dslreports logo
uniqs
14
« I will NEVER advocate stealing BUT
This is a sub-selection from hummm

kamm
join:2001-02-14
Brooklyn, NY

kamm to Kearnstd

Member

to Kearnstd

Re: hummm

said by Kearnstd:

the person making and distrobuting the copy is the pirate.
Right.
so the person you DL from is the pirate.
Right - you don't make it nor distribute it.
which is why the RIAA/MPAA go after these people, not to mention its alot harder to chase a downloader as most p2p aps dont keep IP logs.
Umm but they do go after the downloader.

Pirate515
Premium Member
join:2001-01-22
Brooklyn, NY

Pirate515

Premium Member

said by kamm:

Umm but they do go after the downloader.
WRONG. This is a typical comment made by someone who doesn't understand how protocols like eDonkey/BitTorent work. Once you download a chunk of file, it is automatically shared with other users on the network, even if the whole file hasn't finished downloading yet. So while you have your eDonkey/BitTorrent client running, you are also distributing what you are downloading to other users. And if it is a copyrighted work that you are sharing and RIAA/MPAA nails you, they will sue you for unauthorized distribution above anything else. As far as they are concerned, they are the only ones who have the rights to distribute their music/movies, and if anyone else is caught doing it without their permission, they need to be punished.

FYI, you are pretty safe from getting if you stick to download-only kinds of services such as newsgroups.

kamm
join:2001-02-14
Brooklyn, NY

kamm

Member

said by Pirate515:

said by kamm:

Umm but they do go after the downloader.
WRONG. This is a typical comment made by someone who doesn't understand how protocols like eDonkey/BitTorent work. Once you download a chunk of file, it is automatically shared with other users on the network, even if the whole file hasn't finished downloading yet. So while you have your eDonkey/BitTorrent client running, you are also distributing what you are downloading to other users. And if it is a copyrighted work that you are sharing and RIAA/MPAA nails you, they will sue you for unauthorized distribution above anything else. As far as they are concerned, they are the only ones who have the rights to distribute their music/movies, and if anyone else is caught doing it without their permission, they need to be punished.

FYI, you are pretty safe from getting if you stick to download-only kinds of services such as newsgroups.
COngrat that you finally understood how p2p works - but what are you preaching here, I dunno... it has nothing to do with my comment.

PS: Geez, if you're an age-old usenet user - I've used usenet before internet kicked in - like me then few things can be more sarcastic and/or funny when some young enthusiastic 'expert' fella thinks he can explain p2p or file sharing or usenet for you...

Karl Bode
News Guy
join:2000-03-02

Karl Bode

News Guy

Having seen this discussion about a million times at this point I've concluded there's a semantic club that wanders the vast Interwebs simply pointing out the difference between stating someone is getting busted for downloading versus getting busted for sharing....

The rest of the discussion can make no sense provided they step in to clarify that point.
« I will NEVER advocate stealing BUT
This is a sub-selection from hummm