-pole stuff

People can post a thousand times about similar shareholders and other things, don't mean squat, when CV spun off MSG, they make it air tight legally and in the courts, that's all that matters
nh5

join:2006-01-21
Old Bethpage, NY

Wasted Bandwidth on VZ

Verizon has so much waste in there system, that's why they are out of space. There's like 2 dozen empty public access channels. On top of that I thought the FCC had rules that a channel provider aka MSG had to competitively offer there channels to every available provider?

runzero

join:2005-09-16
DC
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·DSL EXTREME

1 edit

Re: Wasted Bandwidth on VZ

The public access channels are required by the FCC and they only take up 1-2 QAMs. MSG uses a loophole in channel transmission laws to prevent them from being forced to provide it to FiOS.
--
This signature has consumed several bytes of your bandwidth.
guppy_fish
Premium
join:2003-12-09
Lakeland, FL
kudos:1
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS

Re: Wasted Bandwidth on VZ



MSG is a private company not owned by a cable company, so there is NO FCC rule that applies to whom they choose to sell to, just like every other sport franchise ( NFL , Hockey ect )

The Looppole is for when a cable company owns the content provider which CV use to own MSG, but no longer does
robjlevin

join:2002-10-30
Millington, NJ

Re: Wasted Bandwidth on VZ

Let's assume for a moment that you're correct.

What if Coca-Cola sold to Pathmark, Shop-Rite, and A&P but refused to sell to Acme? You can't decide who you get to sell to in an open market unless you choose to have one exclusive arrangement.

MSG and MSG+ HD channels can no longer be considered exclusives.

While you may be correct about the FCC not having a say anymore (and I'm not so sure you are), I believe that MSG now has less legal footing than they did before to deny any carrier the right to purchase the channels.

Greg2600

join:2008-05-20
Belleville, NJ

I think this is excellent.

Forces Verizon to pick up the pace and make the changes to get HD space available again.

runzero

join:2005-09-16
DC
Reviews:
·Verizon FiOS
·DSL EXTREME

Re: I think this is excellent.

They're already working on it. Insiders on the FiOS forum have said IPTV should be active by the end of the year and the Twitter rep (@FiOSTV) is being unusually... enthusiastic about "adding network capacity".
--
This signature has consumed several bytes of your bandwidth.

ja09

@rcn.com

waaaaay more

thats 30-50 more channels than rcn
Billy SI

join:2010-07-29
Staten Island, NY

Hello MSG HD , TWC Sept 14

TW Cable Back on Sept 14

runzero

join:2005-09-16
DC

Re: Hello MSG HD , TWC Sept 14

That's great, Billy. Just don't come crying back to Verizon when TWC doesn't give you the quality you expect.
--
This signature has consumed several bytes of your bandwidth.

anonymiss

@comcast.net

As long as..

The FCC makes all programming contracts non-exclusive this is fine.

Everyone should be able to buy the NFL Sunday ticket then?

Why have these bozos let that continue all this time?

It's un-american to pick and choose which exclusive contract gets to be legal and which does not.

Our government is a pathetic mess of payoffs and back door deal making.
robjlevin

join:2002-10-30
Millington, NJ

Re: As long as..

Exclusive is fine. MSG and MSG+ HD feeds are not exclusive. They're available on all cable systems and even on DirecTV.

Additionally, MSG and MSG+ are local interest channels. Sunday Ticket is an out of market package which causes no loss of programming to local markets.

Sunday, 03-Jun 21:03:00 Terms of Use & Privacy | feedback | contact | Hosting by nac.net - DSL,Hosting & Co-lo
over 12.5 years online © 1999-2012 dslreports.com.