dslreports logo
uniqs
5

pnh102
Reptiles Are Cuddly And Pretty
Premium Member
join:2002-05-02
Mount Airy, MD

pnh102 to bmn

Premium Member

to bmn

Re: Is it rehash Thursday ?

said by bmn:

The US GDP might be high right now, but beware... America's ability to outproduce may very well suffer in the future if the country's last mile networks stay at their current subpar level.
The main reason that I don't agree with this assessment is that there are many areas like inner cities, certain poor rural areas and the like which do have high speed Internet access but are still in the same wretched economic state that they were in prior to getting broadband.

Broadband is being sold as some sort of panacea for every little problem out there when it really isn't.
wtansill
Ncc1701
join:2000-10-10
Falls Church, VA

wtansill

Member

said by pnh102:
said by bmn:

The US GDP might be high right now, but beware... America's ability to outproduce may very well suffer in the future if the country's last mile networks stay at their current subpar level.
The main reason that I don't agree with this assessment is that there are many areas like inner cities, certain poor rural areas and the like which do have high speed Internet access but are still in the same wretched economic state that they were in prior to getting broadband.

Broadband is being sold as some sort of panacea for every little problem out there when it really isn't.
You are correct in that it is not a panacea. There is no "silver bullet" that will magically lift an area from abject poverty to Trumpian wealth overnight.

Having said that, broadband, I think, is fast becoming a precondition (along with transportation, good education, good government), that enables an area to begin to make the transition. A prerequisite, but as you note, not a guarantee of success.
bmn
? ? ?

join:2001-03-15
hiatus

bmn to pnh102

to pnh102
said by pnh102:

The main reason that I don't agree with this assessment is that there are many areas like inner cities, certain poor rural areas and the like which do have high speed Internet access but are still in the same wretched economic state that they were in prior to getting broadband.
Well, that's because you are only looking at broadband in relation to their economic state... You examination of how they are related is flawed. Broadband isn't going to lift people out of poverty by itself. So to say that the discoonect between wired areas and their economic state is some sort of proof that broadband doesn't have economic influence is fallacious.
Broadband is being sold as some sort of panacea for every little problem out there when it really isn't.
Indeed. But that doesn't change the fact that America's lagging position in the broadband world may very well hurt the economy.