dslreports logo
Search similar:


uniqs
2874

Willy
Premium Member
join:2000-09-24
USA

Willy

Premium Member

[Need] Looking for a good Chkdsk replacement?

I just went crazy trying to repair an error on my hard drive. I was doing a Ghost backup on a a partition on a NTFS drive, and encountered a disk error.

"Error Number: (29004)
Message: Read sector failure, result = 1, drive = 0, sectors 102739350 to 102739414"


No problem, I scheduled CHKDSK.EXE for the next startup and restarted. I got a couple of error messages and the "repairs" were made. I then ran the Western Digital utilities that came with the drive and found no problems but when I restarted Ghost the problem was back. I did the same thing with CHKDSK.EXE and the Western Digital utilities and had "no errors".

I then ran MSBackup on the drive and received in part this in the error log ..

WARNING: Portions of "\Belkin Bulldog Plus\2004\1.DAT" cannot be read. The backed up data is corrupt or incomplete.
This file will not restore correctly.
WARNING: Portions of "\Street Atlas USA 9.0\NodeIDs.dat" cannot be read. The backed up data is corrupt or incomplete.
This file will not restore correctly.


For a third time I ran the Western Digital utilities, (not CHKDSK.EXE this time), and finally it found and repaired the errors and I ran a good Ghost backup.

THE QUESTION!

Does anyone know of a good disk utility that find and fix basic disk problem to use in addition to, or in place of, CHKDSK.EXE?
Don't say Norton Utilities. Norton's Disk Doctor is just a front end for CHKDSK.EXE.

Thanks,
Willy

Candle12
Micro Developer
Premium Member
join:2003-03-24
19210

Candle12

Premium Member

You can force a full bad sector/recover operation with the /R option.
»www.microsoft.com/resour ··· kdsk.asp

Willy
Premium Member
join:2000-09-24
USA

Willy

Premium Member

said by Candle12:
You can force a full bad sector/recover operation with the /R option.
»www.microsoft.com/resour ··· kdsk.asp

The problem was Chkdsk didn't even see the error. Nothing there to repair as far as Chkdsk was concerned.

Comp Cmndo
join:2003-08-12
Palm Beach Gardens, FL

Comp Cmndo to Willy

Member

to Willy
Try "chkntfs": »support.microsoft.com/?k ··· d=160963

Ray
Mahnahmahna
Premium Member
join:2001-04-02
85120

Ray to Willy

Premium Member

to Willy
Check out SpinRite

Willy
Premium Member
join:2000-09-24
USA

Willy

Premium Member

said by Ray:
Check out SpinRite

Great idea. I don't know how I forgot about SpinRite. It's been around since before Windows.